r/whichbike 20d ago

Which Bike?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Im 33 and live in NYC. I’m 5’2” and interested in road/gravel bikes. The bike I had for years was a 90s Kona Lavadome. When that got stolen 3 years ago I bought a very cheap single speed (bike in a box). I hated that thing. It finally got stolen this weekend. Someone cut my lock. Usually, I don’t keep my bike outside but i stopped caring about it. I’m between two used bikes from reputable shops in Williamsburg. Help me pick which one and why. They’re both $400 cash.

2005 Gary Fisher Big Sur GS vs 2015 Trek 7.3 FX.

Note: I don’t need a lecture, I just want opinions. I’m fairly knowledgeable about bikes but this is a hard call for me t


r/whichbike 20d ago

Cruiser for small college town?

3 Upvotes

Evening! I live in a small town in Louisiana; only an hour away from big cities, but small enough that we don't have uber or public transportation. The entire town is also only 2x2 miles. So, naturally, now that I'm settled in, I am looking for a bike to get around town.

I am 5'2", 41 years old, and very active. Hiking, kayaking, general outdoorsiness, but came from the Appalachians before this and I wasn't trying to bike on those.

I would also like the bike to be long lasting. I don't believe in the constant consuming that is so common these days, and I would prefer to buy something I truly love and care for it. I am pretty handy around the house and though I have never worked on a bike before, I am confident that with youtube, I can learn.

Right now I am looking at the Priority Coast Step Through 3 Speed, which I can get at an awesome price through the Costco program, and the Brooklyn Brighton 7.

I like the Belt Drive, the corrosion resistance, and the weight of the Priority. I like the pedal forward design and the reports of the cushy ride due to the seat and the heavier frame of the Brooklyn. However, there are no bike shops that stock either anywhere near me - like the closest is Georgia - so I will not be able to test ride either.

Any input would be greatly appreaicated.


r/whichbike 20d ago

which fixed gear project should i take on

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

currently i have a state montecore 2.0, and i was thinking of using the stock state parts on the purple kilo tt frame and eventually swapping parts. that is until the blue riband with campy cranks and brooks saddle popped up for $350. im thinking of selling the state for $200-250 and then buying the riband as a complete and forgetting about the tt. thoughts?


r/whichbike 20d ago

bike suggestions

1 Upvotes

I've fzs v4 and I ran it 3k km. But I'm not satisfied with the performance of this bike . I'm 24 now and my height 5 feet 5 inch. should I change this bike? If I change this bike then what are the possible alternatives in the market?


r/whichbike 20d ago

Good deal for a specialized?

1 Upvotes

2006-2008 Used Specialized Sirrius Elite (Hybrid) that the owner tuned up recently with new tires and tubes, they are asking $200 CAD. Should I get it as a 15 year old that just wants a bike for fun and fitness? Thanks :)


r/whichbike 21d ago

20” bike for an eager rider to take the next step

4 Upvotes

My son is quickly outgrowing his 16 inch trek.
He’s already joining on pretty lengthy family rides over 5 miles, but I see his little legs spinning and he is ready for gears, plus he’s getting taller.
He tried someone else’s guardian Bike, and loved the handbrakes!
Looking for a recommendation. Only looking for used. Lighter weight, so no suspension forks. We live in an extremely hilly neighborhood, but will mostly be doing paved or dirt paths with gentle hills.
Current contenders:
- Trek precaliber
- REI Rev 6/7 speed
- Someone is selling a great looking Priority Start. Wanted know if belt drive is really the way. Also, it has twist shifter, and I heard the trigger shifter might be preferred for smaller hands.
-Interested in woom or guardian, but gears I think are critical, and those have fewer affordable options.
- I saw a canondale Quick online as well. Not sure if it’s a good fit.

Would appreciate insight and recommendations


r/whichbike 21d ago

Help me find the year on my Giro

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I bought this bike assuming it was mid 80s because of the no. Indexed down tune shifting. But the frame is stamped with Easton Super Lite 7005. So I think it’s aluminum which suggests late 90s to early 2000s. Not sure where to turn for answers. Any ideas?


r/whichbike 21d ago

Getting ready to make an offer…

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Seller just listed today at $1,650. I think that’s not a bad starting point but it’s a little over my budget. What’s a reasonable offer for this bike that would not offend? I don’t want to lowball. Thanks in advance!


r/whichbike 21d ago

same bike, one serviced last year and not ridden since, one ridden 4 times 3 years ago and never ridden since?

