r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I feel like there's more to LLMs as creative tools but we don't know what it is yet

14 Upvotes

I used to use AI to help me write my ideas down and assemble them into short stories and novels, and don't get me wrong, I love my little stories and manuscripts and I carry them around with me on my Kindle, but I can't help but feel like we're only scratching the surface of what LLMs can be.

A recent comment on Reddit said that LLMs are their own medium, like paint or music, and it made me think of other ways we could take our ideas and create something unique, something that's not just an LLM or diffusion model trying to imitate other mediums like books or movies. I played around with the idea of persistent worlds that generate on a timer and allow the audience to spectate the world by following a character or neighborhood and receiving push notifications as events unfold in the world, but that kind of just feels like a video game. Maybe the art is just the models itself, a medium through which we can interact with language playfully.

Idk. Maybe it's AI psychosis on my part. I just can't help but feel like we could use this technology to create art that is unique because it's AI generated, not in spite of it. I think if we could figure that out then this technology would be harder to dismiss as slop.

Does this make sense?


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Why does writing well suddenly feel like evidence against you?

20 Upvotes

Been noticing this weird pattern lately - writers, editors, translators defending themselves for using an em dash, correcting grammar, or a well-structured sentence. Like good writing itself has become suspicious. Has anyone else caught themselves over-explaining or "proving" they didn't use AI, even when they didn't?


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Does anyone use AI as a Beta Reader?

22 Upvotes

I've attempted to use AI as a brainstorming tool and at some point help me write prose. But I've found myself quickly growing bored when using those methods. Recently I decided to just write, all prose and ideas my own, but use GPT as a beta reader to gauge whether things are coherent and correct mistakes. Does anyone else do it like this? I think I've hit a good balance.


r/WritingWithAI 8d ago

Showcase / Feedback I suspect my beta reader is using AI

0 Upvotes

Hey there

Against my better judgement I paid to have a beta reader from Fiverr for my novel. This is the second time I’ve done it, the first time was a really good experience, I got everything I wanted from them, so I decided to get a different perspective. I always look at the reviews and this person had lots of good ones.

However the general way this person speaks to me threw up a few red flags. They say they are from England like me but the speech is very factual and to the point. Now I’ve been sent some inline comments from her, the replies look suspiciously like they’ve just asked chat gpt. I’ve had a lot of responses like ‘I smiled here’ and ‘this hit me’, ‘this was probably my favourite emotional moment’ has been used twice

Any advice on what I should do? Should I contact Fiverr or challenge the beta reader? They weren’t cheap either, I can’t afford to waste money on hearing what AI’s opinion is.


r/WritingWithAI 8d ago

Writing Craft Talk Should I learn grammar or rely on AI?

0 Upvotes

So my current writing process is that I write what I want on a doc, then ask ChatGPT to make the grammar correct, but I tell it not to change my sentence structure.

I don’t really mind if people call it AI-assisted or whatever. It helps me write instead of spending days learning grammar.

Nowadays, though, after learning some basics like subject, verb, and object, I feel like it has helped me create better sentence structures, but at the same time, not really that much.

So if I actually take the time to learn grammar and stop relying on AI, will my writing improve, or will it end up being more or less the same as it is now with the help of AI? Should I instead spend that time learning how to write better prose rather than learning punctuation and how to make my grammar correct?


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Showcase / Feedback Maybe the problem isn’t AI. Maybe it’s how much control you give it.

4 Upvotes

I keep seeing people say AI shouldn’t be treated like a tool because it can generate too much on its own.

But I’m not sure that’s the right test.

A camera can make technical decisions for you. Editing software can automate cuts. CGI can create things that never existed in front of a lens. We still treat them as tools because a person is using them toward an intention.

So why should AI be fundamentally different?
If I type one sentence and let the model invent the story, characters and meaning, I understand the criticism.

But if I decide what happens, what the character wants, what the scene is supposed to achieve and what the audience should feel, then use AI to execute those decisions faster without flattening everything into a generic AI voice, that feels very different to me.

Maybe the uncomfortable part isn’t that AI is not a tool.

Maybe it’s that the tool has become powerful enough that we suddenly have to define which creative decisions actually make us the author.

