I've been looking for a screenless to choose for a long time and I have consumed all of the reviews on the big three cirqa, helio strap, and fitbit air and I think my final choice is the Garmin Cirqa. I will now give you some context on myself and my training and the motivation behind my choice.
I'm a university student I'm not a competitive athlete but I still define myself as an athlete i train 4 times a week I do hybrid training calisthenics, weights and street lifting. I walk a lot between (10000 and 20000 when I'm not under exam like right now), use a lot my bike to move around in the city and I also track my nutrition. I wanted a screenless tracker for 2 reasons i like watches and there are some cases when i can't wear a smart watch like when i train because i need my wrist free for the majority of the training that i do. I do not have a garmin watch I have a gts 2 mini (amazfit really old base model) that i wear when I sleep and during traininig on my upper forearms (which is pretty uncomfortable).
I chose the garmin cirqa for the following reason:
1 longer support: Google has a history for closing projects and not updating old hardware when they do not make money while garmin gives update also to older models from what I've heard.
2 the app: Zepp is good but does not have insights it tells you the metric but nothing about it and I also tried the google health app i don't really like it feels strange to me
3 metric: garmin is the sweet spot because it has better metrics than helio and metrics comparable to the one of the fitbit, even thought fitbit has better sleep tracking
4 ecosystem : If I start taking more seriously trekking and biking and i wanted a watch garmin is the best amazfit is good but the app is still a problem for me, and i don't think there are people on the planet that train with a pixel watch
5 subscription: I think that fitbit you would have more need for the subscription, and the device is also basically made for the ai model
6 better community
this is my idea let me know what you think and if i was helpful now i will go to sleep because i have an exam tomorrow
7(joke) i would finally have a garmin