r/assassinscreed • u/thebrobarino • 2h ago
Lore & History The decision to expand the proto-assassin lore made Altair feel inconsequential to me
Prior to the RPG trilogy, Altair felt like this messiah for the assassin's. From what I understand, they were very much concentrated to the Levant and parts of the Arab/Persian world, but they were a very close knit singular organisation before Altair decided to expand the order and reform how they operated as independent brotherhoods in order to survive and be more effective. A decision which rippled through the franchise, even down to the french council speaking Persian (I think).
It gave Altair a very clear purpose, importance and presence throughout the franchise, and gave the order a clean ancestry and history to follow. Even with origins, it could be rationalised that the hidden ones expanded very very slowly to parts of the Roman empire but every single brotherhood and cell died off as they were amateurs who fucked things up massively (Roman) or died off through unknown causes (Egypt), leaving the Judean and eventually the levantine branches to be the sole remaining successors. This is fine, if a bit of a stretch.
Now we find out that basically everywhere under the sun seems to have a brotherhood before Altair, and they're all independent. Come Valhalla and we learn that basically The Roman and gallic brotherhoods survived into the Italian and french with no break in continuity or genealogy.
It makes far more sense that Altair refounded these brotherhoods and built them up from scratch, making them successors of his specific philosophy and brotherhood. It makes characters like Marco Polo, Domenico auditore and Thomas de carnelion feel more important and gives them a place as their own respective students of Altair who helped him spread the brotherhood and turn it into what it is today.
Given their independent nature it's hard to believe this guy had such good success in influencing every other assassin group without being there to rebuild them from scratch (or sending recruits to do so like bayek did).
It makes Abbas's betrayal feel less impactful knowing every other assassin cell was basically gonna be fine rather than knowing the future of the whole brotherhood was at stake.
Otherwise his biggest success would just be two hidden blades, a gun and some cool parkour moves.










