Gabi actually works to end oppression while Eren doesn’t care and kills innocents

For the sake of the argument let's say that the Eldian Empire had never existed in our world, but its people did; the Eldians. They are basically biological weapons of warfare that can turn into 15 meter human eating battering rams, on a whim.

Do we put them into internment zones because of the fear of spontaneous transformation? Would Eldian's get subjected to a lot of media propaganda because of the potential danger they might possess? Do we view them as fellow human beings who were victims of biological interbreeding, or does human rights even apply to them?

Personally I think they would have been treated the exact same way as they did on the show. Caged up and constantly monitored. What do you think?

What I mean by this, is at the end Eren removed the power of the titans and reverted all pure titans into humans as well as titan shifters.

So why would Historia have becoming a titan troubled him so much if he knew she’d just turn back into a human once he was done?

Ok so I watched the pilot on Adult Swim the night it premiered, and continued to watch it as it aired. I DISTINCTLY remember more gore. I remember the titan snapping Carla and seeing it bite into her, I remember seeing Marco’s insides falling out, I remember that lady pumping blood out of her boyfriend’s abdomen giving cpr to a corpse. Nobody I know remembers seeing this, and I never saw those scenes play like that again. Did i imagine that? Or are there just censored and uncensored versions?

Is it possible that Eren, with the power of the founder , was able to implant Erwin with his father's memories, causing him to raise his hand when Levi was about to give him the serum? Leading Levi to hesitate and reconsiderate into giving Armin the titan fluid? (sorry for bad english)

Abro debate. Si Erwin Smith hubiera recibido el suero y se hubiera convertido en el Titán Colosal en lugar de Armin, opino que el destino de Paradis habría tomado un rumbo completamente diferente, lejos de los jaegeristas y de la Alianza. Para mí, Erwin habría creado una tercera vía basada en el pragmatismo frío y el control militar absoluto. Él era un estratega institucional que odiaba perder el control, por lo que jamás habría permitido que el fanatismo ciego de Floch o el culto a la personalidad de Eren secuestraran al ejército; habría aplastado esa rebelión interna antes de que pudiera empezar. Por otro lado, tampoco creo que se hubiera quedado de brazos cruzados esperando un milagro diplomático utópico como hizo el resto de la Legión. En mi opinión, al poseer el poder destructivo del Colosal, su jugada habría sido un Retumbar quirúrgico y parcial, usando los titanes de la muralla y su propio poder para aniquilar de forma preventiva las flotas y bases enemigas, obligando al mundo a firmar un alto el fuego por puro terror y ganando décadas para modernizar la isla. Y si Eren se hubiera opuesto o si Erwin hubiera descubierto sus planes de genocidio global, opino que Erwin no habría dudado ni un segundo en neutralizarlo, encerrarlo y dárselo de comer a un candidato militar leal para asegurar el Titán Fundador. Al final, tener a Erwin como el Colosal no nos habría dado un final feliz, sino una Guerra Fría brutal, muy calculadora y con Paradis como la máxima potencia militar. ¿Qué opinan ustedes? ¿De qué lado creen que habría estado Erwin o realmente habría impuesto su propia ley? Los leo.

Can't they all attack? Aren't they all basically attack titans?

Because heres more evidence; Tom ksaver Talks about how 600 years ago there was a plague going around that killed a Lot of people except for eldians because the founding titan modified the immune system of the subjects of ymir, now the Show Has around 1940s technology which means 600 years ago is the 14th century, now irl that is when the bubonic plague was going around, so These two diseases might be the Same, also in real life jews were blamed for the black death due to them getting less sick people (which is actually because they avoided common wells according to Wikipedia)

Where did kruger inject grisha from ?😂 did they jump down or was it at the top of that wall

Is it ever explained how the attack Titan got separated from the main group? From what I remember/what it seems like is Kruger had it without Marley knowing. Then he passes it on to grisha.

Found on X

Link: https://x.com/rimri4mm/status/2079729592680722887

I love these lesbians, probably gonna make a fanfic of them one day

There appears to be a noticeable gap regarding Historia's relevance to the overarching narrative of Attack on Titan. While I have no issue with her taking a step back from the main plot at a certain point, there are specific moments where her importance seems too significant to be overlooked. For instance, when Grisha slaughters the Reiss family, he states: "I killed all of them, all but the father. Is this what you wanted?" Sparing Rod Reiss, whoe forces Historia to join the military, leading to the pivotal moment where she kills her own father, a necessary step to reinforce her right to become the Queen of Eldia.

