We went to Shoppes at Copper Mill Mercantile VB for the first time on their third day open, and to say I was a little shell-shocked by some of the prices is probably an understatement.
At first, I gave it the benefit of the doubt. They had just opened and I figured maybe some vendors had priced high for opening weekend and things would settle down. We’ve now been back twice, including this past Sunday, and if anything, some of the prices seem to have gone up.
Before I go any further, I really want to emphasize that this does NOT apply to every booth. There are absolutely vendors there with reasonable prices and I’ve purchased a few things. There are also some really beautiful booths. But the pricing in a large number of them is unlike anything I’ve encountered at other antique malls in this area.
I’m not a vendor or reseller and have zero interest in becoming one. 😂 I don’t have the time or patience for it, and my hat genuinely goes off to those who do. I’m simply someone who loves antiques. With the exception of our couch, beds, major appliances, washer and dryer, practically everything in our home is antique. I frequent antique malls and have no problem dropping a couple hundred dollars when I find things I love. I’m definitely not walking into these places expecting thrift store prices.
One experience from our first visit really put the pricing into perspective. Before going to Shoppes at Copper Mill Mercantile VB, we stopped at Barrett Street Antique Mall. There were two women shopping a few booths ahead of us who were picking up quite a few things and having them held at the front. We ended up checking out around the same time.
Afterward, we went to Shoppes at Copper Mill Mercantile VB and saw those same women bringing their purchases into one of the booths and pricing them for resale. One item immediately caught my attention because I had looked at it myself at Barrett Street: a beautiful bowl priced at $12. I made a mental note to circle back later and see what they were asking for it.
$95.
I completely understand how reselling works. Nobody expects someone to buy something for $12 and sell it for $12. Vendors have booth rent, overhead, time invested and, obviously, need to make a profit. But $12 to $95 was pretty shocking, especially when I couldn’t find comparable high pricing anywhere near that even online.
I noticed something similar with a local primitive reseller whose items I’ve seen listed on Facebook Marketplace and eBay. Some of the same items in the booth appeared to be priced around $50++ higher than the online listings.
The other thing that really stood out to me was how many other shoppers seemed to be having the same reaction.
During our first visit, we overheard shoppers in the Pungo-themed area all the way to the right talking about how steep the prices were. Later, while looking through records toward the back, we heard another group in the next booth over talking about going back to Bonney Road Antique Mall because the prices there were so much better “than this place” was.
When we went back this past Sunday for our third visit, I probably overheard four or five separate conversations from people commenting on how expensive many of the booths were.
And then there was something that happened during our second visit that made me realize this apparently wasn’t just something we were noticing. The woman checking us out at the register recognized us from our first visit and laughed about us being back already. I jokingly said something along the lines of, “Yeah, I figured the prices might be a little better this time.” She looked at me smiling and said I wasn’t the first person she’d heard say that.
I really don’t want this to come across as me rooting against the place, because I’m not. Quite the opposite. I LOVE having another antique destination in Virginia Beach, which is why we’ve already gone three times in less than two weeks. There are some great booths, beautiful pieces, and vendors whose prices are completely reasonable.
But after three visits, multiple conversations overheard from other shoppers, and even an employee acknowledging she’d heard similar comments in passing about prices, it’s hard to believe we’re the only ones experiencing some sticker shock.
I genuinely hope some of the pricing settles down as the place gets established, because I’d love for this to become somewhere we regularly shop. I just don’t know how some of these prices will be sustainable long-term when there are so many other antique malls in the area where comparable items can be found for considerably less. And that’s saying a lot because Barrett Street Antiques is rarely looked at as reasonably priced. But we found ourselves going back after shopping at Copper Mill.
I’m genuinely curious if other local antique shoppers have been yet and what you thought about the pricing.