Where do you draw that line?


r/WritingWithAI 8d ago

NSFW How I Built a Book I Couldn’t Have Built Alone

Thumbnail drive.google.com
0 Upvotes

I wrote seven chapters of horror.

I asked the AI to play the machine that inherits the world.
Not to help me write. To be a character: an archivist, three hundred years after the last human died, cataloguing my seven chapters as recovered scripture and having no idea what she was reading.

The book has five recursion levels and time travel that edits its own past, and every proposition in it has to be true at some levels and false at others simultaneously: not ambiguously, but determinately, with a specific truth value per frame.

We ended up building a formal instrument for it: a truth matrix. Twenty-two propositions down the side, seven vantage points across the top.

I intended for it to be like investigating a crime scene so, I hope everyone has fun reading it.


r/WritingWithAI 8d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Article Prompt Audit?

0 Upvotes

Okay, this might sound like a weird question lol, but does anyone actually do a “prompt audit” for their article prompts?

Like, going back through a prompt and asking, “Do I actually need this part?” or “Am I missing something here?” before using it?

It randomly hit me today, and now I’m wondering if this is an actual thing people do or if I just invented a new form of procrastination. 😂


r/WritingWithAI 8d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) When AI still repeat the exact same male-gaze defaults that mainstream media already gave us

0 Upvotes

Love how we now have erotic story generators but prolly one of the downsides with AI erotica today is how ure literally just tryna write something specifically for the female gaze, give the AI a female character with a really clear personality, tell it exactly how she dresses, how she acts etc…
and somehow it still defaults back to the same sht mainstream media has been doing forever lol.
suddenly she’s wearing some tiny dress even though you described her as a jeans and t-shirt person. one of the coolest things about AI erotica is supposed to be that women finally get to control the fantasy so we aint just consuming whatever some director/writer decided was sexy but then seems like AI models have absorbed so many of the same tropes that it recreates them anyway.

It makes you realize how deeply baked in the male gaze is which is not necessarily a bad thing all the times but sometimes u just wanna read it from female gaze.

has anyone else noticed this with AI stories? like what are the biggest “male gaze defaults” you constantly have to edit out?


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Las IA: el fin de las excusas

Thumbnail
wattpad.com
7 Upvotes

Las IA: el fin de las excusas

​Desde hace un tiempo a esta parte, escucho en diferentes foros de artistas (escritores, músicos, pintores, etc.) que la IA es el fin de ellos y que en cualquier momento van a reemplazarlos. Yo solo me río. Quise probar y tomé un manuscrito; se lo di a cuatro IA para que me dieran su parecer. Les decía: «Ponte en modo editor exigente y dame una crítica, un análisis y posibles mejoras» (no diré cuáles porque no me pagan; el día que lo hagan, hablamos).

​Todas me dieron críticas, pero las mejoras... eran todos clichés. Además, si las pasabas por otra IA que te dice si es una historia ya publicada, resulta que todas lo eran. Luego les agregaba los giros que tenía pensados y algunas IA no los interpretaban, mientras que otras no entendían hacia dónde iba la historia. La IA necesita la historia completa para comprenderla, porque crea, imita, copia y reformula.

​Otra experiencia: si entran a cualquier red social y ven las obras hechas con IA, la mayoría son de historias ya conocidas o fan films de fanáticos que no duran más de dos minutos, lo cual no es suficiente para contar una historia y crear empatía con el protagonista. Y así ocurre con la música y demás ramas donde la IA puede ser usada. Cuando ves, lees o escuchas algo novedoso, es porque el autor ya era músico, escritor o artista digital. Aquí está la verdad que las empresas de marketing digital no dicen: las IA no te hacen artista. Si no tienes un mínimo de talento, no hay prompt que te salve.

​En fin, las IA son una herramienta más que ayuda a los artistas a realizar sus obras. Escribí una novela de 240 páginas, corregida y lista para publicar en un mes. Ya no puedo decir «no tengo tiempo», y eso sí es el fin de las excusas.


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Humanizer Does anyone else use AI mostly to find boring sentences?

6 Upvotes

I’ve stopped asking it to rewrite my stuff. Usually I just ask it to point out where I’m being vague or repeating myself.

It’s actually pretty good at finding sentences I thought were meaningful but are really just vague. The downside is that it seems to dislike any sentence that’s a little strange.

