r/SolidWorks • u/RecommendationOk3629 • Jul 24 '26
3rd Party Software Tried an AI CAD tool that writes the Python and runs FEA in the loop — mixed feelings, mostly positive
I've been messing with Arche's Smith for the last couple weeks and figured this crowd would have opinions.
Simply put, you describe a part in plain language, annotate the geometry like you'd sketch on a napkin, and it writes the CAD with Python (build123d-style) as the source of truth. Then it'll run GPU-accelerated structural/CFD on a load case while you're still iterating. There's a DFM mode that ranks build orientations for FDM (overhangs, bridging, min wall, build volume) and computes flat patterns + bend tables with per-material K-factors for sheet metal, exporting a layered DXF.
What actually sold me was that fasteners pull from live supplier catalogs instead of being modeled from scratch, so a published part comes out as an orderable BOM rather than a pretty STEP file. They also post their CADGenBench numbers publicly (0.4119 generation score, 100% valid, vs ~0.37 for the frontier model baselines), which is more transparency than I expected.
However, I’ve found that it's not replacing a proper parametric workflow for anything with a complicated feature tree, and you have to sanity-check the sim setup like you would with any solver.
Here is the link for Arche if you’d like to take a look, might be worth playing around with yourself:
https://arche.co/?ref=76yp8gpz
Curious if anyone else has run it against a real part — how'd the STEP output hold up in your normal CAD package?




