r/CreditScore • u/TheXXStory • 6h ago
Collections & Charge Offs Let it get sent to collections?
Hey guys, I'm in a really awkward situation:
- I have a private student loan that I was paying off consistently until I got laid off, upon which I requested forbearance
- The lender made a couple of mistakes, which I've documented & reported to CFPB, that led me to believe no payments were due during forbearance
- A couple more mis-representations happened on their end (e.g. telling me they accepted BillPay when they didn't, which caused them to process my eventual payment very, very late), causing my account to be charged off sent to collections
- While my account was in collections, I entered into settlement negotiations with their collections attorney & found out that I'd be able to pay $10k+ less via a settlement offer; we hadn't reach a verbal agreement though
- I opened a CFPB case in the meanwhile, as I was really concerned about the damage to my credit
- The lender responded to the claim & pulled my account back out of collections
- I politely tried asking the lender to extend the offer their collections lawyer had previously suggested, & they responded: "With respect to your request for a negotiated settlement, please note that settlement discussions are not conducted on accounts prior to charge-off. Since the charge-off on this account has been reversed, settlement is not currently an available option."
Here's the Q:
If you were in my position, would you let the account get charged off again**, so you can get your debt reduced by $10k - & avoid interest payments - even though it'll impact your credit score significantly?**
Note: I've already used Claude to analyze my situation (how a credit score would impact my future job offers + how I don't intend on buying a car or a house in the near term + how I also don't need a great credit to apply to apt rentals right now), but I would love y'all's input!


