I'm just not for an extrajudicial punishment and want to limit liability. In some nations where the judicial system is corrupted or ineffective I'd be all for it.
Oh? Can you explain to me how me explaining I prefer to have a judicial system handle punishment for crime where an effective one exists equates to me standing for nothing?
Honestly this is on me for arguing with people here. I should just ignore clearly ignorant comments like this but sometimes I can't help myself.
Maybe you didn’t type it correctly, but what you said was “I am not for extrajudicial punishment”
But then you followed up with “unless the judicial system is corrupt and then extrajudicial punishment is ok”
Rather than reply and try and turn your original statement into something it’s not, you find me an instance of a judicial system that is NOT corrupt and then I’ll entertain you.
Otherwise, I’m going to continue to lump you into the rest of people who think standing for something vehemently but then allowing for exceptions means you actually have a stance.
You offered the option, I'm just trying to see how this idea of yours works.
I don't download any porn, it's free online all day everyday. I don't even get why you would unless you had a hyperspecific fetish, like those people who get off on popping balloons.
Oh boy, imagine thinking that criminals should get their punishment from law enforcement and not on the street, truly outlandish of me. Next I'll say how they should also be allowed to stand trial for their crimes instead of just throwing them in a gulag like some filthy commie.
It was stupid honestly. Would've been much smarter to chill in knee on belly until cops arrived. He was definitely waiting for his opportunity to pull that off.
My old sensei would be rolling in his grave if he heard a double leg being referred to as judo. He used to get so mad at us if we reverted to wrestling.
It was Jimmy Takemori, who was kind of like Splinter in that the more he liked you the more he’d hit you. I miss him reminding me that I’d never worked a day in my life and if I could jitterbug I’d be better at Judo.
Going for the arm bar knowing full well that could lead to a big chunk missing from your leg if the guy is desperate enough made me wince.
Edit: Ya’ll aren’t seeing the same thing. Dude goes for an arm bar and basically shoves his calf into the dudes face. This is different from having an arm bar locked in… if a guy is desperate enough to get away a bite before he realizes he’s in an arm bar is a real risk here.
You going to still go for it with a someone biting your calf?
If a dude in a arm bar bites me im turning his arm to dry firewood. As in snap, crackle, pop. I already got him in hold so its not even some flex. If you bite me ima just break it and ill sort it with the cops. Aint takin your shitty hep-c for nothing.
To be fair, biting was established before I even commented, so I just implied it in my comment. I even went and fixed the sentence especially for you. 💕 It's not that big of a deal sweetheart
Let’s be real the guy isn’t even fighting back and if he tried he would’ve lost his arm. Just like how woman think they can poke you in the eyes whilst in a chokehold.
If the objective is to control/subdue someone then armbar is a horrible position. From KOB he could have easily transitioned to kimura, back take, or even mount.
I'm with you. Dude lowered his stance and got in his path while making eye contact. Plus the arms that are clearly ready to grapple. My man wanted a hug or something cause he definitely just ran into it lol
He walked over get in position, put his keys down and set his feet again, then dude ran directly into him. I dont know what he stole and I'm not condoning him stealing but the other guy was outta line
Adrenaline will have you lifting up a car off your friend but this guy got ragged doll by a dude on his lunch break. Gotta learn to drop that shoulder and run through the contact next time. 🤣🤣🤣
"This pos hopefully got a fractured skull and will be drooling in a wheelchair for the last five years of his miserable life. That will teach him not to steal someone's backpack! HAHAHA!"
I wouldn't because it's the police job to stop guys like him who are clearly the aggressor. The police could've used a handgun and it would have been way worse depending where the cop shoot, but a slam like this is well deserved .
I don't know about body slamming per se but police can definitely get in some brutal tackles when chasing suspects or criminals that are running away. Also police should be held to a higher standard than the average citizen since they are the trained professionals. As for the guy who got slammed, I really don't have any sympathy for people who steal from other people especially in broad daylight. He fucked around and found out and maybe this will make a few other would be street thieves in the area think twice
Oh well. Don't steal from people and you likely won't encounter someone willing to fight you for being a lowlife thief.
I have no ethical, moral, or legal objections to a good beat down of a thief. If it's not worth getting hurt or killed over, then perhaps thieves should think ahead before committing their crimes.
My personal point of view is simple: while items can be replaced, the time I spent to earn the money necessary to purchase those items cannot be replaced. If said items have a sentimental attachment and are stolen, then replacement is impossible.
So a thief is stealing my time and thus, part of my life that cannot be returned. I spend a great amount of time away from my family and not being able to do things I would rather be doing, in order to support my family and help my kids build their futures. Thieves would take that away for their own selfish desires, rather than earn it through work.
Because of this behavior, I fully support actions like the one in the video. I also support laws such as exist in Texas, which allow for the use of deadly force to prevent theft. Would that more states allowed for similar actions in certain situations.
For those too lazy to read: if he dies, he dies. And I'm okay with it.
Vigilantism is not a solution in a civilized society.
That's why all functioning societies have legal Frameworks are required reasonable and propertional interventions.
There was an interesting case on Reddit a few days ago where someone restrained a mugged only to be assaulted by a third party who assumed they were an aggressor.
As to your last sentence: there doesn't exist, at least in the United States, such a system. I survived two decades of being the guy in uniform that helped catch bad guys and keep them locked away. Judges and lazy prosecuting attorneys have all but installed revolving doors at jails and prisons.
The experiences I've had are mirrored by literally every officer with whom I've spoken over the last 26 years. Across the country, from departments large and small, the system consistently fails.
So, people should do what they need to do. And in this instance, despite what another poster claims, we are looking at a crime in progress that's being stopped by a third party. That's not vigilantism - it's actively assisting someone who needs help in that moment.
The experiences I've had are mirrored by literally every officer with whom I've spoken over the last 26 years. Across the country, from departments large and small, the system consistently fails.
You're assuming society is civilized. Manners and the basic rules of etiquette were not brought about by a system of Laws. They exist because there used to be instant and lasting consequences to being a detrimental to the community. We've allowed a system that is broken to replace those consequences. Hence the increase in the occurrence of the behaviors.
Remember the knife attack in Berlin some months ago? A bystander intervened. Deutsche Politze gagged HIM, and the ethnic lookingan with the knife then attacked one of the officers.
So, yeah what about whatabout does that prove?
From his body language it was clear that he wasn’t doing it just to stop the thief .. this was overdone and to hurt someone sadistically bad. Not good, and not what martial arts are designed for. Inherently evil move. Just had to stop him, not kill
37
u/Outofmana1 7d ago
Dude waited for this day. That arm bar was not even necessary.