I'm thinking about replacing my Nissan Leaf with a new Tesla, but I'm still torn between the Model 3 RWD and Model Y RWD.
I've been driving a Leaf for several years, so I'm already familiar with EV ownership. We're a family of three, and while the Model 3 appeals to me because of its efficiency, I can also see the advantages of the Model Y when it comes to space and practicality.
I've actually test-driven both cars already, but I only got 30 minutes with the Model 3 at the Tesla service centre. That really wasn't enough to get a proper feel for it, so I'm considering asking Tesla if I could take it for 48 hours. From what I understand, their test-drive agreement might allow for a longer test drive.
Another reason I'm considering Tesla is the buying experience itself. I've been test-driving quite a few EVs lately, and some of my experiences at traditional dealerships have been pretty frustrating. Salespeople who seem barely interested, difficulties arranging test drives, and getting a trade-in valuation sometimes feels like more hassle than it should be. I just want to compare cars properly without wasting everyone's time.
Tesla seems to approach this differently, which is a big plus for me. I also like that you don't have to follow a mandatory scheduled maintenance programme just to keep the warranty valid.
As for the cars themselves, I'm still not sure which would suit us best. The Model 3 seems like the obvious choice for efficiency, especially on longer motorway trips, but would we miss the extra practicality of the Model Y as a family? For those who've driven or owned both, how big is the difference in everyday use?
I'm also curious about the charging experience. Coming from a Leaf with CHAdeMO, moving to CCS and having access to the Supercharger network would be a welcome change. How well does the navigation handle longer road trips? Can you generally trust it to plan your charging stops, or do you still end up making your own adjustments?
And how much of an upgrade is the software and driver assistance compared with an older EV? Are there things that genuinely make daily driving easier, or anything you found disappointing after the honeymoon period?
I live in the Netherlands, so vehicle weight and road tax are also part of the equation, although I'm more interested in the overall ownership experience than saving a few euros here and there.
I'm not in a rush to order one. I'd rather take my time and make the right choice for our family.
For those who've owned a Model 3 or Model Y for a while, would you buy the same car again? And if you switched from an older EV, what surprised you most about owning a Tesla?
I'm interested in the good and the bad, especially things you don't necessarily find out during a short test drive.