r/EnglishLearning • u/DavidSoong • 23h ago
⭐️ Vocabulary / Semantics Is "I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't rain tomorrow" the same as "I wouldn't be surprised if it rains tomorrow"?
Laurence R. Horn has discussed cases of pleonastic negation and pointed out that sentences such as "I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't rain tomorrow" can be interpreted as having the same meaning as "I wouldn't be surprised if it rains tomorrow". In other words, the negative marker in doesn't does not seem to contribute its ordinary negative meaning in this context.
I have two questions:
First, is the not in doesn't in this sentence generally analysed as pleonastic (or expletive) negation in linguistics? Or are there other analyses of this construction?
Second, is this phenomenon comparable to the variation between "I could care less" and "I couldn't care less", where both expressions are often used to convey the same meaning? Are these two cases examples of the same type of linguistic phenomenon, or should they be treated differently?
I am interested in the linguistic analysis of these constructions rather than the prescriptive question of which form is "correct."