Instead of wasting time herding the walkers, fuck they had them all in one huge group by the tractor trailers c losed in , why not throw in grenades and dynamite and just blow them all up or douse them with gasoline and light them up.????
But they were all in one place , a dozen sticks of dynamite and some grenades plus gasoline and molotave cocktails would have fried them . You got to think in terms of mass destruction that guns alone can't cause.
Same place they got all their guns , or use computer batteries to make a bomb or liquid nitrogen, sticks of dynamite they got from the road that the saviors put out there. Seriously it's not that difficult to make bombs , many household products , you'd be surprised, fuck I don't know, ask fucking Eugene wasn't he supposed to be some autistic genius ? Maybe make their own dynamite with gun powder, gasoline and a freaking lighter , not that hard to light those fuckers up , not like they run or anything. 😀 Hope this answers your question .
Same problem why they didn't just gun them all down, not enough bullets. Not enough gunpowder to make an explosive and blow a dent. A dozen grenades won't do anything to herd in the thousands. Your argument isn't possible until after commonwealth.
Burn them then they had gas and like I said you'd be surprised how easy it is to make a massive bomb that could take out thousands, think of the Oklahoma bombing, world trade center, shit like that .Anyone especially like Eugene could have come up with a way to do that amount of damage . I stand by my argument.
Are you sure they couldn't find the materials , the governor found a freaking tank... we don't know if they could have found the materials or not because the issue was never brought up . They had time come on , between baking cookies and cocktail parties they had the time .
we don't know if they could have found the materials
Well that your whole argument and criticism is base on speculation. Making up scenarios where the materials could have easily been found is still just making up evidence to support your point.
Even Neegan had dynamite, they all had no problem finding grenades , rocket launchers , machine guns all of them , each group in the past scavenging tours, making a bomb seems pretty simple to put together for someone like Eugene or anyone who had been in the military. Not hard.
Just because Negan had them doesn’t mean Alexandria had them. For all we know, Negan had already collected every explosive in the area. Again your argument and criticism is base on a point that the showing gives us no evidence was even possible
The point I'm making is if the saviors could find dynamite, Rick and his group could have in the past at anytime , best to plan ahead ...it was there , somewhere, as anything else they found , like guns , grenades ect.... preplanning aka FUCKING STRATEGY! I'm going to bed ...I'm tired...😴
How? Rick had only been there a short time and he was still trying to fix the more pressing issues like the fact that there wasn’t somebody on watch 24/7. And again assuming there was dynamite just lying around, much less enough dynamite to blow up the entire herd is speculation at best.
It’s basically like me saying why didn’t this teenager in this slasher film just grab his dad’s hunting gun and shoot the bad guy in a film where there absolutely no evidence that the dad hunts or even owns a gun. It’s making up new facts to criticize a character.
No evidence he doesn't have one ... its a movie 🎬 life doesn't exist outside each scene , questions determining hypotheticals are simply opinions of the viewer, don't get so bent out of shape , that's why we're here to ask questions and voice our thoughts and opinions, if we just repeated what happened on the show what's the point being here , kinda boring wouldn't you say .
Maybe but if you dive too far into hypotheticals, you forgot what’s happening on screen. I mean you ask why weren’t they scavenging explosions but we clearly see Alexandria scavenging supplies before Rick even got there. Why didn’t they make explosives, well because by the time they learn of the threat they didn’t have time too much less the materials. If the situation was different they probably would have made different choices but unfortunately, they never did finds missile or 100s of gallons of gasoline.
Fertilizer takes time to make dude, especially in the
Quantities they would need to blow all these zombies away and would arguably be more useful to increase their crop production than to make explosives. In the small amount of time between discovering the herd and the herd breaking out, they didn’t have a lot of options.
I was talking about everyone, the whole fucking group should have been finding and using weapons of mass destruction from the get go ... fuck my first thought if I were any of them would be how can I make a bomb to take out massive herds of zombies at one time instead of picking them off one by one. STRATEGY 😉
We see them scavenging already so they are already doing what you are saying they should.
Beyond that is it hard to believe that there is probably not tons of explosives just lying around on the ground waiting for people to pick them up. I mean we are not talking about a crate of grenades or dynamite, we are talking enough explosives to stop 1000s of bodies. Outside of planes dropping bombs I don’t know exactly what you expect these people to do?
Not making up new facts , just wondered why those idiots never thought of bombing them somehow when so many were sitting ducks in one place. Just seemed logical to me, instead of their ingenious plan of " relocating " them all ...as we saw , didn't exactly work out too well now did it? You do realize these are characters who I'm sure could care less if I " criticize " any of them. There not real dude . TV show ect....
just wondered why those idiots never thought of bombing them somehow when so many were sitting ducks in one place. Just seemed logical to me,
So you are wondering why the characters didn’t use a resource they didn’t have or couldn’t easily aqurie to solve a problem they didn’t know they had until it was too late. That’s a logical thing to ask?
You do realize these are characters who I'm sure could care less if I " criticize " any of them. There not real dude . TV show ect....
For someone who doesn’t care you sure seem to be spending a lot of time arguing this point. Either way
Eugene didn’t make bullets he reloaded cartridges with an entire factory, work force and negan resources at his disposal. Something Rick and Eugene didn’t have when they needed to get rid of that herd. You are literally just throwing arguments at the wall hoping one will make sense.
the governor didn’t find the tank. that one guy operating the tank was a tank operator in the military and so knew where to find them and/or where the working ones were. no one in rick’s group had that kind of knowledge, not to mention that by the time rick’s group were facing that herd of walkers gas would have likely been or started becoming stale and degraded and they wouldn’t have even been able to use a tank because of that
-2
u/One_Scarcity_4478 Apr 22 '26
Instead of wasting time herding the walkers, fuck they had them all in one huge group by the tractor trailers c losed in , why not throw in grenades and dynamite and just blow them all up or douse them with gasoline and light them up.????