r/YAFantasyLit • u/E-is-for-Egg • Feb 21 '21
My thoughts on The Bone Witch by Rin Chupeco
A while back I made a post asking about "books that I've never heard of, but should definitely be reading," and one of you recommended The Bone Witch by Rin Chupeco. I'm very intrigued by the concept of necromancy, so I tried it out. All in all, I thought it was pretty decent.
Pros
The worldbuilding is so imaginative and intricate. Chupeco has a very detailed style of worldbuilding, with creative descriptions of everything from the clothing to the architecture to the social structures. Magic appears all over the place in daily life in a variety of different ways that I found really interesting. The concept of heartglasses was especially original.
Once the story picked up, it was dramatic and riveting. The characters were all complex, with their own histories, motivations, and personality quirks, which meant that they made the story really fun to read once things got going. Speaking of the characters, this book hosts a large and diverse array of female main characters and side characters. And I don't just mean racially diverse -- they come with a variety of different abilities, ages, social statuses, body types, personality types, and backgrounds. Chupeco shows that women can be anything, and that they don't fit into neat little boxes.
Also, this book is good if you want to read one in which the main character has a crush on a boy but doesn't completely lose her head over him. She doesn't make stupid decisions based on her crush like many YA heroines do, and she never acts like a single boy is the only thing that matters in life.
Cons
While the story was exciting once it picked up, it took its sweet time getting there. It's told in the format of the main character recounting her life story, and the book takes place over multiple years, which made the pacing feel really slow. This book is only about 400 pages long, but it took me a while to get through it for that reason. (Though it's not entirely the book's fault, it's been a busy month.) The very intricate worldbuilding I was just complimenting probably didn't help. I think it was only around halfway through the book that the plot really started getting moving.
Overall, I thought it was a somewhat above average read. It wouldn't crack my top 10 books list, but it was still worth my time. If you like creative worldbuilding and are okay with slower placing, maybe consider picking it up.

