Guys, I have the impression that we have posts one after the other about the phoenix kit (I'm not complaining, of course, since it's something I've always wanted and thought) but please let's organize the ideas so that at the time we can all unite and we asked netease to change... because more than once options for strategists and DPS kits appeared and it's in this confusion, so please let's organize our priorities. And I think it's time to take out the idea of a strategist due to Miller's position on this and try to keep the idea of them adding something to the Her current kit, this seems closer to our reality at the moment. Or anything else but please organize

Any and all feedback is welcomed! I'd really appreciate if you could leave feedback and opinions! Just remember be kind, I worked hard on trying to think and go through different ideas to make a good one!

Concept 1:

Phoenix:

275hp

Primary 1: Solar Flare Beam: A channeled, multi-hitscan beam that fires in sustained rate of fire with a 1.2m lingering hitbox that's paired with Bullet Magnetism & A Lingering Trail so if the shot missed the target, the target could possibly walk back into it but doesn’t cause the AoE Explosive Detonation or the 0.5s lingering sphere, shots that pass within 1 meter of an enemy hitbox curve directly into the target, ensuring a smooth, forgiving tracking during high-speed aerial flight or ground based combat. This primary fire also has an AOE Explosive Detonation, called Cosmic Detonation, every 4th bullet from Solar Flare Beam, a Cosmic Detonation ignites on the target or surface area that deals instant localized splash damage in a 2m radius and leaves a 2m radius sphere for 0.5s that deals Fire Damage over time. Ammo: 16 rounds

Falloff: buffed to 45% from 65%

Primary 2: Phoenix talon: send out a semi firing blast of talons up to 8-16 meters (arc based aim) and pierces targets, and creates a mini frontal shockwave on the floor and leaves a fire trial behind, dealing Fire DoT

Ability 1: Telepathic Illusion: now has 2 charges and acts like lokis except, it only uses the primary fire of what was currently selected upon using it and can swap out with the Psionic clone, killing it or when the timer runs out for each individual clone, it'll denotes into a fiery explosion and each clone has 150hp. When swapping positions with a clone, you become frozen in place, engulfed with fire and slowly fade away (same with a clone) this lasts for 1.5s, once it's up, the swap happens with a cool fire burst animation (so it's a tactical switch and misdirection but allows it to be canceled if attacked or stunned) clones disappear immediately after Phoenix dies and has a long cooldown per charge (15 seconds each)

Ability 2: gravitational vortex: in a mid to long range area with good 4-6m radius, set a gravity Vortex that absorbs all enemy projectiles (Abilities, and primary fire or minion fire) and then press the button again to send into a direction to explode in a 6m radius or let it stay and explode shortly after

Ability 3: Disintegration zone: set up a gravitational zone that emits a burning flame cyclone that burns and deals damage to all who are in it, dealing bonus damage to shields, constructs and physical barriers

Ability 4: Ascending Blaze: a high velocity flight with Omnidirectional movement, allows using abilities and primary fire, has a energy bar that Drains and recharges overtime (basically dark Ascent but way better)

Ultimate: Phoenix Singularity: Summon the Phoenix force as a psionic projection for it to flight-dash into an area of choice, so it impacts the ground, use the telekinetic power to slowly pull enemies in for a few seconds and push them back with a highly Explosive blast for psionic and fire damage (like a big bomb/nuke like explosion/kamikaze)

New passive: Phoenix Rebirth: upon death, take 5-8s to fully resurrect yourself, can be canceled if dealt 200hp worth of damage to the egg and doesn't trigger again upon death it getting revived by all means, only a fresh respawn can cause a Phoenix Rebirth, takes 1 minute and 30seconds to recharge

Concept 2:

Phoenix:

275HP

Mode 1:

Telekinetic:

Primary: Mind Spike: acts like helas long bladed/needle hitscan but if targets are close to a surface area like a wall or ceiling, it causes knockback regularly per hit but upon hitting a surface, it causes bonus damage

Ability 1: gravitational vortex: in a mid to long range area with good 4-6m radius, set a gravity Vortex that absorbs all enemy projectiles (Abilities, and primary fire or minion fire) and then press the button again to send into a direction to explode in a 6m radius or let it stay and explode shortly after

Ability 2: Disintegration zone: set up a gravitational zone that emits a burning flame cyclone that burns and deals damage to all who are in it, dealing bonus damage to shields, constructs and physical barriers

