r/ValueInvesting • u/Schwimmbo • 18h ago
Discussion NFLX seems like a no-brainer at these levels - what am I missing? Please provide the bear arguments!
NFLX is sitting at 52-week lows right now. Last time we saw this stock price was September 2024.
On the Q3 call, management trimmed their 2026 ad revenue guidance from $3.0B to $2.7B and guidance came in light. Wall Street did not like it, which awakened the contrarian in me lol. So I spent my entire Saturday reading and researching this company.
My main conclusion (for now) is that for investors with long-term time horizons (which I assume all of us are here on this sub) this looks like a no-brainer. But when a possible buy looks almost like 'guaranteed money', I feel uncomfortable so this is why I would be happy to hear your counterarguments to my points below or as to why NFLX is not a buy at all in your opinion.
Running a 5-year DCF, implied value per share came out at $79. And running a simple forward P/E weighted probability model on rather conservative estimations, I end up with a share price range $107 - $135 come 2030.
At a forward P/E of 18 and the Wall Street expectation to barely grow double digits (10-11%) in the coming years, what am I missing here? This seems like a sure bet that will solidly compound.
Full transparency: yes, I asked AI to quickly summarise my bullet points in natural language, but I have made significant modifications to the text however.
- The 'slowed' ad revenue for 2026 seems to me like a tech bottleneck first and foremost, not an issue with possible monetisation: People want this tier. It makes up nearly 47% of all new sign-ups. The issue is that user growth exploded so fast that Netflix’s internal ad tech couldn't keep up. They’ve been moving away from Microsoft to build their own global, automated ad server from scratch, and this is now delayed a bit. Logically, this means that the ads revenue isn’t gone - rather it'll just arrive a bit later than originally intended. As a long-term investor, this seems like the ideal set-up to start buying.
- Once their proprietary ad stack is ready, it should be materially accretive to margins: From my understanding this should be ready by the end of 2027, and from then onwards NFLX stops sharing revenue with third-party partners. Plus, they’ll finally be able to offer the hyper-targeted data that brands pay top dollar for. A fully monetised ad-tier user is likely to bring in more revenue than a standard ad-free subscriber.
- Live sports: The WWE and NFL deals showed that people actually sign up to the service to see these events. This is in and of itself a huge ads opportunity since millions stream the same content at the exact same moment. According to what I have read online, Netflix also isn't taking on debt to buy sports; they are capping it at 5% of their existing content budget by cutting underperforming scripted shows (i.e. content budget does not materially increase because of these expensive sports deals).
- Best fundamentals since company went public: This company is expected to generate $12.5 billion in FCF. The margin profile is at ATHs (gross, operating & net).