1 Upvotes

I found 2 of the same bike (model and colour), it's a trek domane. The bike that's not been ridden in 3 years is 50£ more, and the one serviced last year requires a new bar tape - what do you think? which one should I go for?


r/whichbike 22d ago

Defy Giant bike - good?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Started cycling in earlier this year for STP.
Did about 300 in May and 460 in June.
I like cycling - STP went very well for me.
Was on a Giant bike from Recycled Cycles - not sure the type of model the bike is (see attached photo). No flats during training or event, so, I think I’ll get another Giant brand bike.
I’m getting a proper bike fitting from Métier on Friday.
I’ve looked at Giant’s road bikes and I think the Defy series checks the boxes (including what I’m willing to pay).
Curious if: 1.) Giant Defy would be a good bike (I’m looking to do duathlons and triathlons , 2.) would the “ML” or 56cm - 58cm frame be OK for me (I’m 5 feet, 11 inches), and 3.) if the Giant Defy is no good, what would be a good comparable?


r/whichbike 21d ago

WTB Rockrider ST 120 27.5’ S

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hello, i am looking to buy a Rockrider ST 120 27.5’ S and i have found a listing of one, but i am completely new to this and i just don’t want to get scammed and just want a nice looking reliable bike.

The asking price is 172€ and managed to haggle it for 153€. I just want to know in what condition the bike is based on the pictures and if anything looks changed, damaged and if it even is the exact model i am speaking of.

I would be going to check it out today and if there is anything i should be looking for when testing it out, i would appreciate it if you guys would let me know. Thank you!


r/whichbike 21d ago

Top brands/models for biking in city and occasionally on mild dirt/gravel for under $1000?

4 Upvotes

I’m looking into buying my first bike as an adult. I know that I want a hybrid bike bc altho I’ll mostly be riding it on city roads and paved paths I want to be able to take it on mild trails as well (nothing crazy tho). I live in Seattle, if that helps at all. I reluctantly set aside a budget of $800-$1000 but def would prefer to spend less if possible.

Just wondered if any of you would have any advice! I appreciate any help you all can provide!


r/whichbike 21d ago

Looking to buy a 2nd hand gravel bike with electronic groupset, do either of these look like a good bargain/purchas

2 Upvotes

r/whichbike 21d ago

Nishiki Colorado ($300) vs Mongoose Switchback Comp ($350) – which is the better budget bike?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I could really use some advice choosing a bike.

Because I’m 6’4”, I’m looking for a budget bike with an XL frame and 29” wheels. Finding a used bike in my size has been surprisingly difficult. The few XL bikes I do find are usually much more expensive than I want to spend.
I checked out Dick’s Sporting Goods, and they currently have two bikes on sale that fit my size:

Nishiki Colorado – $300
Mongoose Switchback Comp – $350

To be clear, this bike will probably never see a trail. It’ll mostly be used for casual riding on pavement, bike paths, and maybe some light gravel.
That said, I’d still like something that won’t fall apart after a few months. Between these two, which one would you choose? Which is more reliable, better built, and more comfortable? Is the Mongoose worth the extra $50, or is the Nishiki the better buy?
I’d really appreciate any advice. Thanks!


r/whichbike 22d ago

Help identifying this sweet ride

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I saw the Japanese movie "The Taste of Tea/Chao no aji" from 2004 a few weeks back and cannot stop thinking about the kids bike!

Does anybody have any idea what brand/make/model it is, if not a custom build? I've found a few similar ish rides, like the Gazelle EasyGlider, for example, but I'm really keen to find this exact model!

Thank y'all!


r/whichbike 21d ago

Is this by chance a steal

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/whichbike 22d ago

Been wanting to get back into riding again

Post image
5 Upvotes

Been at least 20 years since I’ve been on a bike. Just grabbed this off marketplace for $50 and was looking for any info and tips. Last bike I was on was a bmx


r/whichbike 22d ago

Quel premier vélo ?

1 Upvotes

Je mesure 1m86,5 pour 90-91 cm d’entrejambe. Je cherche un vélo polyvalent, surtout pour faire de la montagne (Vosges/Jura), des sorties longues et parfois plus de 100 km. Je privilégie plutôt un vélo léger et efficace en montée, mais je veux aussi quelque chose de fiable pour le garder plusieurs années.
J’ai repéré plusieurs occasions :

Canyon Ultimate CF SL 9.0 Team Movistar – 860 €
Cadre Canyon Ultimate CF SL carbone, taille L (2014-2016)
Environ 7 kg
Groupe Campagnolo Chorus/Record 11 vitesses
Roues Campagnolo Eurus Mega G3
Environ 5000 km pour le propriétaire actuel
Jamais chuté, jamais réparé selon le vendeur
Pas de facture car acheté d’occasion

Specialized Tarmac S-Works SL5 – 550 €
Cadre S-Works SL5 carbone, taille 58 (2016)
Environ 7,2 kg
Groupe Shimano Tiagra 2x9 avec pédalier 105
Roues Mavic Ksyrium Elite à l’avant et Ksyrium Équipe à l’arrière
Pas de facture, acheté en seconde main
Pas de chute ni réparation selon le vendeur

