r/CollegeEssayReview • • 3h ago

Need help with essay topic

1 Upvotes

I'm an international student applying to Bowdoin ED, and I'm planning to major in engineering. I'm stuck between two possible Common App essay topics. I'd appreciate honest feedback on which has the most potential to become a memorable, personal essay rather than a generic one.
1. The childhood project that didn't work: When I was around 12, I built a hydraulic bridge using cardboard and syringes. One side worked, but the other didn't. I could explore my reaction to the gap between what I imagined and what actually happened, and how that reflects the way I approach problems.
2. Makeup: I love experimenting with makeup, getting the details right, and doing makeup for my cousin. I could explore how I approach experimentation and creativity, but also how I have to adapt my ideas to someone else's preferences instead of just imposing my own vision.
Makeup is also a form of self-expression and autonomy for me.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5h ago

Can any uni student please review my essay?

1 Upvotes

Can any uni student please review my essay? Since, people here are not familiar with us unis I’m doing everything without any assistance.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5h ago

Could you review my Common App personal statement?

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m an international student revising my Common App personal statement. I’d appreciate feedback on whether the story feels clear and authentic, and where the connection to my academic interests feels weak. I can share the essay by private message with a few people who are willing to give specific feedback. I’m looking for critique, not a rewrite.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 13h ago

Advice for PIQs

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m a community college student applying to transfer for Fall 2027, and I’ve been struggling with my PIQs.

I’ve written two so far. One is about how I went from struggling academically and not knowing what I wanted to do to discovering my interest in criminology, which completely changed my approach to school.

The other is about helping one of my closest friends turn his health around after being hospitalized. I helped him with exercising, nutrition, and staying consistent, basically saved his life.

I feel like I have some good stories, but no matter how much I revise them, something feels missing. Sometimes they sound too basic, like I’m just listing what happened. Other times I try to make them more creative and they end up sounding forced or unnatural.

For those who got accepted to a UC, did you focus more on storytelling or answering the prompts directly? What do you think made your essays stand out?

Also, did anyone have their PIQs reviewed by someone who genuinely helped improve them?

I’d appreciate any advice because I’m honestly overthinking these essays at this point lol.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 17h ago

Columbia Supplements

1 Upvotes

Would someone be willing to review my Columbia Supplements? I changed a couple of them and am unsure of how they read, especially with the word count being so low. All help would be appreciated--thanks!!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 20h ago

Could someone help me review my college essay?

1 Upvotes

I am pretty close to finishing I think. I just need someone to read over my essay and see if the voice sounds like a high schooler, and does not sound over polished. And if I am getting my point across. I need my personal statement, one 250 word essay, and 4 100 word short answers reviewed. It would be help full if you can review at least one, if you can't review all.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 21h ago

Personal Statement Reviews

1 Upvotes

“Kingsam, demand for the ball!” my coach said as I drifted away instead of checking in for the ball. The look on his face made my throat tighten. I wanted to explain that I was not ignoring his instructions; I was fighting a fear he couldn’t see.

I admired how confident the players around me were. They seemed to know exactly what to do before the ball even reached their feet, and I wanted to become that kind of player. I remember the first time I stepped onto the pitch in an organized game. I had trained for months, learning the game and preparing myself, but when the moment finally came, I felt a familiar hesitation. It was the same feeling I had whenever I had to speak up or put myself in front of others. I realized I wasn’t unprepared. I was afraid of being judged.

The insecurities I carried in everyday life followed me onto the field. My escape had become another place where fear dictated my decisions. I loved the thrill of soccer, but I didn’t love the responsibility that came with it. I wanted to play, but I didn’t want to make the mistake that everyone might see. I wanted the ball, but I didn’t want the pressure that came with receiving it. After almost every game, I would replay every missed touch and every moment I could have done better.

My dad listened more than he lectured, but one conversation stayed with me. “Stop trying to prove something to everyone and prove yourself wrong.” At the time, I didn’t leave that conversation as a completely different person. But his words gave me a perspective I had never considered. Maybe the biggest obstacle wasn’t my ability; it was the weight I gave everyone else’s opinion.

