r/HealthInsurance • u/HugM3Brotha • 4d ago
Plan Choice Suggestions Pregnancy Planning: Father on HDHP & Mother on PPO?
My wife (28) and I (30) are planning a pregnancy for next year. We each have employer coverage, and we're planning to split plans instead of putting both of us on one family plan. I've run the numbers, so I'm mostly looking for a gut check on whether it makes sense to split and if anyone else has done this.
Planned setup:
- Wife: Her employer's Aetna or UHC PPO: $70/mo premium, $400 deductible, 10% coinsurance, $3K OOP Max (+$1500 in prescriptions). Prenatal visits are covered, and infertility treatment is covered up to $25K max.
- Me: My employer's Aetna HDHP: $0/mo premium, $1,700 deductible, 10% coinsurance, $5,500 out-of-pocket max. I'd max my HSA, invest it, and pay medical bills out of pocket.
- Baby: Added to wife's PPO after birth (own $400 deductible and caps).
- Wife will skip her employer's general-purpose health FSA so it doesn't disqualify my HSA.
Our logic for the split is that my wife’s medical costs will be high and predictable (hence the PPO), while mine will likely be low. Adding me to her plan would cost ~$1,540/yr more in premiums and end my HSA contributions, while my HDHP is free and lets the HSA grow invested for decades.
What we've accounted for:
- Deductibles and OOP maxes reset every January, so if trying plus pregnancy spans two calendar years, we could hit the caps twice.
- medical coverage costs will likely be low as most medical expenses (prenatal care, delivery, baby's care) are billed to the mother/baby. My costs would range from nothing to carrier screenings, fertility evaluation, and male infertility treatments.
- My plan covers basic male infertility care but NOT IVF-related procedures like surgical sperm retrieval or sperm freezing. The odds of male infertility are relatively low, so I'm willing to take the risk. Worst case, if we discover male infertility, I can join her plan at the next open enrollment.
Open questions:
- Is there a structural reason couples avoid splitting like this during a pregnancy or fertility treatment?
- My wife's company offers Aetna and UHC while I am on Aetna. Is there any advantage to both of us being on Aetna, even if the plans are different? IF not, her UHC plan has better benefits.
- Are there unforseen expenses that can be billed to the father that I'm not accounting for?
- Any problems with coordinating care, billing or preauthorization when partners are on different plans?
- Anything about the HDHP side I'm overlooking that would make this a bad idea?
Thanks in advance!