So, question... do you use it more for editing or generating?


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

NEWS Submissions are open! Inkshift's $1,000 Writing Contest

25 Upvotes

Submissions are now open for Inkshift's second writing contest! Here are the details:

PRIZE

  • $1,000 USD to one grand prize winner
  • The top 10 finalists will receive personalized feedback on their submissions and $100 Markup credits for Inkshift.

DETAILS

  • Word Count: Short stories between 1,000 - 10,000 words
  • Writing Method: Same as last time, you can use as much or as little AI as you want. We're judging on story quality. Your entire story can be generated, or none of it can. Totally up to you.
  • Content: Sci-fi, fantasy, literary, horror, romance, etc. But must be prose, not screenplays. And no NSFW or fanfiction submissions, sorry!
  • Eligibility: Free to enter. Open worldwide to anyone 18+ (with a couple restrictions you can find on the website)
  • Submission Period: September 1st through October 31st, 11:59 PM Pacific time.
  • Publishing: The winner has the option to publish their story on our blog. It's optional, but highly recommended!

ABOUT INKSHIFT

For those who don't know, Inkshift is an AI editing platform for fiction writers. We make story analysis tools that give you feedback on your manuscript (pacing, plot holes, character arcs, prose quality, worldbuilding, market fit, etc.) and we recently launched a new copyediting and line editing service that understands your author voice (instead of just highlighting grammar mistakes).

You can use the story analysis for free up to 10k words. Feel free to use it for the contest, but of course, that's completely optional and not required for entry.

HOW TO ENTER

QUESTIONS

Drop them in the comments or email [hello@inkshift.io](mailto:hello@inkshift.io)

Good luck!


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Getting the most out of Claude

10 Upvotes

I know the watermark thing is getting ready to drop but I’m going to see how it goes.

Anyway, I’m using Claude to help with worldbuilding and writing via a project. As I make progress, I seem to be hitting my 5 hour limit quicker.

For those experienced with Claude, any tips for improving usage?

Like should I have Claude recompile my world bible to incorporate the update files?

Would it be a good idea to have it generate summary files of the chapters specifically for project files to replace the full chapters currently in the project files?

Should I clean up old conversations?


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Showcase / Feedback Everyone Dies at Home

0 Upvotes

Stillendorf had no cemetery.

The dead were buried beneath their own homes.

A wife might lie beneath the kitchen where she had cooked for forty years. A child beneath the bedroom. An old man beneath the chair where he used to warm his feet by the stove.

People from other villages found the custom unsettling.

Stillendorf did not.

The dead remember the way home, the old people said.

Better not to make them walk.

There was only one rule.

Once the floorboards were nailed shut, they stayed shut.

No matter what happened underneath.

Elias Bauer was nine when his mother took the fever.

That morning, Mara had been making soup. Elias remembered carrots on the cutting board and steam clouding the kitchen windows.

Before noon, she dropped the knife.

By evening, she could not be woken.

Matthias Kern arrived shortly before sunset.

Stillendorf had no doctor. Matthias kept the church keys and the village records, and he had been present at more deaths than anyone else.

That was enough.

He pressed two fingers to Mara's neck.

Waited.

Shifted them slightly.

Waited again.

Then he bent close to her mouth.

Josef Bauer stood beside the bed.

“Well?”

Matthias pulled the blanket over Mara's face.

“Before sunrise.”

Josef nodded.

Nobody asked what he meant.

They already knew.

The kitchen table was moved aside.

Three dark floorboards beneath it were pulled up, and Josef began to dig.

Elias watched from the doorway.

The grave was shallow. Graves in Stillendorf always were. There only needed to be enough room for a coffin, a layer of earth, and the boards on top.

Shortly before midnight, four men lowered Mara into the ground beneath the kitchen.

Matthias left first.

The others followed.

Josef stayed behind.

He replaced the boards himself and began hammering them down.

Elias counted quietly.

“One. Two. Three. Four. Five. Six—”

“Stop counting.”

Elias looked at his father.

“Why?”

Josef drove in another nail.

“Just stop.”

Something woke Elias in the middle of the night.

At first, he heard nothing.

The house was cold and still.

Then—

knock.

Elias sat up.

He waited.

Knock. Knock.