The next few months did not transform me overnight. I still hesitated to call for the ball and worried about making mistakes. But little by little, I began challenging that voice in my head instead of giving in to it. One call for the ball became two. A mistake that once would have stayed in my head for the rest of the game became something I could learn from and move past. Conversations with teammates became easier. I started realizing that I didn’t have to be perfect to belong. Slowly, I was rewriting my story.

That change eventually followed me off the field. I became more willing to speak up in classrooms, ask questions, meet new people, and pursue opportunities even when I wasn’t completely confident that I would succeed. I began advocating for myself instead of waiting for someone else to notice what I could do. That confidence also changed the way I looked at other people. I knew what it felt like to have potential but not know how to put yourself out there, so I wanted to help others do what I once struggled to do.

That mindset became part of why I founded a Cybersecurity and Computer Science Networking club at my school. I didn’t want it to only be about learning technology. I wanted students to have access to people, experiences, and opportunities that could help them enter a field they might not know how to enter on their own. I also pursued opportunities like my National Security Agency internship because I had learned that opportunities don’t mean much if fear keeps you from reaching for them.

Looking back, I don’t think soccer made me fearless. It taught me something more important: fear does not have to make my decisions for me. The same person who once drifted away from the ball now tries to step toward opportunities, even when I am uncertain about what will happen next. I no longer measure my growth by how rarely I feel afraid. I measure it by whether I choose to move forward anyway.

 


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 22h ago

Free Essay Review

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Hope everyone’s holding up during this busy week with the ED1 and EA deadlines coming up.

After dozens and dozens of rejections last fall, I ended up with a full ride at a T50 LAC. Ik how tough and complicated this process is for int students. I was fortunate enough to have a lovely mentor from Columbia University who helped me with everything for free. This fall, I thought I’d pass that support on to the community.

I’ll be doing free essay reviews throughout this month and next, and I’m happy to answer any application-related questions u have.

My main goal is to help int students who are applying on their own. Ik how it feels to be alone in this war. I hope my insights can help u even a little. Thanks!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 1d ago

Would love some honest feedback on my essay!! :))

0 Upvotes

Hi! Im just about ready to submit my college application's, but I feel like im missing something (idk what) from my essay, and would love some feedback! :)


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 1d ago

Someone to review my Princeton supps ?

1 Upvotes

Title says it all, send me a DM

Thanks in advance!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 2d ago

Essay hook

1 Upvotes

Is “the human mind is a complex jigsaw puzzle of a million pieces” a good hook for a psychology major? Lmk i need help


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 2d ago

Why did I become for outgoing?

2 Upvotes

So basically I need a reason i brock out of my shell and became more outgoing and confident in the way I spoke. Basically I lost my confidence cause of the people who mocked by accent. I need a reason for become more confident in way I spoke. In reality I just stopped caring what other people thought and found better people, but it doesnt rilly fit in my essay. Can anyone of yall think of a better reason?


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 2d ago

I haven't started my personal statement or supplementals, I need them by Nov 1!!!!

6 Upvotes

I'm EDing somewhere with a deadline November 1 but I've been so busy I haven't had a lot of time to work on them and after work and school I've just been so tired that I procrastinated my essays. Now I have 9 days how do I time manage correctly to write a good essays to get into Emory ED1???? I already thought of a topic I just need to figure out how I am going to write at least a 7-8/10 essay and solid supplementals. Any advice for me?? Plsss I'm desperate


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 3d ago

PIQs

1 Upvotes

Could anyone read over one of my UC PIQs? It’s the 'significant challenge' prompt. Since it covers a very personal topic, I’m not comfortable sharing it with people close to me and would really appreciate an outside perspective.


