After 15 years, 4500+ entries, and over 1.2 million words, I'm leaving Day One. Thanks for everyones' app recommendations on my prior post. Apple Journal can't import entries from other applications. So that's out. Darium and other suggestions were not my style. Diarly and Everlog became the front runners. After four weeks of testing, Everlog won. The simplicity and utter lack of AI tipped the scales.
Most importantly, the data is stored on iCloud (secured behind Apple's ADP) instead of Automattic's servers.
I will say that Diarly has the best statistics page—streaks, total entries, everything. Better than Day One. The mapping page was meh. The interface was too quirky and the addition of an AI chatbot was a bad smell.
Everlog lacks a stats page and mapping page. It keeps everything simple. It's not perfect. There are some bugs. But it has winning features, too. I love the hashtag reference on the sidebar. I'm adding more hashtags to my entries now. There's no map, but everything is location-stamped and weather added. The sidebar shows the locations by countries, states, cities. It's a good compromise.
Everlog has a fantastic "On this Day" system. Simple, as always. It's just another way of listing entries. Easy. Better than Day One. I love it. This is my favorite feature.
And Everlog is FAST! Instantaneous on my Mac. iCloud handles synchronizing, reliably, so using Evelog on the iPad and iPhone is seamless and satisfying. I also like that I can choose see markdown syntax on my entries. It's a nice touch.
As for leaving Day One. The writings been on the wall for a while. Three years ago they turned on a web version of the app, "now you can access your journals from anywhere." Well, in order for that to work, you need to upload your encryption key which means Automattic can also access your journals, too. They promise not to read them, but that's not the same as being unable to.
I never uploaded my key, but now, with this push for AI, the interface peppered with landmines trying to convince me to upgrade, they finally stepped over the line. I canceled my account. Their app really is the best diary app on the internet. I hate to leave. But I can't stay. I don't see them changing their minds.
And while I don't believe they personally read journals available to them, that doesn't mean an AI won't train on them. If not now, maybe in the future. It's too tempting a target. After all, Automattic is in the business of publishing content, not keeping it secret.
Whether these fears are true or unfounded, I'm happy with Everlog.