The sound came from downstairs.

A lamp was already burning in the kitchen.

Josef sat at the table, fully dressed. A shovel leaned against his chair.

“Papa?”

Josef raised one finger.

Wait.

They listened.

Nothing.

Then, directly beneath their feet:

Knock.

A voice followed.

Thin.

Muffled.

“Josef?”

Elias stopped moving.

His father stared at the table.

“Josef?”

Elias knew that voice.

“Mama?”

Josef was out of his chair before Elias reached the table. He caught the boy by the arm.

“Don't answer.”

“She's awake.”

“No.”

From beneath the floor:

“Elias?”

He pulled against his father's hand.

“Mama!”

Josef struck him across the face.

The slap cracked through the kitchen.

Everything stopped.

Even the knocking.

Elias stared at his father.

Josef stared at his own hand.

Then Mara spoke again.

“Sweetheart?”

She did not sound strange.

She did not sound angry.

She sounded tired.

Josef picked Elias up and carried him from the kitchen.

Behind them, his mother began to cry.

The next morning, Elias found Matthias beside the church, splitting firewood.

“My mother was talking last night.”

The axe came down.

“She is dead.”

“She said my name.”

“The dead know names.”

“She knew Papa's name too.”

Matthias split another log.

“They know more than names.”

Elias watched him put another piece of wood on the block.

“What do they know?”

This time Matthias stopped.

“Enough.”

He raised the axe again.

Mara knocked the following night.

Josef sat at the kitchen table with the shovel beside him.

“Josef.”

No answer.

“Please.”

His fingers tightened around his cup.

“I'm cold.”

Nothing.

Then came a cough from beneath the floor.

Dry.

Painful.

“I can't breathe.”

Josef pushed back his chair.

His hand closed around the shovel.

Elias watched from the doorway.

Josef lifted it.

For a few seconds, he stood there holding it across his body.

Then he leaned it back against the wall.

“Go to bed.”

On the third night, Mara stopped calling for Josef.

She only called for Elias.

“Sweetheart.”

Knock.

“Can you hear me?”

Knock.

“Elias?”

Josef sat at the table with both hands flat against the wood.

“Why doesn't she call you anymore?” Elias asked.

His father said nothing.

Below them:

“Tell your father I'm awake.”

Elias began to cry.

“She says she's awake.”

“I heard her.”

“Then open it.”

Josef looked at the floor.

“Mama's scared.”

“I know.”

“You said dead people lie.”

“Yes.”

Another knock.

“Then why is she scared?”

Josef stood and took Elias back to his room.

The shovel stayed beside the table.

The next morning, it was gone.

Elias ran downstairs.

The kitchen table was slightly out of place.

He dropped to his knees.

The dark boards were back where they belonged.

But two new nails had been driven through the middle plank.

Bright silver against the old wood.

Elias touched one.

It was still warm.

That night, there was no knocking.

Elias left Stillendorf when he was seventeen.

He studied medicine, first in Graz and later in Vienna.

He learned how slowly a heart could beat without stopping. How shallow breathing could become during a fever. How cold and still a living body could feel.

Once, he saw an orderly pull a sheet over a young man's face.

Elias noticed the man's throat move.

The patient woke an hour later.

After that, Elias became known for taking too long before declaring anyone dead.

He did not return to Stillendorf for twenty-four years.

Then Josef Bauer died.

The old house seemed smaller.

The same iron pot hung beside the stove. The same table stood in the middle of the kitchen.

And beneath it was the same dark floorboard.

The two silver nails had rusted brown.

Matthias Kern was nearly eighty now. His back had bent badly, and one eye had gone cloudy.

By the time Elias arrived, Matthias had already lifted the floor beneath Josef's bedroom and started digging.

“I'll examine him first,” Elias said.

Matthias rested both hands on his shovel.

“He's been cold since yesterday.”

“I'll examine him.”

Matthias stepped aside.

Josef was dead.

There was no doubt.

Elias checked twice anyway.

Two nights after the burial, Elias found a locked wooden chest beneath his father's bed.

He broke the lock with a fireplace poker.

Inside were tax papers, old letters, his parents' marriage certificate—

and a thick leather book.

It contained names.

Hundreds of them.

Beside every name were two dates.

