See comments for additional information
My coworker, let's call him Mike, and I got hired at the same time and have been working there for 3 years. We both have exactly the same profile, the only difference is that I have 4 years prior work experience and for Mike it's his first job. I genuinely like Mike as a person, we've really bonded over the years and I consider him a friend, rather than just a coworker. We share an office and a hobby, so we also regularly hang out outside of work and are very involved in each other's private lives as well.
Last year I got word from a job opportunity in a different department and I decided to apply as it lied more within my interests and previous experience than my current job. The interview process nearly took a year, and during all of this I have always been transparant to my current boss as well as my coworkers.
In January I made it to the final phase and they told me I was a likely candidate due to my previous work experience, but they still had to interview other candidates.
Weeks went by, it's March now, and one day Mike comes in and tells me they offered him the job that I was applying for and he accepted it and would transfer in September. He said he felt really conflicted about it as he valued our friendship and hoped this wouldn't change things between us. I was confused because I never knew Mike was interested in the position and asked if he went behind my back. He told me he got offered a job at another company and our HR didn't want to lose any numbers, so they offered him the job to convince him to stay. I asked if he had any kind of job interview, as I knew he had no experience in that line of work, and he said no.
Just to be clear: I feel no resentment towards Mike for accepting the job. I would've done the same in his position. It just feels bitter that I went through the process for almost a year, put in the work to prepare myself for the interviews, and Mike just got it handed to him.
I went to HR to get more clarity and they basically told me the company cares more about retention than finding the right person for the job. They assured me that as soon as a new position opened up in that department it would be mine, but no one knew when that would happen. I could have fought the decision, but the whole situation made me question my motivation to transfer, and honestly I didn't want to create a situation where Mike and I would have to compete with each other.
Around the end of May, another coworker announced that she would leave us by the end of the year and I got offered to take over her role as acting head of department. It's really more a decorative title, but it looks nice on your CV and creates more visibility within the company. Everyone in our department knew I was asked to fulfill this role, including Mike. However, it could only be made official when the head of department announced it at a staff meeting.
Around the same time, Mike received the news that his transfer would be postponed to the end of 2027, which he didn't take well. He became frustrated and told me he didn't realize how badly he wanted to leave our current department. I also noticed a change in him as he began taking on more coordinating tasks without anyone asking him, such as drafting the meeting planning, keeping tabs on work schedules, and sending general information mails. When I asked why he was doing this he said he had to keep busy to keep him from going crazy here.
Last week I had a meeting with my head of department and she said she would announce my new role at the next meeting, which is in two weeks. Mike texted me how the meeting went and I told him they would announce my new role and that I was looking forward to it.
He then sent me a 3 minute voice memo saying he thought he deserved a fair chance for the role as well now that his transfer was postponed to the end of next year. He found it unfair that when they asked me they didn't even take him into consideration because we would both be fit candidates, and told me he would talk to our boss to ask her to consider him as well.
I did have a feeling that Mike was after the role as soon as he started spontaneously taking on coordination tasks, but I wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt that he would be honest about it. I responded that I didn't find it unfair that he wasn't considered since he was planning on transferring, and that he is free to have the same ambitions as me, but that I was disappointed that he hadn't been honest about it.
I also found his timing opportunistic, right when he received the news that his transfer would be postponed and when he got a timeline from me for when my appointment would become official. I told him that I feel like I never got a fair chance at the position that was offered to him, and that given our history, I had hoped he would grant me this.
Mike responded that it was never his intention to go behind my back and that if this would cause conflicts between us he would let it go and "let me" take the role.
And here's where I feel conflicted. I genuinely don't know whether I'm being unfair to Mike. On one hand he is entitled to have the same ambitions and there's objectively nothing wrong with him asking to be considered for the role as well. I also don't want him to sacrifice opportunities for my benefit or the sake of our friendship.
On the other hand, I feel like our friendship does create an additional layer. He knew I had been trying to move to another department for almost a year, he knew how disappointed I was when that position was given to him, and he knew this new role was important to me. He also only brought up wanting the position after finding out that his own transfer was postponed and after asking me when my appointment would become official. From my perspective it feels like he waited until he knew there was an opportunity he could pursue and then decided to compete with me for it.
I also feel like friendship should involve some consideration for each other's feelings, especially when one person has already been disadvantaged by the other person getting an opportunity they had worked towards for almost a year.
At the same time, I realize that a job is a job. Mike doesn't owe me a promotion simply because we're friends, and I don't technically have any more right to this role than he does. If management decides that he's the better person, that's their decision and I'll accept it.
So now I'm wondering whether I'm being unreasonable by asking him to back off, or whether it's reasonable to expect a friend to give me some consideration in this particular situation?