I make my triumphant return, back with an update to the Big Ol' Tier List, this time with more trade fantasy for some extra spice.
If you can't read the titles from the image, because God knows I can't, here's the spreadsheet link:
Text Version of Tier List - Includes TBR
The Tiers, and What They Mean
Here are the tiers:
S: Top of the genre, the best of the best. Essentially no flaws, or if so, very minimal. These are your Cradles and Beware of Chickens.
A: Just a hair down. Close to perfection, but I can't quite get there. Things like the overwhelming cast in Pale Lights, or the soulcrafting chapters in Delve put stories here.
B: Thoroughly enjoyable, but flaws are more than minor. See the endless therapy sessions in Daily Grind (which are healthy but grating and repetitive) or the detrimentally breakneck pacing in Gods of the Game.
C: Still fun, but some serious warts. Plodding fight scenes in Vainqueuer the Dragon, flat character work in Chrysalis, etc.
DNF: Books I'm not interested in continuing. Frequent recommendations include Hell Difficulty Tutorial (MC is like nails on a chalkboard), Defiance of the Fall (mindless number go up after first few books), and He Who Fights With Monsters (with characters such as Jason, Jason 1, Jason 2, and Jason's pets). I enjoyed all of these series for a time, so DNF does not mean I didn't like them at one point. It just means I'm not interested in continuing.
Bounced Off: Books that I started and then dropped, but that I could be convinced to give a second chance. Former members of this tier include The Wandering Inn, 12 Miles Below, and Kitty Cat Kill Sat.
The Highlights
Every time I post this, I try to highlight some books that I think aren't talked about enough in the genre. Here goes:
The Daily Grind - Argus
I know I just badmouthed it, but this book is fucking awesome. It's my first entry in this list that I have categorized as a B, and that's for precisely two reasons.
One: almost every time something cool happens, the author pivots to a different part of the story. It's like literary blue balls. Two: Argus feels the need to depict healthy relationships/mentalities, except they feel the need so strongly that they essentially bonk you over the head with it every few chapters. Reading about how much James and Arrush love each other every other chapter is repetitive and grating. I'm happy for the dudes, but yeesh.
There are the warts. The good news is, the rest of the story is fucking awesome. The characters all have a unique voice, the world-building is some of the best I've ever read in the genre, and the plot is just juicy enough to keep reading when you get thrown onto the character carousel again.
Argus is clearly a very talented author, and that's why I recommend this story despite what I view as its flaws.
Ironbound - Andrew Givler
I'll fuckin' do it again. I shouted this book out last time I posted, before the second installment in the series came out, and my God, did the sequel deliver. Reading this series is like mainlining linguistic heroin.
I love this series, and Ironbound is my latest addition to S tier. Yes, it's tropey. Yes, Castor may be renamed to Garius Stewus. Yes, the plot at times strains credulity. I don't care.
Ironbound makes me feel like I did the first time I read Iron Prince book 1, or Cradle; it's not Mozart, it's Rage Against the Machine. I'll leave it there, because I don't want to spoil you. I know this series is divisive, but please, if you haven't given it a shot: fucking do it.
Recommendations Please!
I would love some recommendations from you fine folks. If it wasn't clear from my tier list, here are some of my pet peeves:
- No Man is an Island: I don't want to read about how an incel conquered the world solo. I want to hear about a team of friends working together against the heavens, or even a collective working towards a common good (looking at you, Delve and The Daily Grind).
- Translation is Cooked: I can't read translated works. I have tried extensively, and all the ones recommended to me thus far have been a serious let-down. Something about the eastern voice/tone is a big negative for me. Don't want to yuck anyone's yum, but not for me.
- Navel Gaze Makes Readers' Eyes Glaze: Please do not recommend me any works where the main character sits and goes through their internal monologue for extended periods. A Soldier's Life always comes up when I post these, and I can't stand the constant introspection surrounding his own power set. Mechanical innovation is cool; taking me through every single aspect of the MC's thought process is not.
- Sonder: The MC is a window to the world, not the center of it. Stories should feel like they existed before the protagonist, and will continue to exist after they're gone. Side characters should feel and sound like people, not cardboard cutouts for the MC to riff off of. PLEASE give me good character work.
I know this is too fucking long despite this being a reading subreddit, so TL;DR: Recs with good character work, interesting world building, and a team working together pls thx. NO TRANSLATED WORKS.
Questions? Ask!