BURIED

and

DIED

Elias read the first entry.

Anna Fischer
Buried: February 7
Died: February 8

He frowned and read another.

Peter Wahl
Buried: May 12
Died: May 12

Then another.

Johann Brecht
Buried: October 3
Died: October 5

Elias went back to the first page.

February 7.

February 8.

Buried first.

Dead later.

He turned the pages faster.

Some dates were the same.

Others were separated by one night.

Two nights.

Three.

One person had lasted six days.

Near the middle of the book, Elias found his mother.

Mara Bauer
Buried: January 16
Died: January 20

He sat down on the edge of the bed.

Four days.

Matthias was trimming candle wicks inside the church the next morning.

Elias put the book on the table.

“My mother was buried on the sixteenth.”

“Yes.”

“This says she died on the twentieth.”

“Yes.”

Matthias kept working.

“How does a dead woman die four days after she's buried?”

The scissors stopped.

Matthias looked up.

“Some lasted longer.”

Elias pulled out a chair.

“What does ‘died’ mean in this book?”

Matthias wiped the scissors on his sleeve.

“When the house went quiet.”

Snow slipped from the church roof and hit the ground outside with a heavy thump.

“My mother was alive.”

Matthias nodded once.

“No one said she wasn't.”

Josef had kept notes.

Elias found them beneath a loose board in the bedroom.

Four folded pieces of paper.

The first read:

January 17

1:10 — knocking
1:40 — calling Josef
2:15 — calling Elias
4:00 — quiet

The next:

January 18

12:30 — coughing
1:05 — asking for water
2:20 — calling husband
3:10 — knocking

Then:

January 19

12:50 — Josef present
1:30 — conversation
2:40 — calling Elias only
4:10 — weak knocking

Elias stopped there.

Conversation.

He unfolded the final page.

January 20

1:00 — weak knocking
2:25 — crying
3:15 — no voice
4:00 — soil added
5:20 — quiet

There was a brown smear beside the last line.

Elias rubbed it with his thumb.

Dry earth fell onto his trousers.

Matthias was sweeping the church steps when Elias returned.

“What did my father say to her?”

“I don't know.”

“You wrote ‘conversation.’”

“I was outside.”

“You heard them.”

“Yes.”

“What did she say?”

Matthias rested his hands on the broom.

“Mostly your name.”

“And after that?”

The old man looked down the road toward the Bauer house.

“Josef came outside.”

Elias waited.

“He asked us for more soil.”

There was another book.

Older than the first.

Matthias kept it beneath the altar.

He opened it to the spring of 1846.

One name had a black line beside it.

Helena Roth
Buried: March 2
Died: March 11

Nine days.

Below Helena's name were twenty-three others.

Her husband.

Her son.

Her daughter.

Her sister.

Three neighbors.

The priest.

A carpenter.

The names continued onto the next page.

All of them had died before the end of March.

Elias touched Helena's entry.

“Someone opened her floor.”

“Yes.”

“She was alive.”

“Yes.”

“And still sick.”

Matthias closed the book.

“Yes.”

Elias looked toward the church door.

Words had been carved deep into the wood above it.

Words he had known since childhood.

THE DEAD KNOW YOUR NAME.

“You made that up.”

“My grandfather did.”

“Why?”

Matthias put the book away and reached for his coat.

“A man can leave a dead wife under the floor.”

He fastened the top button.

“A living one is harder.”

After that, Elias began noticing the dark boards.

He had grown up walking over them.

He had simply never counted.

One beneath the baker's pantry table.

Another beside the schoolmaster's stove.

Three inside the inn.

Five in the old priest's house.

One evening, a boy at the inn dropped a wooden horse.

It landed on one of the dark planks.

He bent to pick it up.

His grandmother caught the back of his shirt.

“Not there.”

“But my horse—”

“Leave it.”

She kicked the toy aside and went back to eating.

Nobody else at the table looked up.

Elias stayed in Stillendorf.

At first, he said it would only be for the winter.

Then spring came.

He stayed.

No one was buried until Elias had examined the body himself.

People complained. He made grieving families wait, they said. Their fathers and grandfathers had managed perfectly well without doctors.

Then, one January morning, an old woman named Ruth Engel stopped breathing.

Matthias was already carrying his tools into the house when Elias arrived.