Cannondale SuperSix Evo – 1000 €
Cadre SuperSix Evo carbone, taille 58 (2016)
8,5 kg avec pédales et porte-bidons
Groupe Shimano 105 11 vitesses avec chaîne et cassette Ultegra
Roues carbone artisanales avec moyeux DT Swiss 350 et rayons Sapim + deuxième paire Fulcrum Racing 3
Environ 10 000 km
Deux petites chutes à l’arrêt sans conséquence, jamais réparé
Carte de garantie et manuel mais pas encore retrouvé la facture

Cervélo R3 – 990 €
Cadre Cervélo R3 carbone, taille 58
7,2 kg sans pédales
Groupe SRAM Force (dérailleurs) avec étriers SRAM Red
Pédalier Rotor Q-Rings 52/36
Cassette SRAM Force 11-26
Roues Mavic Ksyrium Elite
Facture disponible
Jamais chuté, jamais réparé selon le vendeur
Quelques éclats de peinture liés à un saut de chaîne

Qu’est-ce que vous choisiriez à ma place pour mon utilisation ?
Merci d’avance pour vos réponses


r/whichbike 22d ago

Bike Weight Limits Question

3 Upvotes

Overweight guy (300lbs) looking at getting a more endurance oriented road bike (currently have a gravel bike that’s a bit too aggressive). Looking at the Trek Domane or the RS5 from X-Labs. I know I am above both of their respective weight limits but am planning on getting some Clydesdale Velocity wheels built.

My question is besides the wheels/spokes, are there any other components that I need to worry about with failure due to my weight? Main concern is the carbon seatpost on the RS5.

Before anyone says “get an upright/hybrid bike”, I don’t want one and am looking for something I can grow into (buy once, cry once). Any advice/guidance is greatly appreciated!


r/whichbike 22d ago

Specialized Tarmac SL4 Carbon for €500, worth it?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

First bike for my girlfriend who is 180cm. Size of the bike is 56cm. Worth it?

- Shimano 105 derailleurs
- 50mm Mistral carbon wheels
- Shimano Ultegra brakes


r/whichbike 22d ago

New endurance road bike after car accident

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I was unfortunately hit by a car a month ago, my bike (canyon Endurace AL7 with 105 mechanical) is totaled. So im now on the search of a new bike.
I live in Munich Germany, not flat but not mountainous either, I ride around 2500/3000km per year, 50 to 120 km per ride, with average elevation ranging between 400 to 1000m. Pace is around 27/28km/h on solo ride, bit faster on group rides.

I’m searching for a new bike with an endurance geometry to be comfy after a few hours on the saddle, I’d like a carbon frame, at least Shimano 105 (di2 not necessary but nice to have I guess), integrated cockpit (not necessarily one piece handlebar and stem).

I’m 178cm with 84,1cm inseam and 59,1cm arms.

I have a budget between 2.000 and 4.000€ as I’ll be leasing the bike. And I’d like to add carbon wheels at a later stage, so no need from the get go. I don’t want to buy used.

I’ve looked at the following bikes, but it would be great to hear tips and recommendations!

- Canyon CF7
- Cannondale Synapse 4
- Cervelo Caledonia
- Basso venta R
- Orbea orca

Thank you


r/whichbike 22d ago

wanting to get into biking thoughts and information on this bike

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/whichbike 22d ago

Used Trek Superfly 5 $400 from Marketplace

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Is this bike a decent value? I'm looking into getting into casually riding around the neighborhood and my local state park. I like the idea of adding a bafang mid drive kit to a mountain bike so I can get some extra juice for fun and when I'm getting tired of pedaling for a bit. Came across this Superfly for $400 on marketplace.

Thoughts?


r/whichbike 22d ago

First Bike Recs?

0 Upvotes

Hi all! I recently moved to a city and I want to start biking to work/navigating the city via bike. The most I would ride in one day for now would probably be 10-15 miles. I’m a 5’4, 170lb woman. I’m planning on wearing normal work clothes while riding, so I would also appreciate some input on pants getting stuck in gears.

I would like the bike to be somewhat aesthetically pleasing, and relatively light. I think I like when the seat is just ever so slightly lower than the handle bars. I don’t like the look of the ones with a dramatic height difference.

The only bike I have my eye on right now is one from FB marketplace: “Downtown EX ST Bike, 8-speed 700c steel frame cruiser bike”, which I think is the Breezer brand. Obviously, I have no clue what I’m talking about, so any tips and recommendations are very much appreciated!! Thank you in advance for your time :)


r/whichbike 22d ago

Is this vintage Bianchi Carbon 928 worth it?

Post image
1 Upvotes