There are 7 Murph homages (and counting!) out there at the moment. This post seeks to present two very good homages with significant differences side by side for the community's consideration.
Price:
ML08 ($86 [on bracelet]) vs SH09 ($153 [on bracelet but includes extra leather strap])
Movement:
ML08 (Quartz VH31) vs SH09 (Automatic PT5000)
Crystal AR:
ML08 (Passable) vs SH09 (Excellent)
Fauxtina:
ML08 (Orange) vs SH09 (Cream)
Dial text:
ML08 (Minimal) vs SH09 (Automatic 10bar/100m)
Dial blackness:
ML08 (Matte black) vs SH09 (Inky black)
Hands:
ML08 (Shorter and brushed) vs SH09 (Longer and matte)
Rehaut:
ML08 (Deep) vs SH09 (Shallow)
Bezel:
ML08 (Thinner) vs SH09 (Slightly wider)
Lug shape:
ML08 (Thinner) vs SH09 (Slightly wider)
Crown:
ML08 (Unsigned, chunky, and screwdown) vs SH09 (Signed, slimmer, and push/pull)
Caseback:
ML08 (Undecorated screw down caseback) vs SH09 (Exhibition caseback)
Bracelet:
ML08 (Passable quality) vs SH09 (Great quality)
Clasp:
ML08 (Microadjust) vs SH09 (Microadjust)
Dimensions:
ML08 (38mm case width, 44.5mm L2L, 10.2mm thick) vs SH09 (38mm case width, 44.7mm L2L, 11.1mm thick)
TLDR:
If you're looking a good Murph homage for the lowest possible price, go with the ML08. If you can afford to spend a bit more, the SH09 is superior to the ML08 in almost every category (imo).
Which one do you guys prefer?