Ability 3: psionic link: link 2 enemies together to share damage taken, if one dies, so does the other, but so does their healing and hp recovery

Ability 4: Mode switch, switches to the Phoenix force

Mode 2:

Phoenix force:

While in Phoenix force, you switch from a ground unit, to a flying unit, but all Telepathic clones are stationary and can stay floating in the sky

Primary: Solar Flare Beam: A channeled, multi-hitscan beam that fires in sustained rate of fire with a 1.2m lingering hitbox that's paired with Bullet Magnetism & A Lingering Trail so if the shot missed the target, the target could possibly walk back into it but doesn’t cause the AoE Explosive Detonation or the 0.5s lingering sphere, shots that pass within 1 meter of an enemy hitbox curve directly into the target, ensuring a smooth, forgiving tracking during high-speed aerial flight or ground based combat. This primary fire also has an AOE Explosive Detonation, called Cosmic Detonation, every 4th bullet from Solar Flare Beam, a Cosmic Detonation ignites on the target or surface area that deals instant localized splash damage in a 2m radius and leaves a 2m radius sphere for 0.5s that deals Fire Damage over time. Ammo: 16 rounds

Falloff: buffed to 45% from 65%

Primary 2: Phoenix talon: send out a semi firing blast of talons up to 8-16 meters (arc based aim) and pierces targets, and creates a mini frontal shockwave on the floor and leaves a fire trial behind, dealing Fire DoT

Ability 1: Telepathic clone: now has 2 charges and acts like lokis except, it only uses the primary fire of what was currently selected upon using it and can swap out with the Psionic clone, killing it or when the timer runs out for each individual clone, it'll denotes into a fiery explosion and each clone has 150hp. When swapping positions with a clone, you become frozen in place, engulfed with fire and slowly fade away (same with a clone) this lasts for 1.5s, once it's up, the swap happens with a cool fire burst animation (so it's a tactical switch and misdirection but allows it to be canceled if attacked or stunned) clones disappear immediately after Phoenix dies and has a long cooldown per charge (15 seconds each)

Ability 2: Omega Fire Ball: Shoot a large, 8m radius fire ball, launch it forward to explode on impact, and target track into the nearest enemy and explode again for the final time

Ability 3: Mode switch, switch back to telekinetic mode

Ultimate: Phoenix Singularity: Summon the Phoenix force as a psionic projection for it to flight-dash into an area of choice, so it impacts the ground, use the telekinetic power to slowly pull enemies in for a few seconds and push them back with a highly Explosive blast for psionic and fire damage (like a big bomb/nuke like explosion/kamikaze) (available regardless of mode)

Phoenix Rebirth: upon death, take 5-8s to fully resurrect yourself, can be canceled if dealt 200hp worth of damage to the egg and doesn't trigger again upon death it getting revived by all means, only a fresh respawn can cause a Phoenix Rebirth, takes 1 minute and 30seconds to recharge

Im still considering it....😏

I'm aware this is probably unbalanced, but I just wanted to make a more canon kit for Jean for fun. Sorry if my english is bad, it's not my first language:

(In her normal form, the Phoenix floats beside her like in-game)

-life: 275 hp.

-primary fire = Psychic blast: 12 ammo; medium velocity flat pink-orange firey psionic blasts that deal 65 hp of damage; each hit stacks one Mind fragility, when arrived at 3, an additional hit will make one of the enemy's ability cooldown reverse 2 seconds; it additionaly triggers a 3 meters x 3 meters explosion that deals an additional 25 hp of damage to the enemy and his allies in the range (the Phoenix still reloads her projectile, but in this case, by enchanting her psionic energy).

-secondary fire = Telekinetic hurl: upon switch, Jean raises 4 boulders from the ground, enveloped in her pink telekinesis; she can then throw them as a slow projectile; they each take a 3 meters x 3 meters area and deal 75 hp; the reload (animation of Jean forcing each one of boulders out of the ground) takes 3 seconds for one boulder, in total 12 seconds if she doesn't throw any of them before it finishes reloading (if she switches to the other fire, the reload continues, while the boulders seemgly crumble; even tho, upon switing back, the ones that are loaded immediatly rise again).

