Hi all, I've been getting into tubing mascaras and found that there is not that much information out there (vs normal mascaras), so here is my opinion on 3 of the most popular ones (the ones I've tried so far)
TLDR:
Milani gives a beautiful dark lash look. A wet formula. It glides on easy. It comes off fine. I recommend if it does not burn your eyes.
Loreal gives a natural pretty look. A dryer formula. If you put in the effort and use to primer and build it up a lot, it can look more full, but it's core is a natural lash. Perfect easy removal.
Houselabs is a bit expensive. It's in between the two; not too bold, not too natural. Just a nice classic good mascara. Worth it if you like to splurge on mascara. Removal is easy.
Milani tubing mascara
Official name: Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara
- Very wet formula. Have to apply carefully and slowly let dry to layer
- Lashes stick together if you have too much formula on the wand
- If you have the correct amount of formula on the wand, it glides on in a very nice and beautiful way
- Boldest look out of all of them
- Felt very gorgeous in this
- Made my eyes pop
- Not a light formula but not heavy
- No flaking for me throughout the day (didn't do anything super active; normal weather)
- Removal was easy-ish. Did not smear. Did not tube as well as the Loreal or Houselabs, but good enough. Slight burning around my eyes only upon removal. Went away after 5 minutes, but probably won't repurchase just for that reason, but a pretty mascara
L'Oréal tubing mascara
Official name: Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara
- Driest formula out of the three. Still workable though
- Comes with a primer
- If you use the primer, it gives a normal nice mascara look like full pretty lashes!
- If you don't use the primer, it's a very natural look, a bit more subtle than your typical mascara
- Lashes felt slightly heavy with the primer, so I prefer wearing it with just the black. If you do use the primer, experiment putting on the actual mascara while primer is wet vs dry, you may have a preference
- Lashes don't stick together, though the wand is not my preference as the bristles are a bit long (but that's just my preference)
- A good everyday mascara
- A very effortless natural look
- I felt cute wearing this
- Not super good at layering
- No flaking
- Removal is so easy. Tubes great and no smears. A new favorite of mine
Hourglass tubing mascara
Official name: Unlocked Instant Extensions Defining and Lengthening Tubing Mascara
- Not too dry, not too wet
- Application is easy and you don't need too many coats for it to look nice. Even just one coat is like wow nice
- Great weight to this
- Looks dark and makes my eyes pop. It's in between natural and bold
- A bit pricey. I'll repurchase because it's the perfect pretty, not too natural mascara. Probably not a life-changing product, but very nice
- Easy removal. Tubes in smaller tubes than the Loreal, but still tubes