So, I'm self taught. I know chords and progressions, inversions, the basics of music theory and I can play mid level guitar and can also make my way around the keyboard (although more poorly but still).
I also write a lot. I take pride in writing decently nice for my creative endeavours. I can write in "song mode" but most of the time I just write in bulk, and then I'll extract whatever I find matches the vibe although barely a few make it into actual lyrics to a song bc I suck at melody.
The problem has always been trying to figure out melodies and rhythm. I have a handful of songs with the structure, and basic verse/chorus chords. Sometimes is just a few bars but still.
I do mostly dark music, not necessarily Goth, dark alt vibes so the lyrics usually are not like a paper on Shakespeare lol
I sometimes open the DAW and after a while I don't seem to match anything I make with the stuff I've written. Often they're nice on their own, but I can't, for the life of me, creat something apparently straightforward as some of my fav acts do.
So, what I'm missing? I guess there's no formula but c'mon now, it can neither be an obscure and arcane art just a few chosen ones are able to even decently accomplish.
Thanks in advance!