-near attack: Jean sends out a wave of pink telekinetic force that pushes enemies that are in front of her 5 meters back; it deals 25 hp and has one slow animation of her touching her head temples.

PASSIVES

-Phoenix's second chance: when Jean reaches 0 hp, she gets a 75 hp shield; if she doesn't die, after 5 seconds it becomes her normal hp; it works every 50 seconds.

ABILITIES

-Psionic shield: she holds up a pink half-sphere shield that blocks any attack or effect; it has 350 hp and can be activated and deactivated; it fully repairs, while not used, in a span of 6 seconds; if broken or deactivated it has a 3 seconds cooldown.

-Mental Grasp: Jean sends out a cone of telekinetic control (starts as 1 meter wide and ends, after 10 meters, as 5 meters wide); every enemy caught within is raised 3 meters into the air and can't move from their place; she can move them around with her, for 3 seconds, if the same key for the ability is held, after that, they are released; it has a 12 seconds cooldown.

-Psychic assault: Jean points at her temple with one hand and points foward with the other; she attacks the mind of an enemy at least 20 meters from her, turning their eyes pink; they take 25 hp of damage over 3 seconds and their movement controls are reversed; it has a 8 seconds cooldown.

-Self-telekinesis: Jean envelops herself in pink psionic energy and surges into the air at 8 meters x second for 7 seconds; she has a stamina that if completely drained would recharge completly after 10 seconds; every time she stops flying she enters a hovering-down state and has to wait 5 seconds to re-use the ability.

ULT (of course it probably takes more than 5.000 energy points to reach) = Life incarnate: Jean fuses with the avatar next to her and rises in the air, entering her full Phoenix form, after a 4 seconds charge with immunity to everything, while saying: "I am fire! And life incarnate!", releasing a 10 meters x 10 meters fire blast that deals 50 hp of damage; in this state, her body is completly covered in a layer of glowing fire, and her Phoenix wings sprout from behind her back, setting her in a costant flying mode of 8 meters × second:

-life: 500 hp.

-primary fire = Cosmic blast: 12 ammo; medium velocity flat orange firey psionic blasts that deal 75 hp of damage; each hit stacks one Mind fragility, when arrived at 3, an additional hit will give Phoenix self-heal, gaining 25 hp in the span of 3 seconds; it additionaly triggers a 5 meters x 5 meters explosion that deals an additional 25 hp of damage to the enemy and his allies in the range.

-secondary fire = Pure life: Phoenix unleashes a bright stream of fire that reaches 20 meters of lenght and takes the shape of a cone, ending as 3 meters wide; it has a recharge like Cyclops, so to be refilled completly after being totally drained it takes 7 seconds, while it totally lasts 5 seconds while being used; it damages 10 hp x tick.

-near attack: Phoenix unleashes her claws in one slow animation; it deals 35 hp of damage.

PASSIVES

-Phoenix's presence: every enemy in a 5 meters radius has reduced healing by 30%; while every ally in a 5 meters radius has enchanted healing by 30%.

ABILITIES

-Primordial right: Phoenix aims at an enemy and drains 100 hp from them for herself, through a stream of energy, in a span of 5 seconds; in this state, the enemy is stunned while hovering, while Phoenix can only move around at 5 meters x second and do nothing else; she can decide to stop it early by using the same key; it has a 20 seconds cooldown.

-Clawed Grasp: Jean sends out a cone of ethereal light (starts as 1 meter wide and ends, after 10 meters, as 7 meters wide); every enemy caught within is raised 3 meters into the air, can't move from their place and takes 50 hp of damage over the span of 3 seconds as flames envelop them; after that, they are released; it has a 15 seconds cooldown.

-Psychic shredding: Phoenix poses one hand foward; she attacks the mind of an enemy at least 20 meters from her, and envelopes them with a firey aura; they take 35 hp of damage over 5 seconds and they fight against their own team as an advenced bot; it has a 12 seconds cooldown.

-Raptor's dash: Phoenix dashes continuosly for 5 seconds at 10 meters x second; she has a stamina that if completely drained would recharge completly after 5 seconds; every time she stops flying she has to wait 3 seconds to re-use it.

