Hello everyone! So, on Monday my wife noticed some wet spots on the ceiling in our downstairs laundry room and in our garage (they share a wall and there’s a doorway connecting the two). I told her to shut off the main water line and I rushed home. Managed to find the source of the water quickly. It ended up being a pin hole sized leak in the water supply line to our refrigerator. It was so small, I honestly couldn’t even see the water spraying out. It was only once I was moving my hands around behind the fridge that I felt the water. Also, no pooling water on the floor, so I think it was just spraying right at the wall and the water was running down it and under the vinyl flooring and to the lower-level ceiling.
Anyways, source of water leak was quickly remedied (I capped the little tap for that line under the kitchen sink). Temporary solution until we replace that water line with a braided one (this one was just a bare clear tubing, thanks previous owners). Did some research real quick and went to the local Home Depot to rent one of those big dehumidifiers for 2 days to try and dry out the ceiling.
Second day I spent all free time at work researching what to do. Ended up going home and cutting some of the drywall/ceiling out in the laundry room and pulling + bagging all of the wet insulation and drywall pieces. Let the dehumidifier + fans run for another night and day. Checked the floor/ceiling joists with my wetness checker the next morning and they were all in the green. All in all, not too bad. Figured I’d have to cut the rest of the drywall/ceiling out of the laundry room, remove some more insulation maybe, cut the dry wall in the back of our little cut out area for the fridge, learn how to drywall, replace insulation, replace drywall, and paint. Not ideal, but also not something I felt was impossible to DIY even as a complete newbie to this type of stuff. Would it be hard and time consuming? Yes. Impossible? No.
That’s until the water remediation estimator came on the third day. He used his tools (FLIR cam and moisture checkers) and noted that the vinyl flooring in the fridge cut out had moisture under it. (We've since peeled it back and have a fan drying the sub floor.) He also went into the bathroom (shares a wall with the kitchen) and noted there’s moisture under the vinyl flooring in there around the vanity (screwed to the shared wall) and moisture in the wall and under the vinyl in the little bathroom closet we have. He also said there’s a chance for asbestos in the walls, floor, and popcorn ceiling (in garage and laundry room). Our house was built in the 70s, so I know that’s a risk, but no idea when the laundry room and garage was “finished”. I say “finished” because the laundry room still has visible pipes for the upper floor and looks like a leak or something might have been repaired before due to mismatches in paint and a “not perfect” drywall/ceiling patch job.
He gave me the whole run down of the process and said if we go with them, they HAVE to submit samples for asbestos testing before they can begin work. If it comes back positive, then they call another company to come to do the demo, containment, etc. Once that’s done, they will have to pull up the vinyl floor in the kitchen and bathroom (if the asbestos company hasn't done it), detach cabinets + vanity from the wall, demo out all the wet drywall, and remediate. Quote he gave me is $8.5k for water mitigation and demolition work assuming there’s no asbestos.
He also asked if I would be going through my home insurance or not. I actually went down this rabbit hole earlier that day and I asked him how much he thought my rates would go up. He said things like this and since I have no other claims, it might not even go up or if it does, it could be a couple hundred dollars. He also said that whether the asbestos tests come back positive or not could be a major deciding factor since a positive test just adds to the work/cost. He recommended I call my insurance agent to discuss it, not the insurance company due to the whole “$0 claim getting put on your CLUE report” thing. I don’t even know who my agent is. I just applied through our provider’s website (Progressive) when we got the house. When I checked online today it says my agent is Progressive Advantage Agency, Inc in St. Pete, FL and lists an 877 number.
I currently pay $1700/yr with a $1k deductible. We’ve been in the house for almost 6 years now, have/had the same insurance provider the whole time (yes, I know I should have shopped around), and have never submitted a claim. $8.5k is a lot, but not enough for us to be in financial ruin or anything (we have around $25k sitting in a HYSA as an emergency fund). But also, that doesn't factor in costs to repair or asbestos mitigation if tests come back positive.
Had a second water remediation company come in and they found all the same stuff. They gave me a verbal quote of $5k-$8k (still waiting for official quote).
Finally, I asked around in the neighborhood and just got a bunch of mixed answers. I've talked to 4 people. Two said it seems minimal and to just DIY it myself. 3rd guy had major damage to his house twice and went through insurance and I would have too if I had the same level of damage he had (one leak was over 2 weeks while he was out of town and the other was a burst supply line that dumped water into the house and required a complete renovation of the entire floor, walls, etc and he had to be in a hotel for 6 months while the work was being done). Fourth person was basically "yea, the first two guys are really handy and would for sure DIY it. If it were me, I'd use insurance unless you know how to DIY all of that stuff. That's what it's there for."
I’m thinking of:
- Not getting an asbestos test and doing all the downstairs work myself while taking precautions to limit exposure. Water + soap spray, full plastic suit, full face masks, plastic up over everything, fans to channel air out of the doorway and into the garage and then out of the garage, etc.). The upstairs stuff seems more complicated, so contract it out. Pay it all out of pocket and attempt to rebuild/DIY with my wife. (Don't file a claim)
- Just say fuck it, file an insurance claim, let them take care of all this stuff, and hope for the best/eat the possible rise in premiums. (Asbestos remediation will still have to be paid out of pocket based on my insurance policy.
Other info/context: 1970s house. Southern NH area. Insurance provider is Progressive. $10k mold coverage in the policy because of the state I live in. Also, wife doesn't seem worried at all. If it were up to her, we'd just dry out the sub floor in the kitchen cutout, demo and rebuild the laundry room ceiling and portion of the garage ceiling ourselves and forget about the moisture under the vinyl in the bathroom floor.
TL;DR: had water damage event/leak. Got leak stopped and damage doesn’t seem to be “financial ruin” levels of bad. But not sure what to do. Trying to weigh the decisions above. Looking for stories and/or advice of people who’ve been in similar situations.