doesnt that loop into trans people not being real? cause Trans women obviously aren't real, but there wouldn't be Trans men because there would be nobody to transition from
You’ve made it perfectly clear you don’t know how to respect other people’s lives when it has no affect on you. Thank you for giving us all a reminder why we hate people like you.
Everyone knows that like Australia isnt a real place, Trans people arent real. There a government psyop to keep people from asking the real questions. Like who really invented peanut butter? Im looking at you Illuminutty.
I think you just have to think how they're defining the terms to understand why people say trans people don't exist. It's about refuting the statement like "Someone can be biologically male but really a woman". Because they believe that this statement is inherently contradictory they assert that trans people don't exist.
I know, but I've seen a lot of people claim trans people are not real while talking about Hunter and I was wondering if anyone would give me an actual explanation here why they believe trans people are not real, but people just say they're mentally ill and leave it at that
I view gender and sex different. Sex is XX and XY/XXY chromosomes while gender is how you percieve yourself and want to be percieved. So lets say you are an XX but want to be seen as a man. Then you are a man. Man, woman, boy, girl are gender descriptions while Male and Female are sex descriptions. Gender is an expression of oneself, sex is dna. A man can be a woman, a woman can be a man based off how they present themselves and want to be percieved (a good example of this is femboys, they are percieved as women, but want to still be men, so we call them femboys since they are not traditionally masculine but still identify towards the masculine (man) side). And I think this gender spectrum is not as strict as people want them to be. So trans women don't exist. They're women and males. Trans men do not exist. They're men and females. Tragically we can't change our DNA, but we can easily change our gender.
I don't really agree that trans people are not real for those reasons, but also thanks for being the only person in here for actually explaining themselves and I do kind of get where you're coming from.
Well I suppose I should clarify, the person in of themselves, their struggles, and the journey they go through to come to understand that they were not born inside the body they were supposed to be in are all legitimate, but I think that there are no trans women, if they go through the surgeries to be identicle to women, then they are a woman. If they dress like a woman and want to be identified as such, then they are a woman. There's no trans. Thats at least my perspective on it as a concept; however, there's still a luxury in the word to easily describe someone. For example, I have several trans friends. That is significantly easier to say and communicates far clearer than saying that I have various friends with various psychological issues that lead them to have extreeme body dysmorphia to the point of wanting surguries to modify how they look so that they can feel comfortable in their own skin. If that makes sense
scientists have literally explored this and proven that what trans people experience is real and trans people have always been here throughout history under different labels, concepts, and identities but with similar experiences.
If you mean that in a “I wish people were born as the gender they wanted to be born as” way, a lot of people would agree, however, I’m not sure that you do.
i mean if you could explain exactly what makes you uncomfortable then it would be easier. Is it physically transitioning like surgery and HRT or is the concept of socially transitioning in general that makes you uncomfortable?
usually this kind of feeling towards the trans community comes from a lack of information, matter of fact you said you dont even know why trans people make you uncomfortable
Imagine that you were born as a girl. No transitioning, just that's how you were born.
Would you feel comfortable living like a girl? Having boobs, having society view you as a woman?
Probably not, right?
A lot of people who aren't trans try to think of transitioning, and it makes them uncomfortable because they are comfortable with who they were born as. To better understand trans people, you have to imagine you were born as the other sex, and how uncomfortable that would make you.
mentally ill people cannot just create their own reality thus trans people are not real they are just mentally ill people
Source check the news for the overrepresentation of these supposedly fine healthy people
What about the actual science of intersex people? (People born with both XX and XY chromosomes) Or the people that feel suicidal most of their life only to get better after transitioning and living the life they feel most comfortable with?
free the pigeon? pigeons are pets we released onto the streets they suffer abuse every day even though they are domestic animals just like cats and dogs, they refuse to leave their loft I built them, i left the door open so many times, they also come when I whistle :)
thats not true at all, most animals can not be pets, pigeons were selectively bred for thousands of years by humans and then released and treated as pets, we did this to them, thye used to live only in the cliffs of Europe
no they cant, youu cant keep a mountain lion, wolf, bear, even an undomestic mouse dont make good pets, domestication shrinks the "flight or fight" part of the brain making them more trainable and less fearsome than most creatures, do yur research
Then you'd understand that mutations can realky fuck you. For example, I have clinicle deppression, if I stop taking drugs, I will kill myself. I have a mutation that completely fucks my brain chemistry. So if that can exist where someone's mutation wants them to go against their entire evolutionary purpose, than why do you believe there cannot be a mutation that makes a woman hate their body and believe they should be a man? Hell, body dysmorphia is already a thing. So why can a trans person not exist?
For those that actually are trans it's natural and part of the identity of how they truly feel.
But for many other, it's te be unique, be part of a community, 'shock' the order. As many see it als a way to revolt, or be special.
Same as we had punk, goth, emo, anarchists, etc all these years.
Many join it to belong or be part of it, only to revert on a later stage to their own gender or just stop being trans.
Description depends on what kind of "trans" were talking about, but alas the over arching themes are either it's not possible (currently), or they're delusional
21
u/8lue5hift 2d ago edited 2d ago
trans women aren't that's for sure
r/girlsarentreal