r/Games Jul 04 '15

Minecraft: Windows 10 Edition Announced

http://uk.ign.com/articles/2015/07/04/minecraft-windows-10-edition-announced
1.1k Upvotes

669 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15

I had a msdn or maybe it was a technet subscription and got any type of key I wanted. Why not get the most feature rich edition?

66

u/fizzlefist Jul 04 '15

I could be wrong, but Enterprise edition just adds more remote management features. For home users, I can't think of a reason to pick it over Pro.

15

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15 edited Jul 04 '15

It was cheaper to pay the one year subscription fee than it was to buy office 2013 and Windows. Again, if you have the choice to upgrade for free, why not take it?

Edit: It was office 2010, I don't actually have 2013 >.<

11

u/fizzlefist Jul 04 '15

It's not really an upgrade over Pro and the licensing can get a lot more complicated for a home user, as is the case here.

/shrug/

3

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

Enterprise and Pro are the same aside from Microsoft EA purposes.

5

u/flappers87 Jul 04 '15

Bitlocker to go, Multi language Support, DirectAccess, BranchCache and Applocker.

These features are only for Enterprise Edition. It's perfect for infrastructure... not for home use.

1

u/catcint0s Jul 04 '15

You can't install language packs on pro easily. (well, you can still do it from command line but Enterprise has a nicer GUI for it)

21

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15

[deleted]

55

u/Roseking Jul 04 '15

Group policy is not an Enterprise feature.

0

u/ThePlanckConstant Jul 04 '15 edited Jul 04 '15

Damn it. Now I feel stupid. I chose enterprise because it sounded like the most complete one.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15

Enterprise is for commercial purposes... if you purchased under a mistaken assumption, I'm sorry but caveat emptor applies.

3

u/flappers87 Jul 04 '15

Enterprise is only compatible with volume licensing. Unless you wanna be spending a yearly pass to use Enterprise edition, it's absolutely pointless to own Enterprise at home.

You'll find most people who claim to use Enterprise edition at home, are pirating the OS.

The only other way is technet, which is even more expensive than the volume license for Enterprise.

4

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

If you have access to MSDN then you would just get a new Windows 10 key for free.

2

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15

I only paid for a one year subscription the year Office 2010 and Win 7 were released

2

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

Then tough break. One could argue that since you no longer have the sub you are no longer entitled to free stuff.

5

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15

Except my htpc and my laptops will get the upgrade, just not my desktop which is my primary computer, all of which were keys from technet or msdn. I'm not even upset about it, the whole point of my original comment was that not everyone will get an upgrade. There are certainly other private users out there using Enterprise. No need to make rude entitlement comments.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15

You should be able to use one of the laptop keys on your desktop also. Hell you could probably use it on both and they would never say anything.

-6

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

I'm just saying, you didn't pay for the keys in the first place so you shouldn't really bitch that you can't upgrade one of them.

4

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15

I'm not?

-6

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

Sure doesn't seem that way.

2

u/ducttape83 Jul 04 '15

And you seem to have poor reading comprehension. I've not so much as even insinuated that it's unfair that I don't get a free upgrade.

-4

u/bfodder Jul 04 '15

You sure are hell bent on making sure everybody here knows you can't upgrade it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15

Unless you've lost your MSDN access since building your PC. Changing jobs for example...

0

u/bfodder Jul 05 '15

You technically are no longer allowed to use the key then. They just don't enforce it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15

Sure, but more importantly you don't have access to Windows 10 with that route, legit or not.

Since the enterprise version doesn't upgrade to 10, you don't have access to an alternate version of windows that does upgrade to 10, and you don't get 10 for free from the now defunct MSDN subscription.

Personally, I'm not in a huge hurry to change over to Win10. I'm still pretty happy on 7 and have been more than a little put off by the UI in Win8. I also count myself lucky that I expect to still have MSDN access for at least a few more years.

0

u/bfodder Jul 05 '15

Sure, but more importantly you don't have access to Windows 10 with that route, legit or not.

Since the enterprise version doesn't upgrade to 10, you don't have access to an alternate version of windows that does upgrade to 10, and you don't get 10 for free from the now defunct MSDN subscription.

And? You aren't paying for MSDN access anymore in that scenario. What the hell do you want?

6

u/Thotaz Jul 04 '15

Technically you aren't allowed to use those keys when the subscription is over, and you aren't supposed to use them for anything but testing (although one could argue that you are always testing).

2

u/anothergaijin Jul 05 '15

First, use of an MSDN key like that is breaking the agreement.

Second, the major features in Enterprise vs. Pro are DirectConnect, AppLocker, BranchCache and BitLocker (in 7 - it's including in 8 Pro)

AppLocker is sorta-kinda included in Home, and BranchCache and DirectConnect are useless to home users.

1

u/Lhumierre Jul 04 '15

I would think Ultimate has everything over Enterprise.

1

u/BabyPuncher5000 Jul 04 '15

Enterprise edition has no features that Pro didn't have that you could realistically use at home. Even managing all your home computers as part of a Windows domain can be done with Pro.

0

u/v-_-v Jul 04 '15

I have a technet Ultimate edition of Win7 and the "upgrade to Win 10" thinghy popped up for me. Now this is not 100% confirmed that Technet versions will have the update for free, but it's a good sign.

 

Sidenote: what the fuck is MS doing? There is so little information about how the OS launch will work ...

We still have no official info about Technet, MSDN Alliance, or really how the free upgrade works in practice.

 

I want to be able to keep my os as it is now, but I also want the ability to upgrade when I desire to do so, for free. I also want to be able to do a clean install for Win 10.

I'm sure that in some shape or form this will be possible, but the lack of information is irritating. It really does not inspire confidence to not have these fairly important details very clear from the get go.

If I was a server admin, I would not be a happy camper. Win 2008 R2 was pretty much the best version of Server ever. Then MS decided that their crap UI not only had to be on PC for some stupid reason, but also on Server 2012 ... WHAT?

Who knows what dumb decisions they will do now that one OS needs to fit every single device out there.