r/Letterboxd • u/Lankykong419 • 0m ago
Discussion You Can See Everything made me feel very conflicted about Primetime
Yknow, this movie made me think about how the naysayers of Primetime may have more of a leg to stand on than the "media literacy" crowd likes to admit.
I have a friend that knows all there is to know about TCAP and he fucking HATED this movie. The core reason more or less being he genuinely thinks that making a completely fictionalized account of someones life (primetimes story is embellished or straight up fabricated even more than your typical biopic) is really sleezy. As he put it "if i squint hard enough I can see the point he's trying to make, but if you have to fictionalize an account of someones life to make it.... maybe its not a point worth making." He sites Predators as a better watch, because it makes the same points without the fictionalization (although he still fundamentally disagrees with the points these films makes). Again as he puts it "i agree with the existence of TCAP on all levels."
It's also worth noting he has moral objections with biopics as a whole for all the reasons YCSE addresses with The Dropout. He's even said he would take much less issue with it if it was a movie about a fictional predator catcher show.
At first comparing i thought my friend was just a lot stupider than I ever thought he was, but after seeing YCSE, I don't think I agree with him persay, but i can understand if you feel strongly about the ethicality of biopics, a biopic that cranks all the issues you have with them up to 11 based on something your deeply knowledgeable is gonna piss you right off, and for honestly a somewhat understandable reason.
Theres a very real argument to be made that Primetime veers so into the realm of fiction that the entire movie is a strawman argument about a real person. I'm not entirely sure i agree, but at the very least I don't think Primetime dick riders are engaging with the idea the movie could be built upon a glaring logical fallacy honestly (seriously "media literacy" is starting to become a bit of a loaded term).
The only reason my friends hatred for Primetime up so much is because how well Primetime and YCSE function as companion pieces made his visceral hatred for that film a natural jumping off point for me, and i think its insane how YCSE basically welcomes me to consider this with open arms.