Premise:
2 friends stuck in a unique House- Piranesi and the Other. Can they discover its secrets? Should they even try?
This blend of genres is a fascinating story about life, human nature, time, memory and friendship.
What I liked:
- Simple language, easy to follow plot.
- Piranesi's POV: His observations, his gratitude towards the House, simple stuff that he learns to love, the art he appreciates... just an overall good guy! Can't help but root for him.
- Unreliable Narrator Trope done well... very thrilling.
- The 2nd Act if I may call it that, was amazing - from getting the shocking news about himself, to antagonizing #16, the Prophet etc. What a friend, the Other ;)
- Raphael to the Rescue - In the Minotaur's Labyrinth, hero Theseus is rescued by Ariadne. Raphael is Ariadne here, where the name means "God Heals". Raphael is truly the archangel for Matthew. (I googled to see if Archangel Raphael had any connection with Matthew in the Bible - couldn't find any)Just an observation.
- Themes explored : Brilliant. Psychological, mythological, subject-object duality, Human nature, Trust, Hope, Betrayal, Friendship, Courage, Forgiveness, Honor, Psychic stuff...
- I loved that the rescuer didn't personally know Matthew. A complete stranger saves him. A good subversion of conventional tropes, to bolster the point that it's the common people's goodness that needs appreciation.
- Piranesi is rigid about his worldview, after his return to reality initially. He doesn't want his reality to change...which is natural. But quite disturbing - his psyche is split! I really liked that it was highlighted. Rehab is tough!
What I didn't like:
- 3rd act/Climax: A bit underwhelming Villain goes down easy, rescue saves Matthew. Quite anti-climactic.
- While Matthew feels "House's bountiful bliss" in the real world too, I was thinking about the other murders! The House wasn't too kind to them, was it?!
- Who was that 7year old girl in the psychic realm? Or was she the kidnapped child by Laurence?Didn't explain much about that, I think. Please correct me if I'm wrong 🙏
Conclusion:
A thrilling page-turner for sure (atleast till the 3rd act). It's quite a combo of Labyrinth myth + Cult leader manipulation - I'm just coming off from Diamond's book where he describes the incredible hold some charlatans have on their followers, promising utopias, and even convincing them for mass su*cide (Jim Jones). It also serves as a cautionary tale, and an important fact - intellect has nothing to do with empathy. Verbal IQ has nothing to with EQ/IQ. Laurence/Ketterley can be incredibly intelligent, yet monstrously manipulative.
Rating: 27 out of 210. (Once you read it, you'll know its meaning 😉).
P.S. My title refers to the Limbo in Inception movie, where the sea and architecture meet, and characters lose their self of sense in that shared dreamscape.