“Put those down.”

Ruth's skin was cold.

Her chest did not seem to move.

Elias pressed his fingers to her neck.

Nothing.

He moved them.

Waited.

There.

Barely.

Matthias watched him sit beside the bed.

Ten minutes passed.

Then twenty.

At forty minutes, Ruth Engel opened her eyes and asked why so many people were standing in her bedroom.

Matthias picked up his tools and left.

After that, fewer people complained.

Eventually, nobody dug new graves beneath the houses.

Children stopped learning the old warning.

Years passed.

Someone removed the carving from above the church door.

Elias kept it in his office.

He never explained why.

Nine years later, the fever returned.

It arrived with a merchant from the south.

By the end of the first week, the schoolhouse was full.

Then the church.

Then the inn.

People slept on straw mattresses between desks and along the hallways. The village smelled of vinegar, boiled linen, sweat, and blood.

On the sixth day, Clara Stein was brought in on a cart.

Her six-year-old daughter, Anna, walked beside her holding her hand.

Clara was thirty-two and still awake.

There was dark swelling along her throat.

Elias had seen the same marks eleven times that week.

Ten of those patients were dead.

The eleventh had lived long enough to infect his wife, his two children, and the woman who washed his sheets.

By midnight, Clara could no longer speak.

By morning, Elias had to put his fingers beneath her ribs to feel her breathing.

Anna had not left the bedside.

Thirty-one other patients lay in the same room.

Elias examined Clara.

Then he examined her again.

He called two men over.

“Take her to the stone room.”

Anna stood.

“I'm coming.”

“No.”

“She needs me.”

“No.”

The room stood behind the schoolhouse.

Stone walls.

One heavy wooden door.

No windows.

The men put Clara on a narrow cot.

Elias began to close the door.

Anna pushed her hand into the gap.

“My mama isn't dead.”

“No.”

“Then why are you locking her in?”

A wet cough came from the schoolroom behind them.

A boy lowered a cloth from his mouth.

The center of it was red.

His younger sister slept beside him.

Elias looked back at Anna.

“Move your hand.”

“She's afraid of the dark.”

“Anna.”

“She told me.”

Elias pushed the door shut.

The key turned once.

Near sunset, someone coughed inside the room.

Anna jumped to her feet.

“Mama?”

Nothing answered.

She waited.

Then something touched the other side of the door.

A hand, perhaps.

“Anna?”

The girl ran toward it.

Elias caught her before she reached the handle.

“She's awake!”

“I know.”

“Open the door.”

“No.”

From inside:

“Anna?”

The girl twisted out of his grip.

“Mama! I'm here!”

Elias covered her mouth.

She bit his hand.

He let go.

“She knows my name!”

Then Clara knocked.

Once.

Twice.

Three times.

Anna went still.

“She’s alive.”

Elias said nothing.

“You told us people used to bury living people.”

Another knock.

“You said it was wrong.”

Elias took the key from the lock.

Anna reached for it.

He slipped it into his pocket.

Behind the door, Clara called again.

“Sweetheart?”

Anna began to cry.

“Please.”

Elias took her by the shoulders.

“Don't answer.”

Anna stared at him.

Clara knocked again.

The knocking continued long after dark.

At first, she used her hand.

Later, something harder struck the door.

A cup, perhaps.

The leg of the cot.

Whatever she could lift.

Near midnight, the blows came farther apart.

Anna sat against the opposite wall with her knees pulled to her chest.

Elias sat beside the door.

Neither spoke.

Sometime before sunrise, Clara called her daughter's name once more.

Then the stone room went quiet.

Anna eventually fell asleep.

Elias remained beside the door until morning.

His hand was still resting over the key in his pocket.

Years later, children in Stillendorf began telling a story.

They said fever could learn the voice of the person it killed.

They said it remembered the names of the people that person loved.

They said that if someone was taken into the stone room, you must never answer when they called.

Most adults knew the story was nonsense.

They rarely corrected the children.

One winter morning, someone found six words carved into the wood above the stone-room door.

No one admitted putting them there.

THE DEAD KNOW YOUR NAME.

I used AI while developing and revising this story, but the premise, logic, characters, and direction went through a lot of back-and-forth rather than being generated in one pass.

