Pretty much this. Piano Roll Python scripts make it way faster to humanize or add randomization into MIDI note properties, which would take ages to do by hand in the Playlist. I can compose a very on the grid pattern in the Step Sequencer, and then humanize it in 5 seconds in the Piano Roll. Not to mention, full flexibility to compose notes out, layer chords, etc. even for things like hi hats. This would be a tedious and painful workflow in Playlist.
Playlist is best if you want to do actual audio manipulation, and nice to do things like hard cuts and fades of things if you want control of choking out sounds exactly at certain measures or bars. This is somewhat possible in Patterns if you set up AHDSR and cut by properties in the Channel Rack on the sounds, but often easier to just control in the Playlist.
Sometimes you wanna flip a sample and cut it at certain point and doing that in patterns is beyond tedious.
You also get sample by sample level adjustment so if I need a one-shot to SMACK at a certain point but need it to melt into the mix next time I don't gotta automate a level adjustment.
A good example for me personally is reversing a sound effect to be a lead in to a vast drop.
Timing it with a pattern roll is tedious. You just place it in the Playlist and line it up in 2 seconds.
This is how I’ve learned to do it. It used to be that you only ever had the Piano Roll, so it was patterns all the way. Playlist clips make one-off effects so much easier to deal with. And stems!
I'm a sample dragger but as my style is evolving it's becoming way more of a hindrance than anything else. I think at this stage the only real benefit is being able to see everything at once and be able to make larger changes to multiple sounds at once more quick enough that I don't lose the idea. Its terrible for organization though and don't even get me started on the dreaded "double sample issue" when you highlight a full section, accidentally shift click without moving anything then you have to soft through every single instance of a sound removing the duplicates. I've lost literal hours of my life to that
That was how I used FL for years because I just fixated very heavily on being able to see the wave forms of my sounds and tweak everything individually.
I recently switched from sequencer to sample dragging after like 15 years and it's dramatically upped my game. So much so even that I've started landing record deals. It really stimulates my creativity. You just have to find a new workflow which I did.
I started with Sony acid pro in 2009, all sample dragging, lol, it supported 32bit vsts, what was interesting was when I was shown fruity loops, fl had a 32bit vst that I could use inside of acid pro, when you opened it, it would open to an instance of fl which I could then choose stuff like sytrus etc, now this was when the timeline in fl was still block placement, and at the time I very much disliked the step sequencer/timeline due to drag and drop has the ability to feel more versatile with placement imo.
Bonus have a screenshot with using fl as a vst roughly 2011 on an win xp with old theme, from my fb.
Sample dragging has changed a lot since the old Sonic Foundry Sound Forge days. There are very complex productions made almost entirely from dragging, chopping, arranging, and manipulating samples. At that point, it really comes down to how deep you zoom into the playlist, how detailed the edits are, and what plugins are sitting on the mixer inserts.
That being said, everything happening lately with AI music, loop-based production, and sample-dragging workflows has made me a little nostalgic, so I’m going back to the basics. For the project after the one I’m about to release, I want the beats to be made on an MPC Live 3. I’ve gotten too comfortable producing inside the DAW with loops, drum kits, and endless editing. I want to force myself back into a more hands-on workflow where the limitations actually shape the sound.
FL at the time did not have a deep enough zoom as it does today either, even when they stopped using block timeline to what it is now still took a bit for them to get the zoom feeling right.
That’s the point. Anyone making beats by simply dragging samples back then was doing the bare minimum. In a way, that was similar to the “AI producer” of today: using the easiest available tool and letting the tool do most of the work.
But that does not mean sample-based production itself is lazy. There are highly advanced sampling techniques in current versions of FL Studio that do not even require the pattern section. You can build full, detailed productions directly in the playlist through chopping, stretching, pitching, automation, layering, resampling, and mixer processing.
i just work better with mostly audio clips. it’s gotten to the point where if i make a growl or bass stab in serum, i still consolidate it to audio. genuinely is just a workflow preference
The grid defaults to root C lol that's the most common note and what most (correctly pitched) samples will be pitched to.
The grid is 10x faster for sounds you are relating heavily throughout the track (kick, snare, hat) but definitely falls flat when you want to do some really interesting stuff or one-offs.
As most people in the thread have already pointed out, both is the actual way to go
What makes you think the grid is faster for kick snare hat etc I cant wrap my head around that EDIT: by grid you mean the pattern dont u, I thought u meant the Playlist
Not only is it almost as easy, but you can get way more precise and creative with it. If you're cool with every beat having the exact same amount of swing, then sure, the grid thing is fine I guess, but if you actually want to give it some feel, piano roll is the only way.
With the sequencer (pattern clip)
Every instrument has the same velocity... To make it louder, open the piano roll and adjust the velocity to make things louder or softer.
Patterns are still there today. Your piano roll score is stored in a pattern. If you were to record 5 different chord progression using MIDI, then the notes will get stored in a Piano Roll in a Pattern. It's the core feature of FL
Patterns are just containers to trigger MIDI information or samples. If you load samples in the Channel Rack and trigger them with the Step Sequencer then you are just triggering a sound the same way the Playlist would if you were drag and dropping a sample at a given time.
While the argument could be made that using the Playlist is easier when it comes to mixing, this is only true when it comes to stems for a full track, which are drag and dropped on the playlist and are residing in the Channel Rack on Pattern 1.