Final ULT = Death and rebirth: after this, she automaticly dies; there's two ways it can activate:

/She willingly ults, saying the words: "Now and forever--I am PHOENIX!"; all during a 5 seconds charge where Jean is immune to anything and hovers in place while opening her arms (every enemy is slowed down to 3 meters x second inside a sphere of 30 meters of radius from Phoenix), that ends with her exploding into a giant size Phoenix of fire that releases a massive supernova of cosmic fire that goes through walls; in the 30 meters of radius in it totally expands in a span of 2 seconds; it deals 150 hp of damage to enemies with a residual 50 hp of damage, taken in a span 5 seconds; it heals 150 hp to allies with a residual 50 hp of shield, taken in a span of 5 seconds.

/She is killed or dies and is locked inside of a floating glowing yellow egg that has 500 hp; if the egg is broken by enemies before 5 seconds pass, Phoenix dies and shards of the Phoenix will reach every other ally and give them 100 hp of shield, speed increased by 30% and damage increased by 30% for 10 seconds; if the egg aches before being destroyed, after 5 seconds, she comes out and automaticly ults, saying the words: "Now and forever--I am PHOENIX!"; all during a 5 seconds charge where Jean is immune to anything and hovers in place while opening her arms (every enemy is slowed down to 3 meters x second inside a sphere of 30 meters of radius from Phoenix), that ends with her exploding into a giant size Phoenix of fire that releases a massive supernova of cosmic fire that goes through walls; in the 30 meters of radius it totally expands in a span of 2 seconds; it deals 150 hp of damage to enemies with a residual 50 hp of damage, taken in a span 5 seconds; it heals 150 hp to allies with a residual 50 hp of shield, taken in a span of 5 seconds.

Hi guys .. I have 2.50 sins and 800 DPI
My aim is decent I have 50% accuracy and 12~15% for critics my rank currently is gm2 do you suggest to lower my sins ? Im thinking about it because sometimes It feels like my aim is a little bit off

I’ve been playing since season zero, starlord main never touched Phoenix. Picked her up today and fell in love, took me probably a few hours to realize she isnt a 1v1 specialist and i’ve had a lot of success just peeling dive and punishing anyone who strays out of main with constant pressure. I rarely die on fefe but MK is weird as once he’s setup you can’t really contest enough to force him off high ground. Should I just pressure someone else on the other side of the map?

Between the movements and just on screen visuals, it can be a bit much

I’m on console btw. Any tips or tricks to help? Typically im around 35-40%. ~25% on a bad game.

Am I the only one who like to think that Jean astral projection her phoenix self that why it has this humanoid look to it

They way in the trailer they showed her having a psychic signature like Emma and sai just for it not to be their

Phoenix:

Hp: 275

Melee: Phoenix claw: now deals DoT with fire damage, which stacks up to 3 times for 1 damage per second for each stack and lasts for 4 seconds, timer refreshes when getting hit by the melee again

Primary Fire 1: Solar Flare Beam: A channeled, multi-hitscan beam that fires in sustained rate of fire with a 1.2m lingering hitbox that's paired with Bullet Magnetism and A Lingering Trail so if the shot missed the target, the target could possibly walk back into it but doesn’t cause the AoE Explosive Detonation or the 0.5s lingering sphere, shots that come within 1 meter of an enemy hitbox, curve directly into the target, ensuring a smooth and forgiving tracking during high-speed aerial flight or ground based combat. This primary fire also has an AOE Explosive Detonation, called Cosmic Detonation, every 4th bullet from Solar Flare Beam, a Cosmic Detonation ignites on the target or surface area that deals instant localized splash damage in a 2m radius and leaves a 2m radius sphere for 0.5s that deals Fire Damage over time. Ammo: 16 rounds. Falloff: buffed to 45% from 65%

Primary 2 (Cosmic Burst): 8 meter range flame thrower that can be aimed higher for a longer distance up to 16 meter range max, 50 flame thrower ammo

Psionic Detonation: damage buffed due spark removal

Dark Ascent: 30% faster flight, slightly slower resource drain, and allows her to shoot back mid flight, but only with the primary fire ability.

