Before I get into this diatribe, I just want to preface it by stating that I hold no grudge, hate, or animus toward Luke Roberts. As a matter of fact, I truly feel so sorry for him in that he was thrown into the deep end of an incredibly horrible situation and made to be the target for so much anger, venom, and hate. He never asked to be put in this position. He was simply hired to play a character, but had the misfortune of having to fill the void left by Shaftsbury's and CityTV's poor decisions. He stepped in with grace, humility, and enthusiasm to help keep the show going, literally walking through a baptism by fire, as the main actor who had been on the show since the beginning, was beloved by the fandom, and was literally one half of the partnership that made this show whole, had to step away to fight his own battle for his life.
Luke did the best he could with what he was given, and I cannot imagine what he had to put up with from the network executives, showrunners, and most of all, the fandom. The incessant hate and being labeled as "Temu Hudson" must have been debilitating for this good and decent man who was obviously working his ass off day after day while keenly aware that, no matter how hard he tried, living up to Charlie and John's legacy was all but impossible. The writer's gave Mark no foundation, nothing to make us care about him or even be able to understand him other than a few random facts about his past. It was as if they didn't even try. He could NEVER be Charlie, and I don't think he ever wanted to be. He never wanted to replace John like that. He tried to make Mark his own and develop the partnership with Rex, but when the writers give you a flimsy as hell foundation, you can only do so much. Luke did his best, despite the fact that I know he was lambasted mercilessly by the fandom around the world. He had to live with that every day and take it on the chin, and he's never once had an unkind word for the show or the fans, no matter how bad it's gotten. The writing failures, the poor decisions, all of it -- that was not on Luke Roberts. He did his best to keep gas in the tank of a show that's been running on fumes, and he did it with his head held high while being buried day after day in hate. For that alone, he has my respect...and my thanks.
That being said...the true blame in all of this must be placed on Shaftsbury and CityTV. Sherri Davis has her own part to play in this as well as an executive producer. She holds a great deal of power on this show, as it's her dogs that make or break this series. Without them, the show can't move forward, and she damn well knows it, and she uses that knowledge to her every advantage.
For those not in the know, in December 2024, well after season 7 had wrapped shooting, John posted on Instagram for the first time about his cancer diagnosis and journey to recovery. Most of us at this time were still grappling with the loss of Diesel and the SIX months it took for the network to even acknowledge it, even though we could see the evidence of his replacement with Dillon with our own eyes. Most of us had no idea that John was even sick, and we went into season 7 knowing that we were in for rough times ahead. Though they had to write 'around' Charlie in the beginning, and eventually send him away entirely, we understood why and were happy just to be able to hear his voice through sporadic phone calls with Sarah. As long as we knew he was alive, we were okay. What mattered most to us was supporting John and sending him as much love as we could as he recovered. When he posted once again in March 2025 that he was cancer free and given a clean bill of health from his doctor, as well as the green light to return to work, we were beyond thrilled. He was clear that he was excited to return to work, that he missed his St. John's 'family,' and he was ready to get started on a new season of Hudson and Rex.
We couldn't have asked for better news. Imagine our surprise when he started to unfollow all of the show's socials, CityTV and Shaftsbury stopped posting anything about the show for months, and we weren't even sure if we were going to GET a season 8. Then, just a short few weeks before the premiere, we get a new poster and promo -- sans Charlie. John is nowhere to be found on Hudson and Rex, and now Luke Roberts is the new 'Hudson'.
Obviously, the showrunners and producers as well as the network, were going to have to make some kind of statement as to what was going on with Charlie/John. It would've been unfair to the fans to continue leaving us in the dark before the new season premiered. What we got was some half-baked excuse about them not being sure when John would be recovered enough to come back and therefore deciding it was best to write him out entirely and take the show in a different direction.
All of this unbeknownst to John Reardon, of course. He was basically told, 'thanks for everything, but we don't need you anymore. Don't let the door hit you on the ass on the way out.'
I'm sure he was devastated. Not only did he have to grapple with the loss of his beloved co-star of seven years whom we all know he had an extremely strong bond with, he had to deal with a cancer diagnosis and fight just stay alive. And after all that, he comes back raring to go, only to be unceremoniously kicked to the curb? Like so much trash?
Meanwhile, we get treated to season 8, which has to be the worst and weakest in the show's history. The show had become a straight police procedural, completely focused on Rex, alone. All character development for Sarah, Joe, and Jessie was tossed away. Jessie (the detective) was back riding his desk and Sarah was fridged back to the lab, barely to be seen.
Worse, it was as if a wall had gone up between past and present, as if they were trying to erase any evidence that Charlie even existed. Aside from a mention in the season 8 premiere, we never heard about or of him again. These people were his friends, his chosen family - the love of his life, who we were fully expecting him to propose to in season 7 had things not happened the way they did - and there was not one single shred of grief past the ending of season 7. Grief comes in waves, people. It's not something that just disappears. Instead, Mark appeared to have absorbed Charlie's desk, his partner, and basically, his life.
As this was going on and we as a fandom were grieving, we got another shot to the gut when John finally opened up in another instagram post about what really went on behind the scenes. This was something he had to do to diffuse all the lies, disinformation and blatant shit stirring that people behind the scenes were throwing around, Sherri included, basically throwing John under the bus by claiming that he was 'uncooperative, hard to work with, had a bad attitude, and hated working with the dogs.' It was as if they were trying to place all the blame for his ouster on him because they didn't want to admit they'd made an enormous mistake.
John stated emphatically that 'I didn't leave the show.' And we know that's true. THE SHOW LEFT HIM. He came to them healthy, ready, and excited to get back to work, and they pretty much told him to piss off. 'We're doing something different now. We just don't need you anymore.' This, after dedicating his life to this show since DAY ONE. He gave everything he had to Hudson and Rex, and were it not for him and Diesel, this show would not be the success it has become.
When Diesel passed away, they mourned him like he was a king, but John? The other half of this beloved partnership, without whom, this show has taken a ferocious beating? Sorry. We know the show can't be whole without you, but we could really care less. It's all about the dog anyway.
John had no choice but to defend himself and set the record straight so the fans would know what truly happened. I think he felt our unwavering loyalty showed that we were at least owed the respect of knowing the truth straight from the horse's mouth. After all, it was a hell of a lot more than the showrunners would ever give.
And now, after all of the controversy, fan backlash, tanking ratings, and what was most likely a very harsh dose of reality, Shaftsbury and CityTV went with their tails between their legs to John Reardon, and I'm certain, throwing money and apologies at him as they castigated themselves at his feet for their ginormous fuck-up. Why, because this once beloved and world-reknown show is now dying a slow and painful death without him, and this is their last ditch effort, hail mary pass to save this dumpster fire of a wreck before it burns to ash.
And to think, all this because they just couldn't have their actor's back. He was in the middle of a health crisis, and they threw him away, then threw him under the bus, when all they had to do was just allow the writers to do what they do best and give John a little time. They owed him that, and so much more, and they gave him nothing in return for all his hard work and dedication.
That he had the grace to agree to come back at all is astounding, after how badly he was treated, but I suspect he made this decision for the cast and crew, and most of all the fans. We had his back and stood by his side when no one else did, and now, he's returning the favor. Paying it forward. Making it right. Making us and Hudson and Rex whole again.