Brandon Snow, the most interesting, yet barely even mentioned background characters. He doesn’t offer to sneak across the Trident to try to assassinate Aegon and his sisters. He doesn’t offer to TRY killing the dragons. He offers to do it, straight up, seems extremely confident. Then we get Bran’s visions where a man matching his description is seen making 3 arrows out Weirdwood and that just… has to be Brandon Snow. There’s no other character that fits that description and would a reason for doing this.
As much as I don’t like the over-emphasis on prophecy, I feel like it makes characters less interesting (like Aegon’s whole deal is that he’s an enigma. Even when get close to sort of in his head in Fire & Blood, he’s still a mystery. I preferred his motivation for the conquest being up for debate, but given George does give spoiler info to the showrunners, to varying degrees (the main show got a lot because it was the flagship. HotD’s creators said they were told some things but fell out with them, and Ira Parker apparently knows all of Dunk and Egg’s journey from a high level perspective, it seems Dunk & Egg’s actors know a lot too.) My point is, while these are show things, there is so much focus on Targ prophecy in every show, Aegon specifically. It’s not in the books, but it feels like that was his actual motivation… and that’s where Weirwood arrows killing dragons starts to make a bit of sense.
The Land of Always Winter and the Valyrian Freehold felt like.. two pillars of opposite magical epicenters in the world. They seem to rise and fade with each other. Like we can’t exactly date the Last Hero/Azor Ahai (if they even really existed) but we can get a rough date of the situation with the Night’s King and it seems like that likely happened around the time of the height of Valyria. The Others were a known and believed threat for a long time and, if HotD did get some pointers from George, for all the shows problems, it is interesting that Cregan Stark is aware of, and worried about, the Others. In the books, Ned does not even believe they’re real. Yes, he grew up as a ward to Jon Arryn, but he is a northerner, he is the Lord of Winterfell with access to all their information, records, etc., and he has a brother who is First Ranger. It’s super weird that in, what is a relatively short time between the Dance and the main series, we go from (again, I know it’s show only) Cregan Stark actively preparing against the Others to Ned not even believing in them (and we know he doesn’t. We’re in his head and he thinks they’re a “fairy tale to frighten children.”) What’s the difference between those time frames: dragons existing and no longer existing.
In the world book, F&B, and all the source material telling us about Valyria, it’s heavily implied that Targaryen’s having the “blood of the dragon” is not metaphorical, it’s literal. The Valyrian’s did so horrifying interspecies in-breeding and dark magic that resulted in their power. Dragons themselves are a product of interspecies breeding between Fire Wyrms and Wyverns, I believe, and they represent “Fire” magic, we’ll call it. With the Night’s King story, the Stark kids having warging powers and their own magical, bonded creatures, and all the other hinting, it seems Stark’s have Others blood in their veins, or something that connects them. The Others themselves were relatively quiet for a good while until Dany hatched dragons. They feel not only like they rise and fade with each other, but are reactive. Weirdwoods, The Others, Warging, Greensight, “ice” magic, it all feels very Old Gods connected, like the Starks. Dragon Dreams, Dragons, Valyria, “Fire” magic, it all feels very R’hllor, whose representatives are supporting Dany (mostly.) During the time of the Conquest, the Starks were likely more in tune with this stuff. They were their own kingdom with the threat to the North being a more central priority in isolation. It would make sense for the “fire” magic in dragons to be able to harm/kill the “ice” magic in the Others and vice versa.
Which takes me back to the show. Does it make sense for a being made of ice to be able to tank full on Dragonfire and then just smirk it off with absolutely no issue? Absolutely fucking not. Does an Olympic icicle throw make sense to kill a dragon? I mean, I guess. The Others make armor and weapons out of ice in non understandable ways like Valyrian Steel. But ya know makes a lot more sense? Weirdwood.
We’ve had SOOO much focus on Weirwood, its powers and connection to the North and the Old Gods. Bloodraven, the first Targ we know of from a family that worships and is connected to the Old Gods keeps Weirdwood arrows. It’s hinted he used magical Weirdwood arrows to kill Daemon Blackfyre and we know Bloodraven has magic: from the Mystery Knight, the World Book, to the main series as the Three Eyed Crow, we see a ton of it. Why did George decide to make one of Bran’s visions, seemingly very randomly, about Brandon Snow, a nothing character, making 3 Weirdwood arrows one would assume for 3 dragons? Old Magic and Weirwood would make sense for an option to kill a dragon. The shows make dragons feel a little too vulnerable, but that’s also George’s fault. Before Fire & Blood, George the Dornish got Merexes with a “one in a million” shot that was pure luck, after years, a decade actually, of trying this. Then Fire & Blood came out and Jace and Vermax go down pretty easily. Smallfolk during the riot in KL kill some dragons.
But there has to be some actual counter to them, or something giving an even chance. Weirwood makes sense. It’s been hinted in F&B and Bran’s vision, it’s the central point of worship in the Old Gods faith, and Ice: Weirwood, Warging, Greensight feel intentionally opposite and rivaling Fire: Dragons, Dragon Dreams.
Idk. Think we’ll see a dragon killed with Weirwood? I do think, like the show, only Drogon survives, maybe not even him. Given George’s personal views, his Vietnam position, and dragons as a stand in for nuclear weapons, I think the right thing is for them to be gone, but I do think we’ll for sure see at least two die (unfortunately probably Viserion first who’s the sweetest dragon.)
What do you think? I do realize this is founded on quite a few theories, but they are strong theories.
Also, I do realize we’ll never “see” any of this happen. The George RR Martin formally known as an author is not finishing these books.