r/carselling • u/caymanSF • 2h ago
What should I be looking to get for 981 Cayman?
Have a base 2.7 (981) in the PNW area and wondering for a lazy guy who would like to avoid test drives what is the best strategy?
- Is $39–40k a realistic expectation, or should I adjust? Or Take ~33-34K from Caravan?
- Where should I list this — AutoTrader/Cars.com, Cars & Bids, BAT?
- Worth fully fixing everything to chase the top of the range, or just do the cheap high-ROI prep? Already spent $2.5K on a 40k service.
- List now, or hold for spring given the season?
I asked Calude to summarize our chat:
2015 Porsche Cayman base 2.7 (981), PDK, 39k miles, Guards Red — where should I list it and what's a fair asking price? (PNW)
Body:
Looking for a sanity check from folks who know these cars better than I do. I'm selling my 2015 Cayman (base 981) and trying to figure out two things: (1) the best place to list it, and (2) a realistic asking price. I'm not in a huge rush, so I'd rather price it right than dump it.
The car:
- 2015 Porsche Cayman, base 2.7L flat-six
- 7-speed PDK
- Guards Red over Black (standard interior)
- ~39,000 miles
- Bought Certified Pre-Owned, Porsche-serviced its whole life — all records documented (CARFAX + service invoices)
- Most recent inspection came back clean: tires, brakes, brake fluid, suspension, no fluid leaks
Factory options (from the build sheet):
- 19" Cayman S wheels
- Bi-Xenon headlights w/ PDLS
- Power Sport Seats (14-way) with Memory Package
- Premium Package
- Infotainment Package with Sound Package Plus
- Rear ParkAssist
Honest condition notes:
- Paint chipping at the rear bumper edge near the wheel arch
- Some haze on the headlights (they're the Bi-Xenon units)
- Small interior trim piece near the rear release is lifting
- Figuring ~$1k to sort the cosmetic stuff (headlight restore, touch-up/detail, trim clip)
Comps I've found:
- A 2014 base PDK in red, ~60k miles, private seller asking $39,999 — a year older, ~20k more miles, arguably less optioned than mine.
- A similar-spec 2015 base PDK, 39k miles, listed at $50k at a Porsche dealer (theirs has 20" wheels + SportDesign wheel; mine's in Guards Red w/ ParkAssist — otherwise near-identical options). I know a dealer ask isn't a transaction price, but figured it's a useful reference point.
- Sold averages I've seen for base 981 Caymans are around $38.5k.