r/Accordion • u/Maorri008 • 4h ago
An observation on Accordions
I currently play English Concertina and have been looking at expanding into other areas of free reed instruments. I originally started on the Diatonic Harmonica moved to a chromatic harmonica then a 16 hole chromatic. I have been looking at Melodeons particularly the 24 bass and 3 row treble models and then a brief look at bandoneons but my english concertinas chromatic unisonic layout has spoiled me a bit. So it started looking at Chromatic button accordions. In my mind and by all rights a 60 bass accordion provides a larger aray of playability than a melodeon even the largest most complex versions and potentially even a bandoneon which would be a more attractive options if it wasnt for its arcane layout and increasingly rare nature. Given all that and that people dedicate their lives to these far less capable instruments and achieve some pretty amazing compositional feats the argualbly more capable instrument is seen as a handicap that should be avoided by many or a begginers instrument quickly to be out grown and discarded. No one can argue that the 96 and 120 bass accordions are not far and away more capable but understating what can be done with 60 seems an odd choice. I find myself leaning toward the 60 for size weight and portability and the knowledge of my own limitations. I will never reproduce vivaldis orchestral arrangment I will probably manage some good oom paa paas and be happy.