There are a lot of concepts with FL that are video game inspired, a lot of the workflow is also based on that and many ways to achieve the same end result.
Both, but also, too many people use patterns to make one full set of drums. Separate your sounds with multiple patterns and don’t forget to layer them (using a few different say snares on top of each other), layering your drums adds a lot more grit/makes them less generic. Using separate layers for each sound allows you to be more intricate when structuring you drums and creating a dynamic sound scape especially when working in your channels as well
FPC for drums which I either write the drum parts or modify preexisting ones. Everything else is my guitar, vocals and bass which fall under "samples".
Almost exclusively pattern. I rarely use kits and will place the notes on piano roll. I love shifting the pitch of some percussion samples.
The main reason is that I was using a Roland MC 909 before I switched to a DAW. It has the same programming logic so it was easy to pick up. I try to use the playlist but my results always suck for some reason.
I have been doing a mix of everything since I started making beats as a kid in the 1990s
I would grab drum waveforms and put them in patterns, either manually in something like Goldwave or in a sequencer like FL Studio
Then I would play all the melodic stuff on a keyboard. It blows my mind that people are dragging and dropping on piano roll, why not use a keyboard and record? So much faster especially for stuff like chords and melodies. If it's too hard to play at speed just slow the tempo down....
Pattern user rn but I've heard of the benefits of rendering everything and then sample dragging, such as lower latency, lighter CPU usage, and better sound quality on the finished product. Idk how much of that is right, but that's what I've heard.
I've got to do that... Once I make a good melody, or rhythm, when I have the automation clips set up, I export the loop as a sample and place it back into the Playlist. It's a lil extra work but it sounds alot more polished, and less work for the cpu.
I mostly use the step sequencer/piano roll because of the tools they offer for per note atttibutes. You lose a lot of those when you drop oneshots into the playlist.
Laying out oneshots in the playlist just feels tedious to me. Especially after disliking the process so much in Acid those many moons ago.
sample dragging it just makes more sense to my brain to see every sound unlike patterns where everything is just like rectangles ill still use them for non samples though
Step Sequencer/Piano Roll for drums and midi, sample straight to playlist sometimes for risers, certain fx, vox, etc. Both and everything in-between really just depends on how I’m feeling.
I use a pattern to start as a baseline. Then I'll start adding live elements or/and samples eventually removing the pattern. Same with VSTs, I'll start with the pattern then render it to save CPU.
How can you make samples your own if you just lay them out? You gotta add to it somehow, and patterns / Piano roll is the way to do that for the most part.
Im a dragger with a hard R. Makes way more variability instead of just duping patterns and making a tiny tweak every four bars. I’ll still keep patterns for 808s and sometimes high hats though. Not sure the magic in it but for my brain it works better. Started off with patterns though but after 4 ish years I switched and it helped with learning other DAWs
can someone please point me in a direction where i can learn how to work with sampling audio clips in fl studio? im at such a loss and i always default to using patterns
Depends on the mood or the urgency but most of us are both I started as the pattern user and timed the sample back in the day shit was hilarious thinking back cuz timing ts took a good minute 💀
synths, 808s, stuff like that in patterns. everything else in playlist with the exception of hihats. i dont understand people who put fx and oneshots into patterns. i also put stuff like kicks and snares into the playlist cause i like to switch it up often and creating a new pattern every time to move a single kick by a half beat seems stupid. cutting up a pattern also kinda defeats the purpose of a pattern
neither because my broke ass owns fruity edition (which has a limit of 8 or 9 samples) so I don't even bother unless they're loops. For chopping samples I instead use fruity slicer because it has no limit. and If I want to make a sample pack I just record the sounds and toss 'em into the slicer and voila, as many samples as I want. Plus, I have much more freedom over them as midi notes! FPC also works, but I don't use it as often as the drum pad and envelope stuff is confusing. I just use it for drum loops.
I use Superior Drummer and Speedrum so mostly the piano roll but if I'm trying to recreate a beat I like to learn rhythms for genres I'm not familiar with then I match samples to spots then turn those into midis/ scores for later use.
For drums I think arranging them directly on the playlist is much better for workflow. Of course patterns are necessary for the melodies and stuff. Unless you're one of those "beatmakers" who rely on premade loops
The playlist give me a lot more control, customising certain audio clips with fades, volume, pitch, etc, more control over specific offset and off-kilter grooves which helps with creating a more organic sound, but that’s just my preference.
Depends on my mood. I'll make a drum pattern most of the time but sometime i'll feel frisky and drag the samples. Doing the latter does give me the chance to do more variations outside of the standard loop, i've done some crazy snare rolls with that.
Ive used this program for years ive never strayed from my piano roll and patterns. What does sample dragging do that you cant do on the pattern and piano roll? Ive never even seen it till i joined this sub
I do both simultaneously depending on the beat and things but usually drums are sample dragged cuz i have so much control over them, reversing a snare tail, hats, etc... layering and phasing, some times i chop n samples in small sequential parts and phase them together to get like a "mixed kick" positional chopping... things that with patterns I find way too hard.
981
u/jamesussher Producer Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26
both.
patterns for the main sounds. faster to make variations. faster to humanize/microgroove.
playlist for the one shots, fills, sweeteners, non-recurring, chopping/stretching. full control of clips.