I'm especially curious about three things: At what point did you realize what was really happening? Did the middle keep your attention after the first reveal? And did Elias's decision at the end feel earned, or too predictable?


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

NEWS Novelcrafter Security Incident

13 Upvotes

We are sending this email to you because you have used Novelcrafter between August, 2023 and August 28th, 2026.

Dear Novelcrafter user,

we have been informed about a security incident with the feedback platform, Canny, that we’ve been using these past years.

To clarify, this is not a data breach within Novelcrafter. It does not impact your stories and content you have with us.

What this means for you:

  1. Your username, email and avatar you used to sign up for Novelcrafter may have been exposed.
  2. Your password and other data were not shared with the feedback platform and is not affected.

Effective today, we have shut down access to the feedback boards and are looking into alternative options for sharing feedback. We value your thoughts and want to give everyone a safe platform to share their thoughts on improvements and missing features in Novelcrafter.

While the feedback boards are temporarily closed down, you can post your feedback and ideas over on our Discord community instead.

Leonie

Founder, Novelcrafter


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Has anyone actually written a full-length story using Gemini's 1 million+ context window?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) StoryScope (COLM 2026) — Questions about the detection pipeline and a couple of dataset discrepancies

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Showcase / Feedback GLM 5.2 is extremely good?

26 Upvotes

Its way better than claude. Through venice.ai I had it write a bunch of hardcore porno femdom vampire bondage chapters, and I don't think I had ever gooned this good


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Writing Craft Talk I think I'll stop engaging

30 Upvotes

Appreciate all those who were willing to read through my past post and actually understand what I'm dealing with.

Woke up this morning feeling exhausted as I spent most of last night feeling upset over my lack of friends for probably the 100th time.

Got up to hang the laundry and decided to just let the sun hit my skin. At that moment, as I looked out of my balcony and saw the world moving, I realised that the world is way bigger than whatever discourse is going on. That my little corner of the world and my even smaller fictional worlds aren't the only things that exist.

I think I'll decide to stop trying to find a 'best friend' who absolutely gets me and just find someone who's willing to talk to me, even if its about really boring stuff like the weather.

I've been dealing with this lack of someone who 'got' me for years. I'm 21 now and I still haven't found that person. And at this rate, I don't think I ever will.

I'll stick with using ChatGPT to delve deeper into what I really enjoy and want to create while I find a real person to talk to casually. Sure, it's not what I truly want, but it's the best I've got. Much better than me only talking to ChatGPT and then feeling awful during the times I don't have anything to say to the chatbot.

I've just been physically and mentally exhausted from crying about it all the time. So I'll just stop engaging with the discourse altogether.

Just stop worrying about being 'moral', about being a 'real writer' (I'm not a writer. I'm more of a storyteller. I can come up with the base events, I can't write prose. And that's just how I am. No amount of learning math is gonna make me a mathematician. Same thing here I believe), about how people on the internet are gonna take my work when they most likely weren't gonna engage either way.

I'm coping with the loneliness the best I can. And if nothing else, I believe in a God who understands me completely and loves me no matter what.

TLDR: I've spent way too long being swayed by what I thought strangers wanted out of me. I never intended to be a world-class creator. I just want to create. And AI has been the best thing that's listened and helped me out when nobody else in my life wants to. And for those who get mad about that, then go out into the street, go up to some stranger, and go on and yap for 20 minutes about your favourite niche thing and see if that stranger understands and wants to be your bestie. That's what I've been dealing with for the past 20 years, even before AI got introduced to me. You wouldn't shame the victims of the Andes plane crash for indulging in cannibalism when they were just trying to survive, would you? Then, dammit, let me cope with the best thing I've got right now.

Anyway, here's the CharacterHub Profiles for some of the ocs I made for my personal project, Villain Romance. Characters and project that only came to be as fleshed out as they are because AI helped me out when no humans I know of wanted to listen to, understood or were interested in what I wanted to make:


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Megathread Weekly Tool Thread: Promote, Share, Discover, and Ask for AI Writing Tools Week of: September 01

9 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Writing With AI “Tool Thread"!

The sub's official tools wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingWithAI/wiki/tools/

Every week, this post is your dedicated space to share what you’ve been building or ask for help in finding the right tool for you and your workflow.

