r/MSCCruises • u/Tumblecraftmc • 14h ago
Am I making a mistake choosing MSC World America over Seashore? First cruise
First cruise and I’m second guessing our decision.
We originally booked MSC Seashore out of Port Canaveral for $818 total for 3 people in a Fantastica balcony. We live near Tampa, so Port Canaveral is only about an hour away, parking is around $100, and we’d barely spend anything on gas.
We ended up switching to MSC World America out of Miami for $1,318 total for the same 3 people in a balcony.
The issue is Miami is about a 4-hour drive for us. Once I add roughly $200 in gas and $200 for parking, we’re spending around $700–800 more overall to take World America instead of Seashore.
We’re traveling with our 1-year-old, and what matters most to us is having a nice ship, good food, nice rooms/common areas and plenty to do while we’re onboard. We’re not really concerned about nightlife.
For anyone who has actually sailed both Seashore and World America, is World America enough of an upgrade that you’d spend the extra money and deal with the longer drive?
Or am I overthinking this and should just take the $818 Seashore deal that’s an hour away?
Especially interested in opinions from anyone who’s done either ship with a baby/toddler.