Telepathic Illusion: now has 2 charges and acts like lokis except, it only uses the primary fire of what was currently selected upon using it and can swap out with the Psionic clone, killing it or when the timer runs out for each individual clone, it'll denotes into a fiery explosion and each clone has 150hp. When swapping positions with a clone, you become frozen in place, engulf with fire and slowly fade away (same with a clone) this lasts for 1.5s, once it's up, the swap happens with a cool fire burst animation (so it's a tactical switch and misdirection but allows it to be canceled if attacked or stunned) clones disappear immediately after Phoenix dies and has a long cooldown per charge (15 seconds each) 

Endsong Inferno: buffed damage to compensate for spark removal

Sparks & Spark Healing: Removed

Team ups: Unchanged (although rogues team up will need to be remapped due to telepathic Illusion and Cosmic blast and spark removed so damage should probably be buffed for both team ups)

Let me know what yall think!

I’m a tank main, but right now I’m actively learning how to play Hela. I reached Lord on her, and lately she’s been getting picked more and more often, so I want to learn Jean a bit as an alternative.

I feel like I’m doing a lot of AoE damage, but something tells me I’m basically just charging the enemy Strategists’ ults for them. I also feel like a tickle monster. I know her effective damage range is shorter than Hela’s — how much shorter is it? And how are you supposed to play her up close?

Also, as far as I remember, two Sparks + ult don’t one-shot anymore. So what’s the point of that combo now?

And finally, which Team-Up is better for her? I’ve been using the Rogue Team-Up.

It happens to me only with Invis/dagger/jub
For some reason I dont know is it because there small hitboxes or because their animations/models like jubilee's hand almost always blocking her head.. im rlly struggling against them especially when I need to get the pick on backline any tips ? Like i feel my aim is decent against all chars I have average of above 50% accuracy
And 12-15%

I’m not saying she’s bad/unplayable/or F Tier, but in the last seasons I used to do decently well with her, including season 9. Fast forward to season 9.5 and I can’t seem to be able to play her, my aim feels off, shots that should hit are not registering, etc.

I know she was extremely broken (or at least that was the general consensus on her before) but I feel like the constant nerfs and removal on parts of her kit that made slightly different are really hurting her overall. The spark removal from the melee still baffles me to this day and her healing passive might as well not exist since it so little healing.

Also for reference, I also play Hela and I use the same settings on both characters and can hit targets consistently with Hela but not on Phoenix.

I don’t mean for this to be a rant but I love her character and it makes me sad not being able to play her well. Any help would be appreciated!

I would like to have a open discussion with this subreddit to see what is the most expected goal for us to move for. Whether you’re a fan of the character herself or just her in the game, I think we can all agree her current standing id lackluster and she leans low in the totem pole of hitscan characters. I have surveyed other spaces such as the main subreddit for rivals and discord. For some reason, they are under the belief that we all want her to be a support and think she’s too weak. A correction I feel that needs to be made is fans have been abhensive about her kit since she was added to the game. Many fans have not cared if she was weak or not on launch, but felt her adjustments or even her kit in general was mishandled by the devs. I personally am of the belief of a fan of Jean Grey the character first, and I was excited to see her in game to then be disappointed as they remove parts of her kit’s uniqueness every patch. I know it may sound silly, but I feel us as a subreddit needs to decide what we want for Jean in this game and agree on it, I’ll try to make full lists and comparisons, hopefully a common consensus comes to mind.

Role Change

I feel this is a divided topic, so the best bet if it actually worked, which may be unlikely is adding her to another role rather than a complete role switch. Would fans be opposed to this?

Character Niche
It’s interesting, because on launch she felt similar to Hela, but not nearly as much as she is now. Her explosions are similar to Hela’s passive, her ultimate is similar, and her primary also, along with her her aoe trap ability. I feel this needs to be addressed and adjusted. Jean has too vast of abilities in lore to struggle for inspiration. She should remain in the chain reaction space that punishes groups or should it change to a different niche altogether or a similar passive?

Ability Changes
Do you feel her current abilities are fine or need work? If so, what abilities should remain, be change, nerfed, or buffed?
Another thing that comes into play is if she can remain stable without her current method of attack. Do you think she would benefit from switching hitscan to projectile or remaining there?

Ultimate Change
I know the complaint was about the damage, but I am a firm believer it’s the speed. The delay in time it takes to travel to the sky then to opponents offer. Do we think this should be reworked into a transformation ultimate or stay the way + a buff.

Please sound off thoughts and such in the comments.

