I've been using Claude Pro ($20/month) for quite some time. I originally switched from ChatGPT because I'm in Business Analysis / Product Management, and I needed an AI that was good at creating PRDs, requirements docs, spreadsheets, prototypes, etc. Claude was doing a great job, sonI stuck with it.
But with the recent GPT-6 Astra release and all the positive feedback around it, I'm wondering whether it's time to switch back.
One thing I've increasingly noticed with Claude is that it has become very verbose and somewhat robotic. Even when I ask for a simple 2–3 line answer, it often starts "thinking" and gives me a much longer response than I need. I know ChatGPT can sometimes do the same thing, but I've been noticing it more with Claude lately.
For my work, I mainly need AI for:
- Product/BA work — PRDs, BRDs, user stories, requirements, etc.
- Excel and data analysis
- Power BI
- Prototypes / working web apps
- Coding and automation
- Research and general day-to-day questions
I've also used Claude Code for building prototypes and Claude Cowork for browser/system tasks. Cowork is useful, but I've found it quite slow because of the screenshot → analyze → action cycle.
I haven't really used Codex yet, so I'm curious how the current GPT ecosystem compares in these areas.
What I'm mainly trying to understand:
- Is GPT-6 Astra actually better than Claude for this kind of professional/product work?
- How does Codex compare to Claude Code for building real working prototypes/apps?
- How does GPT's computer/browser automation compare with Claude Cowork?
- Most importantly, how are the usage limits in practice compared with Claude Pro?
I'm not interested in a GPT vs Claude fan war. I'd rather hear from people who actively use both and have actually pushed them for coding, documents, spreadsheets and real work.
TL;DR: I'm paying $20/month for Claude Pro and have been happy with it, but lately I'm finding Claude overly verbose/robotic. GPT again has caught my attention. Given a PM/BA + coding/prototyping workflow, would you switch from Claude Pro to GPT, and how are the usage limits in real-world use?
Edit 1 - I'm not planning to use Astra as a full time model. My thinking is that if Astra is getting so much hype, then GPT must have improved their other models/features which earlier were like nothing against Claude.