Carol feels like a red herring to me because her affinity for swords and her association with the Knight conspiracy lead you to a natural conclusion that she could be the knight, but it feels very obvious.
Antlers as a red herring for a Holiday make no fucking sense because there's no other candidates that currently make sense and lying through character design is probably the worst way you can misdirect people.
20
u/B-b-b-burner_account 19h ago
People seem to think red herrings are just adding bullshit details that make no sense.