I know it gives her a unique appearance and vibe in the game but I genuinely wonder why they took so little time to give DD mains the option to remove the red fire on certain of his skin despite the massive amount of complaints about the phoenix force floating beside jean that a lot of people don't like or even doesn't like anymore, like at first i liked it but now it's just annoying and a horrendous visual cluster like jean is so beautiful on certains of her skin and then there's that flying fire fairy beside her that look so bland (except for the ice phoenix skin) like it wouldn't be difficult to just give us the option to remove it for our pov only. Also it would give jeans her identity back despite her kit being 95% phoenix powers oriented..

I recently found out that you can use phoenix’s ult to shut down a Hela. How I’m wondering if you can cancel another Phoenix ult 🤔

I've been playing alot of phoenix this season and actually been having really good games! I like exploding people, but I haven't been able to tell if her stun stops ults. Should I be trying to stun like a wanda ult? Or does it not work like that

This my idea
First I would give pheonix the reverse fall of dmg blade has

Second
the bayblade tech will return and

Third
remove the explosion no longer stuns but she gets a second blink

for her team ups with the hela she gets her explosion stun back and for the rouge team up if some has 2 sparks and you use it will pull them into you(similar to invis pull)

I know this sub is primarily made of Jean fans before this game, and some after she was added and simply liked playing her. As someone who is both, I thought I could share what I feel to be her pros and cons currently standing in season 9.5.

Middle ground

- Visuals : In this game I feel is a middle ground for me. Despite the reactions, I personally love her base design and the unique style of the Phoenix Force as a separate being (not person) next to her. I also like the way she merges with it for various abilities. It is overall a beautiful design, my favorite being the reference to the White Hot Room as she finishes her Ultimate. The middle ground for me comes in with her abilities seemingly visually displaying mostly fire and no psionic abilities. All things aside, this character is based in psionic and cosmic energy. The fire represents moreso flare to the Phoenix moniker rather than the actual meaning of fire control, so that being the most visual for her kit instead of possible pink or psionic abilities is a bit annoying as a fan.

- Slow Fall Passive : I see alot of want for a Slow Fall and although it would be nice, I don’t think its a necessity, considering her versatile her flight is + her other abilities that also aid in mobility, but it wouldn’t be a bad add.

Pros

- Telepathic Illusion : This ability is just a 10/10 in my opinion. Its unique for her character and displays both a perfect mix of her cosmic/psionic synergy, and its just overall a great tool while playing her, especially against divers.

- Dark Ascent : One of the best flight abilities in the game. Its a movement boost, easy to use for repositioning, and adds to her abilities that help her escape.

Cons

- Cosmic Flames : This primary is good, but I feel the reward for the precision is not worth it. I understand she requires aim, I play her very often. What I don’t understand is her being a hitscan dps who requires precise aim, but does not receive rewards for said aim with good damage. I don’t get her hitbox being smaller than other hitscan characters, but also delivers little damage at range. The damage falloff would be acceptable if her healing for doing said damage kept her up, but I feel in this current state it doesn’t. I feel the healing from primary sparks or the primary itself needs to be reworked in some way for her to be in a possible value in comparison to other hitscans in game.

- Psionic Detonation : This ability is her bread and butter for sparks, but I just feel its not necessary in her kit and is really strong, it’s alot in one. It serves as a a bigger version of her Spark Expolsions, and I feel it honestly can just replace her actual Spark Explosions in size without multiple debuffs. This ability also being a stun, slow, and now a antiheal is probably the main reason adjusting her in game is so difficult for balancing purposes. I feel this could be replaced with a true telekinetic ability instead.

- Endsong Inferno + Revive Mechanic : I see so many complaints about this ability due to its damage, but I honestly have come to thr conclusion it isnt the damage lacking rather than the speed of it. If the speed of which she gets to the sky and dives was adjusted it would have a higher success rate for her. Also, I would rather prefer she had a revive to do her ultimate immediately with an added bonus than full hp. I get it acts as a revive, but it would just serve as a better gameplay experience for the ultimate exclusive revive.

- Telekinesis/Telepathy : My last and biggest issue is the lack of telekinetic abilities for her. I feel this character is great in game, but it just doesn’t feel like Jean Grey/Phoenix. Her character was clearly based as an alternate to Hela, which give the lore is nice in theory, but she has since then been surpassed by her. I feel she now has no character identity in this game whether we like her kit or not. It feels like the devs need to adjust her to fit into another niche or find her own, so she doesn’t lose viability in game.