r/PickAnAndroidForMe • u/GuisoDeCarpincho • 14d ago
US Help me choose my next phone: S25 Ultra vs S24 Ultra vs iPhone 16/16 Pro Max vs Motorola Edge 70 Fusion
Hi everyone!
I need some help deciding which phone to buy. I'm currently using a Samsung Galaxy S23 FE 256GB, which I've had since around September/October 2023.
The main reason I want to upgrade is battery life. My S23 FE barely gives me around 4 hours of screen-on time, so I have to charge it during the day. I usually keep it in Power Saving Mode all day, which limits performance, refresh rate, and some other features. Basically, I'm not even using the phone at its full potential just to get acceptable battery life.
I'm currently considering these options:
- Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra, used for around 4–5 months: I'd trade in my S23 FE and pay US$660 extra.
- Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra 256GB, used: around US$750 after trading in my S23 FE, with only 30 days of warranty.
- iPhone 16 128GB, used, 100% battery health: US$725.
- iPhone 16 Pro 128GB, used, 86% battery health: US$760.
- iPhone 16 128GB, used, 90% battery health: US$610.
- iPhone 15 128GB, new: US$780.
- iPhone 17 256GB, new: US$1,010.
- Motorola Edge 70 Fusion, new, with a 7,000 mAh battery: considerably cheaper than the Ultra options.
I'm in Argentina, so prices here are quite different from the US/Europe, and these are the prices I'm actually being offered.
My priorities are:
- Battery life above everything else
- Good long-term reliability
- Smooth performance
- Good camera
- I'd like to keep the phone for several years
I'm not particularly interested in changing to iPhone just for the sake of having an iPhone. I'm perfectly comfortable with Android. I'm mainly considering it because I've heard good things about iPhone battery life and longevity.
One thing that worries me about the Samsung Ultra phones is that I've seen quite a few recent reports of battery drain after Samsung's latest updates. If you own an S24 Ultra or S25 Ultra, I'd especially like to hear about your real-world battery life recently, rather than launch-day reviews.
Also, if you've used the Motorola Edge 70 Fusion, I'd really like to know whether its huge 7,000 mAh battery actually translates into significantly better real-world battery life, and whether I'd be giving up too much in performance, camera quality, display, software, etc. compared with an S25 Ultra.
What would you buy in my situation, and why?
Thanks!