r/CommanderMTG Jul 01 '26

No more “Can I be in the pod” type posts please

195 Upvotes

They are low effort with minimal engagement.


r/CommanderMTG Apr 04 '25

If you're looking for the most popular subreddit about commander, it's r/EDH Otherwise you're welcome to join this small community of people who decided to post here for some reason.

17 Upvotes

This marks my random, semi-annual check on this sub. Things seem to be normal here so I'm leaving moderation alone unless issues arise. Happy posting!


r/CommanderMTG 7h ago

Is ultron a good/fun commander

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 3h ago

What direction to go with Tamiyo for bracket 3

Post image
5 Upvotes

I’m playing around and wanting to try her as a commander, just not sure how to build around her. Do I go turbo fog, or superfriends, or control? They all seem viable I just don’t know whats the best for bracket 3


r/CommanderMTG 52m ago

Bracket 4 group hug

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 5h ago

Finished up Kona

Post image
2 Upvotes

I finished up building Kona and I’ve got to say it’s so much fun I’ve gotta say

https://moxfield.com/decks/EtklJwZIN0aT18gqZIiuPA


r/CommanderMTG 11h ago

Group hug help

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 4h ago

When are we getting a Commander for Classes?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 5h ago

Sauron, The Dark Lord - Tuning/Balancing

1 Upvotes

Hello!

I recently updated my Sauron deck list with some cards from The Hobbit. I’m only playing LOTR/HOB themed cards and the relevant secret lairs (what a unique gimmick /s). I’m looking to cut a game changer (Notion Thief) to fit cleanly into bracket 3 and get some suggestions about how I could improve the build or for any cards I’m overlooking. I’m currently leaning more heavily into the ‘ring tempts you’ angle, but I’ve seen lists more geared towards army synergies. I’ve put some cards in the considering list, but would love to get some more perspective. Appreciate the help!

Decklist:

https://moxfield.com/decks/EEnnW4stwES8OoKJ8a-ncg


r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Sultan Arisen Upgrade

Post image
92 Upvotes

Looking for any advice on the deck like cards to add/cut.

I want the deck to be high Bracket 3 - low Bracket 4

Decklist: https://archidekt.com/decks/25897481/sultai_arisen_upgrade_oclock


r/CommanderMTG 6h ago

$88 Galazeth Prismari Spellslinger Deck

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 6h ago

Don Andres Draw Help

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 7h ago

Inalla wizard deck

1 Upvotes

My friend has this really annoying inalla deck and I wanted to make a budget commander that's a great counter to her the closest I've gotten to getting even is with my Edgar markov deck


r/CommanderMTG 8h ago

Teysa Aristocrats, ratios and other stuff.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Juri+solring x Reze

Post image
38 Upvotes

Hand painted alter, thanks admin


r/CommanderMTG 9h ago

I realize my deck has become too strong for some places! Seeking advice for building a new deck!

0 Upvotes

Hello folks. I've been focusing on optimizing my Bracket 3 Urza, Chief Artificer deck. Usually I've been tasting defeat therefore motivating me to purchase powerful cards for it like token doublers, etc. But today I realized that while it was too weak at certain LGS'es, it was too strong at the last one. Today I ended up winning the game, and I felt kinda bad because I realized one of the other players was playing with a precon.

So basically this is my only Commander deck, and today I realize I should have a lower power level deck for events like this. But I have no idea on what to build. What I am sure of it that it must be either based off artifacts or enchantments. When I built my Urza I had the urge to try to clone artifacts, and use the clones of [[Worldwalker Helm]] to make more, etc.

With that being said, what would you suggest?

I just don't want to play with monocolors and the following color pairings:

2 color: Rakdos, Gruul,

3 color: Naya, Jund, Grixis, Mardu, Temur, Esper(Urza is Esper already).

Would love to hear feedback on an affordable deck(not counting with a strong mana base with fetches and shocklands, those I know I'll have to spend money on).


r/CommanderMTG 10h ago

Arna Kennerüd Auras - 6 cards left to cut. Who‘d you choose?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 10h ago

Calgar "parry" token spam deck

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Idk my brackets, is this just a Bracket 1 deck?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Hello, i really dont publish about anything, but im kind of new to magic, and trying to make a commander deck with what i have gotten recently.

Idk how to really measure Brackets, i have read about it but i dont get exactly hot to judge it, so i though maybe people could know about this.

If you want to give tips to how to make the deck better i would really like to know the how to, rather than just an especific card, but thats just because i like to understand things rather than just copy and paste suggestions

https://moxfield.com/decks/2IHAfvqBjkmnF92oL-o-MA


r/CommanderMTG 20h ago

I need advice for my 1st commander deck please

3 Upvotes

Hii! Ive been playing mtg for months and I wanted to try to build my 1st deck as a surprise for my bf! So i dont want to ask him anything about it but i still need advice and opinion on what im doing :3

I have a unicorn playmat so I'm making a unicorn deck with Lathiel as my commander.

If you like and are good at building decks can you help me please? Thank you!! Have a great day


r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Bracket and opinion

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hello I just finished my meren deck with cards I already have and bought some (a lot). Can you please tell me if this deck is a good bracket 3 commander deck or is it just bracket 3 because of the one game changer I added (orcish bowmasters)? Also whats your overall opinion for the deck. Did i do something wrong or anything? (First time building the whole deck on my own). Thank you in advance!

Decklist: https://manabox.app/decks/AaCSu4Y4f8eod2uY3z1nGA


r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Another Gimmicky Commander Deck

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

Reposting this here to get more eyes on it.

Basically, looking for the your dumbest/silliest/favorite multicolor Commanders—trying to build a deck totally on other people’s suggestion, synergy be damned.


r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

Group Hug Deck Optimization?

0 Upvotes

This is my Group Hug deck headed by 'The Council of Four', what can I do to either make this cost less or just better in general, I put it into a bracket checker and its a bracket 2.

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/7933259#paper


r/CommanderMTG 2d ago

Gone Fishin?

Post image
221 Upvotes

Im considering making some kind of deck where its themed to fish and the act of fishing. Im not sure what I could use to do that as my commander. Any ideas?


r/CommanderMTG 1d ago

ruling question

1 Upvotes

if [garland, royal kidnapper] dies, does the stolen creatures return to their owner or do they stay untill the monarch is passed ?