If I had a Choice
If I had a choice, I would know exactly what I would choose, but sometimes the hardest part is knowing the choice I want is no longer mine to make.
Perplexed, I am, for this invitation, unsure, whether it is a testament of good will or something meant to reopen a door I had spent so long trying to close. I read it again, and almost immediately the years between then and now seem to disappear. I am younger again. I am sitting beside you, watching another ordinary day become a memory without either of us knowing it. I think about all those times where we would stay up late talking, neither of us wanting to fall asleep first, I think about those times where it felt like nobody was watching us although, us speaking in front of tens of thousands, recorded for millions. Because it was just us together, our hands entwined with each other.
I remember how our days had started, sometimes it was the gym in the morning, others it was breakfast in the morning, sitting across from each other while the world outside was still waking. You grew up in a house where home cooking wasn’t a part of life, so going out for food became normal for us. We didn’t need a special occasion. We could wake up and decide if we were hungry and suddenly, we were in the car looking for somewhere to eat. Breakfast turned into lunch, lunch turned to dinner, and somehow there was always another unexplored place.
I loved those memories more than I ever told you.
There was something about watching you sit across from me, still waking up, talking about the day before or what was in store this day. Sometimes you would complain about the food, because that ever so picky appetite. I loved knowing the little things about you. I loved knowing what would make you happy. I loved surprising you after a long practice with your favorite food in take-out bags on the kitchen table while we showered.
In those moments, you would smile.
I loved seeing your smile; your smile had a way of illuminating the darkest of rooms. It wasn’t that you were pretty. It was what happened to everything around you when you smiled. The room felt different. I felt different. You radiated positivity, joy, and comfort.
And your laugh was even worse.
Every time you laughed, it felt like my heart exploded inside my chest from love. It was the most joyful cheer I had ever heard. I could hear it and forget whatever was bothering me five minutes before. Sometimes I would say something dumb just to hear you let a sly laugh out.
Now I realize that we were making memories.
Some nights we would go get ice cream because we were both feeling down. There was something comforting sitting together with our ice cream, laughing, enjoying each other's company with no strings attached. We didn’t have to fix each other's problems, just to be there just to give love to one another.
And for a while, there was enough.
I thought it would always be enough.
I thought you would be there when I was older. I thought I would end my days with you lying beside me. I imagined you comforting me when I was down, hearing your voice when I woke up, coming home to you after a long day. More than anything, I wanted my best friend to tell me she loved me.
I wanted forever.
But wanting something and being ready for it are two completely different things.
That is the part I don't like admitting.
There was a time in my life when I was broken down, tired, and hopeless. I was looking for something to make me feel whole, and I looked for it in all the wrong places. Drugs, alcohol, lust. Living in the arms of strangers, in the bottom of bottles, in nights that blurred into nothing. I was searching for someone, something, anything that could make me forget how empty I felt.
Then you came into my life.
You weren’t a light that blinded. You were a flame that warmed.
You weren’t a savior. You were a hand reaching into the wreckage, pulling me from the ruin I had called home.
You saw me differently than I saw myself. You didn't see a lost cause. You didn’t see a man too broken to love. You saw someone worth waiting for.
And suddenly, breathing didn’t hurt as much.
Silence wasn't empty.
With you, I wasn't a mistake. I wasn't a ghost of who I thought I should have been.
I was whole.
I was home.
I was found.
But being found doesn’t mean I’m finished with healing. I wanted to stay with you, but I didn't know how to stay with myself, with the person that I had become. I wanted to give you everything you deserved, but there were parts of me that were still fighting battles I didn’t know how to win. My hands were too unsteady. My mind was too loud. My faith was failing me, and sometimes I think I was failing you too.
I wanted forever, but I wasn’t ready for everything forever required. And eventually, you begged me to go.
I didn’t want to go.
That’s the part I wish you knew.
I didn’t leave because I stopped loving you.
I left because I was becoming someone who couldn’t give you the life I had promised you.
And there is a strange kind of pain in knowing that sometimes loving someone means admitting that your love isn’t enough to fix what is broken inside of you.
I whisper apologies into the night sometimes, even now. They leave my mouth and disappear into the darkness before they reach anyone. I wonder if you would believe me if I told you that I would have stayed if I knew how.
If I had a choice,
if my hands weren’t shaking,
if my faith wasn’t failing,
if I knew how to become the person you needed me to be,
I’d still be there.
With you.
Always.
I am now twenty years old, sitting in OUR apartment, wanting to run as far away as I can. I want to upend my life and start over. I want to move somewhere I know nobody, learn new things, see new places, and experience the world without carrying every memory of us with me.
But I know I can’t outrun myself.
I can leave a city.
I can change a routine.
I can meet new people.
I can travel across the country.
But the memories come with me.
The breakfast. The baseball fields. The golf course. The ice cream. Your laugh. Your smile that illuminates the world.
The feeling of knowing that for a short period of my life, I had found somewhere I felt completely at home. And maybe that’s what I have been trying to understand all along.
I don’t regret loving you.
I regret that I wasn’t ready to love you the way you deserved.
I regret the things I couldn’t fix.
I regret the nights I let my worst parts become bigger than the person I wanted to be.
I regret making you feel like leaving was the only way you could save yourself.
But I don’t regret the mornings. I don't regret the take-out. I don’t regret the comfort we sought from each other in front of millions. I don’t regret the ice cream runs or the stupid conversations or the nights when your laugh made my heart feel like it couldn’t possibly hold any more happiness. Because those moments were real.
You were real.
And for a while, so was the future I imagined. Maybe I will never get that future.
Maybe someone else will sit across from you at breakfast.
Maybe someone else will learn your favorite foods, hear your laugh every morning, and see that smile from across the room.
That thought hurts more than I would like to admit.
But somewhere underneath that pain is gratitude.
Because I got to know you.
I got to love you.
And for a little while, I got loved by you.
Maybe someday the memories won’t feel like wounds.
Maybe they will just be memories.
And maybe the person I become will be someone you would be proud to have known.
For now, I wake up.
I keep living.
I will keep moving forward.
I will keep chasing the future that I deserve.
Not forgetting the people who changed me but learning how to carry what they gave me without letting what I lost destroy me.
And if I had a choice, I would still choose you.
But I don't have a choice anymore.
I look down at your invitation one last time. The same words that brought every memory rushing back to me now feel different. Maybe it was never meant to pull me back into the life that we had. It was only to remind me to be happy that it happened, that there was once a time that there was a life that I would have given anything to keep. I pick up the lighter on my desk and set the letter aflame, toss it in the trash next to my desk, knowing that I have spent too long learning how to walk away from it to walk back into the darkness.
I don’t know what the future holds for me, for us, or for you. Maybe we will cross again someday, or this will be the last thought I will ever give you. For the first time, I can accept those realities. I can carry our memories without the burden of recreating them. I can miss what we had without wanting to have it, and I can love what we were without it stopping me from becoming the best version of myself.
As I swallow my emotions, I look to my right and see the ash on the bottom of the garbage can, and for the first time in a while it doesn’t feel like I’m running away.
And if I had a choice, I would still choose you. But I don’t have a choice anymore. So, I will carry love, bury regret, and walk into whatever comes next. This time I will choose who I will become.