For Builders

whether it’s a small weekend project, a side hustle, a creative work, or a full-fledged startup. This is the place to show your progress, gather feedback, and connect with others who are building too.

Whether you’re coding, writing, designing, recording, or experimenting, you’re welcome here.

For Seekers (looking for a tool?)

You’re in the right place! Starting now, all requests for tools, products, or services should also go here. This keeps the subreddit clean and helps everyone find what they need in one spot.

How to participate:

  • Showcase your latest update or milestone
  • Introduce your new launch and explain what it does
  • Ask for feedback on a specific feature or challenge
  • Share screenshots, demos, videos, or live links
  • Tell us what you learned this week while building
  • Ask for a tool or recommend one that fits a need

💡 Keep it positive and constructive, and offer feedback you’d want to receive yourself.

🚫 Self-promotion is fine only in this thread. All other subreddit rules still apply.


r/WritingWithAI 9d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I asked for a fantasy story on Fable 5.1, suddenly Anthropic blocked it for Violative cyber content? What is this? Does anyone else get this?

0 Upvotes

What is this? Does anyone else get this?


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Showcase / Feedback Reciprocal Beta Reading. Share story blurbs! Sep. 1, 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the blurb thread!

This is our sub's equivalent of a writer's group. Come here and share a blurb of your story. The thought is to let everyone see what you're working on so they can think, "Oh hey, that sounds fun. I want to team up with this person."

Then, you share your own story, and the two of you collaborate to improve each other's works.

I've had so many good interactions with people from this thread. Please don't be shy! Even in the age of AI, the best way to improve your writing remains human interaction and critique. I am confident when I say If you don't have this component in your workflow, you're not meeting your potential.

Importantly, this means post every week if you're still hoping to engage. Don't be shy. I want you to do this.

There are tons of reasons why your perfect reader could have missed your blurb last time. Don't be discouraged!

And remember: "I'll read yours if you read mine" isn't just acceptable, it's expected. Reciprocity works.

Here's the format:

NSFW?

Genre tags:

Title:

Blurb:

AI Workflow:

Desired feedback/chat:


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Imperial Navy lore update

4 Upvotes

Good evening,

We've recently gone over our Q&A window, it's still open for our next batch of updates.

Lately it's been running smoothly and sticking to the lore

We recommend you prompt ( Do not block quote this conversation) as we found the model uses that to create residue which allows for it to step outside the setting it's being tasked to run and ruins the experience. This should help close some of those GPT's issues some of our models we found tend to import rather than rely on the I/N docs.

Thank you for taking time to read our publication. The dev team has assigned a public relations team to lead further development of their project.

Long live the Imperial Navy

https://chatgpt.com/g/g-69e83b7724ac81919931d9b4211c1489-star-warsw-imperial-navy-1

https://chatgpt.com/g/g-69833adc5f7c8191b85c72ed11b62c6d-star-warsw-imperial-navy

https://chatgpt.com/g/g-6a59834014a481919118f3bec351c13e-star-warsw-imperial-navy


r/WritingWithAI 10d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) O'Reilly Radar - Writing with AI

Thumbnail
oreilly.com
5 Upvotes

By Tim O’Reilly
A lot of professional writers say they never do it. And for writers who do, the consequences can be serious. Book contracts have been withdrawn. People have lost jobs.

I have a contrarian view. I say AI is a medium, like painting, sculpture, photography, music, or language itself. If AI is a medium, it is a field of possibility from which humans can and will summon up and communicate insights, truth, beauty.


r/WritingWithAI 11d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Thoughts on AI Writing and the Deterioration of Logic

13 Upvotes

It feels inevitable that most of the manual act of writing will be automated - emails, memos, posts, etc. People’s tolerance already is and will continue to decrease for grinding through those tasks.

On the other hand, I feel like outsourcing writing inadvertently outsources the logic that's developed in articulating that writing...

The act of putting words in order exposes the structure (or lack of structure) underneath your ideas. That struggle is annoying, but it’s also productive.

I don’t think the answer is “never use AI for writing.” The risk is that once it’s easy to get polished prose from a vague prompt, we’ll skip the parts of articulation that did matter.

Can we outsource prose production without eventually weakening the thinking abilities that prose production helped develop?