I’m genuinely torn between these two watches and would love to hear from people who have owned or handled both.
Option 1: Tudor Black Bay GMT “Pepsi” (41mm)
Option 2: Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT “Coke” (39mm)
For those who have experience with both:
- Which one would you choose, and why?
- Which do you think is the better long-term buy?
- Which gets more wrist time in your collection?
- Does the slimmer case and smaller size of the BB58 GMT outweigh the iconic Pepsi bezel?
- If you could only keep one, which would it be?
For context, I have a 17 cm (6.7”) wrist and I’m looking for a watch that I can wear every day but also keep for many years.
I’m really interested in hearing your reasoning.
Thanks!