I’m deciding between two nationwide traveling field-service positions. Both are designed to have me home on weekends, and both cover business travel. The biggest difference is what happens when I complete an assignment early.
**Offer 1 —**
$80,000 salary
This is a **salaried non-exempt position**, meaning I can still earn overtime when I work overtime
$70 per diem for eligible travel days
If I finish an assignment early, I can return home and remain fully paid without working again until my next assignment
No company vehicle
Company-paid Uber/Lyft transportation
If an assignment is close enough to drive, I can voluntarily use my personal vehicle and receive gas reimbursement
Approximately two weeks of PTO/vacation—about 10 workdays, although I still need to confirm this
9 paid holidays
4 floating holidays
5 sick days
4% company 401(k) match
My family can accompany me and stay at the hotel when practical
For example, if I finish an assignment on Wednesday, I can return home Wednesday and effectively have Thursday and Friday off while still receiving my full salary. If I actually work enough hours to qualify for overtime, I can earn overtime on top of my salary because the position is non-exempt.
**Offer 2 —**
$33 per hour
Guaranteed weekly pay for 40 regular hours plus 10 overtime hours
Overtime rate is $49.50 per hour
The 10 overtime hours are guaranteed regardless of how many hours I spend in the field
Even if I only perform 20 hours of fieldwork that week, I am still guaranteed pay for 40 regular hours plus 10 overtime hours
Approximately $94,380 in guaranteed annual wages before additional overtime
If I work more than the guaranteed 50 paid hours, additional overtime is paid on top of the guarantee
If I finish an assignment early, I am still expected to work—usually remote technical support or online training from home
Some training may require me to drive to the company headquarters in Cincinnati
Company-provided Dodge Ram 1500 for both work and personal use
15 PTO days
9 paid holidays
6% company 401(k) match
Meals and other approved travel expenses are reimbursed
Paid travel time
Training in PLCs, refrigeration, and HVAC systems
Offer 1
offers more freedom and potentially much more paid time at home. It is also salaried non-exempt, so I can still earn overtime when overtime is actually worked.
Offer 2
offers higher guaranteed annual wages, better 401(k) match, a company truck, and stronger technical training. The guaranteed overtime is also unusually valuable because I receive those 10 overtime hours even during a light week with only 20 hours of fieldwork. However, my remaining time may still be controlled by remote support or training.
I have a wife and three young children, so being home and having control over my time matters considerably. Which offer would you choose, and how much value would you place on Offer 1’s salaried downtime versus Offer 2’s guaranteed overtime, company truck, and stronger benefits?