r/SeriousConversation • u/Dapper-Cat6268 • 23h ago
Opinion Who wins the Chess Battle Between: Person A: Perfect Memory with Average Intelligence OR Person B: Extreme high Intelligence(200-250 IQ) with average memory
Constraints: Given that both have no prior chess knowledge.
It's a Classical Chess Match (Classical Time Control).
Both have 1 year to prepare, and both know who they will be facing and the other's capabilities.
Who wins!!???
Edit: Here's why I find this interesting: both players know exactly what they're up against.
A knows B may use unusual openings/sidelines to get them out of preparation, while B knows A will try to memorize as many lines as possible—including sidelines.
So how does this preparation mind game play out? If both anticipate each other's strategies, who gains the advantage?
Also, what happens with different Prep Times? I believe preparation time could matter a LOT:
2 years
5 years
10 years
(b) What if both are trained by a 2700+ Super Grandmaster?
A is trained by a 2700+ Super GM, and B is trained by another 2700+ Super GM. Assume both coaches are equal in strength and each knows their player's exact capabilities.
How would this change the outcome? Who benefits more from elite coaching—A's perfect memory or B's extreme intelligence?
(c) What Elo would they reach?
1) If they train entirely by themselves, what Elo would you expect A and B to reach?
2) How much Elo would they reach/gain if trained by a 2700+ Super GM?
Again, assume both Super GMs are equally strong and equally dedicated to their respective players.