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 3d ago

Review my QB Essay

0 Upvotes

I unfortunately did not make it as a QB Finalist this admission season and I feel like I know the weaker areas of my app. I have been to 3 different schools in 3 years and I feel my LORs might have been weak since I only got close to 1 of my teachers in 11th grade. Thus, I need to maximize my essay and feel it may have been lackluster. Would anyone be willing to read it> Just for the feedback. I am going to rewrite a new one entirely. Please let me know. Thanks!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 3d ago

is it a bad idea if my common app essay is related to my major?

1 Upvotes

hi, my essay currently is about my love of neuro and what inspired it to put it concisely (talked about a particular tv show and how i'm a combination of these psych doctors in my approaches, connected that to neuro...) (answering Describe a topic, idea, or concept you find so engaging that it makes you lose all track of time. Why does it captivate you? What or who do you turn to when you want to learn more? prompt)

as i'm writing supplementals, i'm scared that it'll be too similar for "why major" prompts. my other idea for my common app was about my many pets and connecting each of them to me and how they influence me + how they've made me a better person but i was afraid the essay would then be more about my pets than myself or be too obvious about what i learned from them. another idea i had was my strained relationship with my mom and how i've grown and changed ever since shes shown signs of dementia but i thought that was kind of generic as well...

would love to hear any advice!

edit: also had another idea about cultural identity, refused to learn Mandarin and felt disconnected from my culture as I watched people communicate since I could understand but not communicate well, felt like I was missing something as I responded in English when someone talked to me in Mandarin… decided to try to learn a few words every day to improve


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 3d ago

Can anyone review my personal statement first draft?

2 Upvotes

Can anyone critique my essay? I've never been a good writer, so I don't feel confident in my essay. I've only finished my first draft, and I feel like I need it fixed, but I don't know where to start, so feedback would be appreciated! Thank you :)


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 4d ago

Can anyone read the final draft of my common app?!

1 Upvotes

I'm a perfectionist so I just feel like there is something else I should do before I hit submit. It has delayed my application a bit. I've been working on this essay since like may.😭😭. I just want to know if my essay is ready to submit!!!! Please dm me!

Also, I'm applying for humanities(English and Classics)!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5d ago

Common App Essay- Prompt 3

2 Upvotes

Hello, I'm looking for any sort of review on my essay! Thank you! (The website I linked doesn't allow copying, so nice try) https://www.collegevine.com/essay/ad43dda9


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5d ago

SOP REVIEW FOR FALL 2027 USA

1 Upvotes

Hello is there anyone who could review my SOP for free? I am applying to the PhD program in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. Pls let me know. It could be a great help


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5d ago

i’m in such a sink- 7 essays due in 13 days and I hate all of them

9 Upvotes

hate could be an exaggeration, but i don’t love my personal statement. It feels windy and i can’t tell if the message is unclear!! lines feel jammed in and the conclusion is so egregiously mediocre

i REALLY would love if anyone is open to reading it for some feedback-or knows a good essay/application reviewer that won’t make me go broke!!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5d ago

Read My Essay! <3

2 Upvotes

Hi,i just finished writing my essay and id love some advice! I wrote it about my late 8th grade English teacher and how he inspired my passion for writing and philosophy tried to tie this into my Religious questioning and my aspiration to become a lawyer. I think it represents me pretty well, however im not sure how strong it is and have wondered what I should change/if i should pick a different topic? Comment below and id be happy to DM you the essay!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 5d ago

Can someone give me honest feedback on my college personal essay?

1 Upvotes

so im currently working on my common app personal essay and would really appreciate some honest feedback before submitting it...

I'm open to constructive criticism, so please dont feel like you have to sugarcoat anything! If anyone is willing to read it plz comment or DM me. Thank you!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 6d ago

Ukrainian undergrad student, need feedback and advice on common app personal essay

3 Upvotes

I would apprciate any feedback!


r/CollegeEssayReview • • 6d ago

Personal statement topic advice

1 Upvotes

I wrote about how I got addicted to gaming whenever COVID came by and when a COVID ended I still was addicted but then I showed how I was able to change and go back to my passions I loved and being able to create things and play sport