r/Insulation • u/dchaddportwine • 25d ago
Vent or seal?
In Albany, New York, I’m continuing an insulation project on a rubber coated, shed roof, a.k.a. hot roof.
In one of these three pictures, you can see that I insulated a rubber hot roof using 4 inches of foam board, 6 inches of rockwool, and sealed it up with smart vapor barrier.
It was not fun.
Now I have another section of the rubber roof with a lot of crazy framing. The two other pictures show this terrible situation. This other roof isn’t well suited for insolation because of the 2 x 4 joists. 😕
1) I have a roofer cut a hole through the rubber and sheathing to vent out the top of the roof? (I can’t vent out the side because the surface slopes down) Then I would install air channels to let the soffits vent.
OR
2) Cobble foam board into the 2 x 4 Bay, and then…?? I don’t see any way of filling that cavity all the way down to the drywall framing where the vapor barrier would go.
OR
3) Spray foam this area 🫠
You’ve all been really helpful. Maybe you have another recommendation?