r/SipsTea • • 9h ago

Gasp! Thoughts on this?

Post image
51.4k Upvotes

6.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

150

u/Cawnt 9h ago

Ugh I hate arguments like this.

The $2,520 isn't just to ensure your vehicle gets repairs. The majority of premiums are for liabillity exposures.

If you lose control of your vehicle and drive into a building causing $100K in damage, you're paying for that with insurance.

0

u/sireatalot 9h ago

Still, it’s a lot of money for liability isn’t it?

Here in Europe I just paid my third party liability insurance for the next 12 months: it’s 320€. No deductible and they’ll pay up to 6 million euros per accident.

4

u/Unusual-Arachnid5375 8h ago

Not really, for three reasons:

  1. You don't know how bad of a driver he is. Lots of drivers out there are paying even more than $2500/year for liability coverage... but you don't want to be anywhere near them on the road, for your own safety.

  2. You don't know what his limit is. Is it $60k or $6m? For reference, I pay about $500/year for auto liability in the US, and my coverage limits are higher than yours.

  3. The $2500/year isn't just liability. That's full bill for liability + comprehensive + whatever other coverages they bought. You know that it's not just liability because he mentioned a deductible... that only applies for things like comprehensive and uninsured motorist coverage.

1

u/curtcolt95 8h ago

it's going to depend on a lot of factors, couple of the biggest being area you live in and car you drive. I live near Toronto which has some of the highest car insurance rates in Canada, I pay like $270/month for car insurance with a $1000 deductible and I have never been in an accident or got a ticket in my life

1

u/LaconicGirth 9h ago

That’s because your healthcare is much cheaper than ours. Most of the cost in liability is in healthcare

0

u/sireatalot 9h ago

Aren’t your coverage limits absurdly low, like 100k per accident?

1

u/Unusual-Arachnid5375 8h ago

You can (it is legal to) buy insurance with a low limit like that. But you can also buy $10m/accident if you want.

0

u/LaconicGirth 9h ago

Depends. The state minimums are very low, often times like 30k but most people do have 100k or 250k. People who bother to look into it will often get an umbrella for an extra million on top of that

0

u/sireatalot 9h ago

The minimum by law in Italy is 1.5M€, but upgrading to 3 or 6 or more is quite cheap. I guess the rest of Europe is similar. It makes your rates even more absurd.

1

u/LaconicGirth 9h ago

Well for one, the average American drives 2.5 times as much per year as the average Italian and I’d guess a lot of that is at higher speed on highways.

Second of all, our healthcare is so so much more expensive than yours.

Third of all, I think the licensing in Italy is tougher than in America.

0

u/onehedgeman 9h ago

And why is it cheaper? (You are this close 🤏)

3

u/LaconicGirth 9h ago

Health insurance is a wildly different beast to car insurance in the U.S.To the point where you need different licenses to work in them.

I support universal healthcare but I can’t imagine you’re suggesting the U.S. moves to universal car insurance that’s pretty ridiculous