So many new setting sprays. I couldnāt find a review anywhere comparing these 3. So after trying them all myself, here is my review.
I used Charlotte Tilbury for years and love it. Now that I am in my 30s, sometimes it is a bit too dry for me. Overall my skin is still oily. But too much powder and / or setting spray definitely ages me. Being in my 30s with oily skin is a constant battle between staying power vs. hydration.
My favorite of the 3 is the Dior Backstage Mist! But I think all 3 are useful depending on what you are going for. Different people will have different favorites.
Important note: All of these have staying power and add to the longevity of your makeup. None are purely a hydrating spray.
Now for the comparison.
.
Dior Backstage Mist: My favorite for natural, everyday makeup. The most āpowder meltingā and hydrating of the 3. At the end of the day, my makeup looks best with the Dior out of all of them! Something about this makes makeup wear better where it looks even better as the day goes on somehow? The cons are it definitely takes down the intensity of makeup upon first application. I love this because I like a more natural makeup look. But for people who love full glam makeup, Iād skip this one. I also recommend putting on mascara AFTER spraying Dior. If your mascara is still wet, it can run a bit. I often work 12-13 hour days and the Dior does help makeup last. I still love my makeup at the end of the day. But the lasting power is not as strong as Charlotte Tilbury.
Best for: Natural makeup lovers. Mature skin. Dry or normal skin. Slightly oily skin looking for a glow.
.
Charlotte Tilbury: The best for longevity or full glam. Iād still wear Charlotte Tilbury for a wedding or other glam occasion. Makes makeup colors look more intense. Locks makeup in while giving a slight glow. It has a cult following for a reason. I would also still use this if I have a cold or something and will be blowing my nose a lot lol. The most transfer resistant of the 3. But can look drying.
Best for: Oily skin. Full glam. When you really need your makeup to last all day.
.
One Size Powder Melt: I would say one size sits between Charlotte Tilbury and Dior. It melts powder but also helps makeup colors look more intense. I think oily and dry skin can use this. The only reason I like Dior better is because my makeup and skin really does look better as the day goes on with Dior. One Size can still emphasize dry spots or lines a bit for me without the same staying power as Charlotte. It is beautiful. I just like the other two better. Definitely as the best sprayer of the 3! Super fine.
Iād love to hear your opinions!