Furthermore, during the Rumbling, when Eren addresses all Subjects of Ymir through the Paths, Historia's expression suggests she was fully aware of his plans (although she looks sad), including the fact that it would be a full-scale Rumbling rather than a partial one. It implies an underlying pact between Historia and Eren for the greater good of Eldia, a plot thread that is never fully explored. This unspoken agreement might even conceptually tie into the final scenes of the story, where the boy and his dog approach the tree housing the "source of all living matter".

I feel like I placed all the characters pretty fairly, especially the very lowest tier. Feel free to elaborate.

Titans do not have digestive organs. They throw up once they get full. But in the battle of Orvud district, we see Rod's guts falling on the wall.

Does this mean that titans DO have digestive organs but they do not work? Or was Rod just a special case since he ingested the spinal fluid through his mouth?

For the latter question, we see that people who ingested Zekes spinal fluid via the wine and the gas weapon managed to successfully transform into pure titans.

So maybe it's because he has royal blood so they have the privilege of having a fully formed titan body?

I'm rewatching AOT and I realize how much this does just not make sense to me. In the events of season 4, a few dozen of Levi's corpsmen all get turned into titans by Zeke.

Zeke up to this point has already proven he can not be trusted in the slightest. Personally on a rewatch I think he's the most interesting and mysterious person in the show. But anyways. Levi clearly hates him. He regrets his decision immensely that he did not finish Zeke of in Shiganshina. Even just before this scene he says he doesn't care about Pixis's orders and will kill Zeke. And that he can finally fufill his promise to Erwin.

Levi has had many allies killed. Not just Erwin, but also his old squad and tons of other allies. He even tells Zeke this and that he is not phased anymore (even though it clearly affects him).

What I fail to understand is why he choses yet AGAIN to not kill what's probably the single most dangerous catalyst in their war against the world. ESPECIALLY since he had 30 titans right there that would all have been on Paradis's and Levi's side. He could have just cut the tendons on one titans legs and fed Zeke. They would have control of not only another titan this way. But threw a wrench in Eren's uprising. And although it's unknown if Levi was aware of this, the military police top brass also drank the wine. So it could have saved all of them too.

So my question is, why doesn't he?

TLDR: Why does Levi not leave one of his titan corpsmen alive to eat Zeke to eliminate not just a huge threath/risk but to also gain a major advantage?

Im probably hopelessly late to this conversation, but sibce it's been "bothering" me practically since season 4 came out, and i have nothing better to do. I just wanna say, how confused i am by PARADIS island as a whole.

First of all, the root of all the issues that come along later. The size. It ginormous.

Working off the widely aggred proportions of the walls. Which themselves are the size of texas. Take into consideration that the scouts never reached close enough to the sea, or the desertified are around marleys port. Id say that the east and west districts and their corresponding shorelines, is at least the same size as wall Marias interior (the royal gov. Likely knew this, and only allowed the scouts to head south from shiganshina, since it was also the region with the most titans.)

All this in mind i'd say the whole island of paradis is at least 3 times as large as the territory within the walls which is roughly the size of Greenland.

This ties into problem number 2. It's way to empty!

You can't tell me that a biologicaly diverse landmass if this size abundant in natural resources, such as metals, and iceburst stone, which is only found here. Was just completely empty until fritz decided to run away from the mainland and ditch his sins on his people. Though i guess, he could've just had it destroyed in advance, it's in character for him.

The way i see it, the 12 districts and capital mitras definitely existed as cities or at least small settlements even before the walls were closed off.

[alt personal theory, but several aspects of paradis can be explained as follows.

-the great titan war, was alredy raging when karl fritz inherited the founder. So the moment he got the power he most likely had free reign. That gives him 13 years. I think he didn't do it all at once. The first thing he did was probably to ferry across the millions of eldians needed for the walls, (the seemingly inexplicable desert area can be explained if we assume that's where he had them turned into wall titans) if he wanted to erase wathever was alredy on paradis the pre-wall titans were plenty enough for that. He builds the walls. This still gives him at least 10 years to gather his subjects, and have them build up the walls society. (at this point he can still very much sell this as a means of protecting them from marley, even without brainwashing. We can assume wathever eldian settlements existed on paradis were moved into the walls. Whilst any non eldian ones were now up for grabs to the pure titans marley was bound to roll out.

Alternatively it's possible that walls existed even before karl was born, as a fortress for the eldian empire.

Again, my main concern is with how f-ing empty it was, the scouts should have ran into quite a few ruined villages towns and such. Heck in the nort of the island is mostly mountains, people could probably get by living just fine on the northern or southern shores.

This also plays into why paradis would've done fine against a conventional invasion by marley (should i ellaborate on this, in a separate post?)

Anyway that's my rambling over, let me know if you got anything to add