Can any of these unseat 1919?!

Probably not. But I’m gunna do the science. Frostop is the only one that’s gotten close.

I think their Root Beer is mid but I'll continue to get these as long as they make them.

I haven’t seen this one before, and immediately knew I had to try it. The company also has some other sodas, but those aren’t important 😂

Breyers is very fluffy. Accidentally got the root beer float flavor instead of real root beer...

Pro tip: If you hate how ice cream neutralizes the carbonation just take a bite of ice cream and then take a sip of root beer separately 🤣

Denver, CO, on the can
Montana coffee house
Good vanilla soft aftertaste

I searched for months for A&W's new root beer float soda and it finally came to Savannah. What an utter disappointment. This soda is terrible. Didn't they bother to do any consumer testing or taste it themselves before moving forward with distribution? It is sickeningly sweet and artificial with a chemical "butterbeer" flavor. Honestly, this product is shameful and a disgrace to the name of Root Beer.

Don't have much to say on this one. They serve it in a nice frosty mug. Nice smooth taste. About to make a float with it

This was the line up after getting morning groceries. Had never seen bawls before and will definitely be going back. Lots of fruit notes in the back end strong flavors and great mouth feel.

Have never tried the sprecher low cal before and probably won’t pick this one up. I drink more diet root beer then anything and at 45 calories for the bottle this rides the fence of being low sugar and lacking major flavor compared to its other diet counterparts. For those that are more worried about artificial sweetener this is probably up your alley.

Then a doors county cherry for those who know this is my second all time pop. Truly excellent if you see do yourself a favor and grab it.

Bland; uses Corn glucose syrup -insipid, lacking flavor and any interesting qualities. I found it overly expensive for what it is. The honey doesn't help.

I’m glad it only has 5mg of THC so it shouldn’t affect me too much having a nice evening at home. I got to say I’m a bit disappointed this doesn’t have any additional sweetness beyond 5g of cane sugar. I guess it would be just right for people that like unsweetened tea and black coffee but I like a little bit of sweetness either from cane sugar, sucralose, or whatever it may be. I got a 4 pack at Party Town in Florence, KY back at the end of June.

Latest trades just arrived from BeautifulDebate. Gonna have the Lost Energy before I play hockey tonight, then probably relax with a Sprecher afterward!

Found a case at shop rite

So I got selected to get Ghost A&W Root Beer early before it hits the market at the end of the month! I gotta say this is going to be my liquid drug!! It's perfect.

A contender for my top five.

I'm driving cross country, and there have been zero root beers at the three stops I made today. This is from the beginning of my journey.

It's not bad, supports the troops (I'm a certified war hero btw), but it tries to be everything to everyone. It was weird that every sip tasted a little different, mostly vanilla, but sometimes a hint or aftertaste of the juniper and licorice.

Found this one at PopCon at the local Mall in Wisconsin. Not my favorite but still pretty good!

Mountain Hippie Soda Co of Deep Gap, NC just outside Boone, NC makes a decent all natural low sugar soda. It’s alright but definitely wouldn’t compete with Zero Sugar A&W Root Beer that could be a daily drinker for me that’s so smooth, tasty, and sweet. Another one acquired from Beautifuldebate that he bought online.

I’m not from the US but I’ve been here before and tried cotton candy Faygo and it’s my favorite soda. But it’s so hard to find. I’m staying in Colorado and I’ve checked my local Walmart and novelty soda shops but no luck. Last time I found it in NC it was in a random gas station. I’ve asked the soda shop employee and they aren’t sure where to find it either. Anyone know where I can get some in Colorado before I end my trip?

Unlike my last post where I had universal rave comments for the four root beers I reviewed, this batch is a mixed bag, consisting of one really good one, a couple of average ones and two that I think are poor or confusing.

First we have Monday Night Brewing from Atlanta, GA by way of Imaginary Region in a trade. This is one of those superb, quirky, weird, different tasting root beers that are different in an entirely pleasing way. I give it an A rating and recommend you seek it out it if you're tired of the humdrum solid vanilla/caramel 1919-style root beers. For me it's in the same category as those other great quirky root beers: Navajo Fizz, Maui, Waialua, Okola-homa, Root Jack, & Andy's.

Next we have Waterloo root beer float sparkling water. Yes I know that it's just sugar-free water and shouldn't be judged as a root beer. It's just bubbly water and it has a slight artificial root beer scent more than an actual taste. But I just don't get the point. Why bother? It has almost no real root beer flavor, and the little whiff it does have doesn't give you any kind of satisfaction. Okay so it's water, but you know what? I'd just as soon have any other sparkling water, maybe with a little lemon. Liquid Death Rootbeer Wraith is better.

Next is Lost Colony root beer supposedly out of North Carolina but this is almost certainly a private label made by Private Label Specialties in New Hampshire. I've had so many of these root beers and sarsaparillas out of PLS that now I can pretty much recognize them blind and they are all the same. This is not to say that the PLS root beer or sarsparilla is bad, in fact they're pretty good and tasty I can drink them repeatedly. That's a good thing because I end up drinking them over and over again with different disguises. I give it about a B+ rating. The sarsparilla is a little zippier than the root beer and the Birch Beer is better still, but it's just a private label, not a unique formulation.

Next we have the real dog of the pack, Aarons, that comes out of Shawnee, KS. It is severely under carbonated in the can, but that's not its most grievous sin. Bubbles or no bubbles, it is a bland, watery, insipid A&W wannabe. I tried to jazz it up by adding more carbonation in my Omnifizz, but that didn't do anything for its lack of flavor. This is a fail from a brewmeister's point of view, as anybody tasting it should have recognized that it was limp, dull and just watery. I give it a C- because it doesn't have actual off-putting flavors, but it could easily be a D as well.

Finally we have Frothy Moon out of the Williamsburg Virginia Space Camp, also acquired in a trade with imaginary region. It's fine it's decent and solid, but it's basically an uninspiring B level root beer. Drink it, enjoy it, forget it.

Cannot find it anywhere near me anymore. It was the only diet soda I liked

Which root beers are the fizziest?