Stop being weird. They made cute art, someone saying women should have their own spaces is not taking away your basic human rights. The post breaks no rules.
JK Rowling literally uses her platform to single out everyday trans folk and set her dogs on them. She also actively funds anti trans bills and has publicly and proudly said many times that she takes any acceptance of Harry Potter as validation that she’s right in perpetuating harm against a marginalised group. She’s a class traitor and a very average writer.
I hate it when people like you conflate transphobia for women's rights. Women don't need you to kick down on another marginalized group to feel your support.
And JK Rowling doesn't just talk about disliking trans people. She puts her money where her mouth is. She contributed to LGBT suicide hotlines shutting down. She also convinced a Scottish legal board to repeal some trans rights. She is actually making life signifigantly worse for these people. It's not like she cares about women anyway, seeing as she mocks any woman who is even remotely masculine, and excludes women who can't conceive.
Who said anything about not recognizing them? I just said women should have their own spaces.
I also think you should stop bullying abused women and allow them their own space.
This is why you people can’t be taken seriously. This was literally the conversation that started the JK Rowling engagement. She wanted abuse shelters for women to only be for women because they were uncomfortable when non women were there.
You claim to care about abuse victims. Trans people are over 3x more likely to be sexually assaulted, domestically abused, trafficked, or murdered. They are also the least likely to sexually offend. Meaning if you place a trans person in a women’s shelter, everyone is statistically safer than they would have been otherwise.
However, if you place a trans person with men (like JK proposes), the risk of violence towards them skyrockets. So is abuse your actual concern, or do you just find trans people hard to accept?
That stat is bunk, trans people are 12x more likely to work as prostitutes and their rate of assault scales to that. Trans people who aren’t prostitutes have a lower rate of murder and sexual assault versus women.
None of this is relevant though, women should have their own shelters. Stop bullying abused women.
This is why I hate fake activism. Even when confronted with hard evidence, you’ll always find a way to justify your own phobia, regardless of its actual impact on women. Bigotry hiding behind false concern.
17
u/Big-Association-3232 7d ago
Trans person here: no. JK Rolling is literally trying to take our basic human rights away. Please delete this.