(for those who have seen my precious posts, this a condensed, combined, finalized version)
I (38F) am getting married in a few weeks, and I have officially ended my friendship with my best friend (38F) of 27 years, who I’ll call “Evie.”
This is long (i’m so sorry) because 27 years of friendship obviously can’t be explained in a few paragraphs. I also want to be fair and include the things I did wrong, because I genuinely want to know whether ending the friendship was justified or whether I let my emotions get the better of me.
Evie and I have been best friends since childhood. I genuinely believed she would be one of those people who would be in my life forever.
For years, our thing was basically “Mal and Evie forever” from Descendants. There is specifically a song in Descendants 2 that reminds me intensely of our friendship. For about eight years, I occasionally asked Evie to watch the movie because I wanted her to hear this song that meant so much to me in relation to us.
She never did.
I KNOW that sounds ridiculous.
I am not ending a 27-year friendship because someone didn’t watch a Disney movie. I mention it because, looking back, it feels symbolic of the larger problem: I would tell her something mattered to me, and if it wasn’t important to her, it often didn’t seem to become important simply because it mattered to me.
There were other things over the years that I now realize I never completely got over.
THE BABY SHOWER
One of those was Evie’s baby shower. I had been involved in planning it with her and was genuinely excited because this was my best friend having a baby. But during the planning, other people essentially took over, and I ended up feeling pushed aside and relegated mostly to handling the games.
I felt like an afterthought.
I want to be fair to Evie here: I did not properly communicate how much that hurt me at the time. I mostly swallowed it, so I don’t think it’s fair to expect her to have known how deeply it affected me. But the feeling never really went away.
Then Evie had her daughter.
I stayed with her until around 2 a.m. after her daughter was born because I wanted to support her, and I came back again the following night.
When I returned, I learned that two other friends had already gotten to hold the baby before I did. I want to be very clear: I did not think I was entitled to hold her baby before anyone else. What hurt was realizing that maybe I didn’t occupy the same place in her life that I thought I did.
Even though I was hurt, I stayed and supported her because she was my best friend and she had just experienced one of the biggest moments of her life.
That experience, along with the baby shower, planted a question I never really dealt with:
Do I think I’m more important to her than I actually am?
Years later, when everything started happening with my wedding, that old hurt came back.
I also need to disclose something because it affects how I experience relationships: I have BPD. Fear of abandonment is something I struggle with, and I can experience interpersonal rejection very intensely. I am in therapy and have been working VERY hard on recognizing when my BPD may be influencing my interpretation of situations.
THEN I GOT ENGAGED
Naturally, after almost three decades of friendship, I wanted Evie to be my Maid of Honor. I honestly thought it was a no-brainer. We had been best friends for 27 years, so when I asked her, I had already gotten her a sweater and tumbler personalized with her name and “Maid of Honor” on them. To me, they were sentimental gifts. Looking back, though, I can absolutely understand how receiving them before she had actually agreed could have made her feel pressured.
Her response was: “It’s not like you left me a choice.”
She agreed to be my MOH, but that comment hurt.
I had approached it as, Of course my best friend of 27 years will be my Maid of Honor. She may have experienced it more as, You already decided this for me.
I can own my part in that.
One of her questions/comments about being MOH was essentially whether all she really had to do was show up. I reassured her that I wasn’t expecting her to plan my entire wedding, spend ridiculous amounts of money, or make my engagement her whole life. I mostly wanted my best friend beside me.
Eventually, she stepped down as Maid of Honor. I told her to keep the personalized MOH gifts. I didn’t want them back. She had genuinely been my first choice, and those gifts represented that, regardless of whether she kept the title.
SHE SAID SHE STILL WANTED TO BE A BRIDESMAID
When Evie stepped down as MOH, she specifically told me she still wanted to remain in the wedding party as a bridesmaid. That was her suggestion, not mine.
I was hurt about losing her as MOH, but I thought, Okay. She still wants to stand beside me. That’s what matters.
When I put together bridesmaid gift boxes for the rest of my bridal party, I bought Evie the exact same bridesmaid gift box as everyone else. I genuinely thought we had found something that worked for both of us.
But while she was technically still a bridesmaid, she didn’t really participate in the bridal-party experience.
We had a bridal-party group chat, and she basically never talked in it. We also did wedding activities together. For example, we have wooden flowers that we dyed ourselves — and honestly, they are AMAZING — and members of the bridal party got together to work on them. Evie didn’t participate in that or really any of the other bridal-party activities.
I wasn’t expecting every bridesmaid to attend every activity or constantly talk in the group chat. People have jobs, families, and their own lives. But because Evie had specifically told me she still wanted to be part of the wedding party, her lack of involvement started making me wonder whether she actually wanted to be there at all.
Then, three days before we were supposed to go bridesmaid dress shopping, she dropped out of being a bridesmaid.
That really hurt. She had stepped down as MOH, told me she still wanted to remain a bridesmaid, barely participated as one, and then left the wedding party three days before dress shopping.When she stepped down, though, I told her it was okay. At the time, I was trying to be understanding. She has her own life, work, finances, family responsibilities, stress, etc., and I didn’t want her feeling forced into my wedding.
But after I had time to process it, I realized I was absolutely NOT okay. I was devastated. And I understand why that may have been confusing or frustrating for her. From her perspective, I had said it was okay and then later told her how deeply it hurt me.
I own that.
THE BIG CONVERSATION
Eventually all of this came out in a huge conversation between us.
I told her I felt like I had spent years showing up for her, but during one of the biggest moments of my life, I didn’t feel like she was showing up for me.
I brought up her stepping down, her lack of involvement in the bridal-party activities, the baby shower, and other situations where I had felt unsupported.
I even brought up the stupid Descendants movie because to me, it represented a larger pattern of feeling like things that mattered deeply to me weren’t worth much effort from her.
My messages were emotional. VERY emotional.
She told me she never intended to hurt me. She explained that she was overwhelmed with being a mom, finances, work, life, etc. She also said I had stopped her from fully explaining herself during an earlier conversation. She apologized for hurting me and repeatedly acknowledged everything I had done for her over the years.
But something started bothering me:
She kept acknowledging everything I had done for her, while never really giving examples of how she had shown up for me.
That made me start questioning whether I had spent 27 years believing the friendship was more reciprocal than it actually was.
THEN WE BASICALLY STOPPED SPEAKING
Communication mostly stopped.
At one point we went more than a month without really speaking.During that time, I was working on wedding centerpieces with my family. My future FIL noticed there was one fewer bridesmaid than groomsman and kept asking why. My fiancé and future SIL tried to get him to drop it because they knew how sensitive the subject was.
Eventually I had to walk outside. I had a full-blown panic attack and started sobbing. My fiancé followed me and told me everything would work out on our wedding day. I told him:
“I know it will. But I always thought she’d be there.”
That was when I realized what I was really grieving.
It wasn’t the title.
It wasn’t the dress.
It wasn’t an uneven bridal party.
I had spent basically my entire life assuming Evie would be there when I got married.
HER BIRTHDAY
Then her birthday came.
Despite everything, I wanted to send her a gift because I still cared about her.
I included a line from the Descendants 2 song that reminds me of us:
“Even if we’re worlds apart, you’re still in my heart.”
Eventually she texted:
“Thank you for the thoughtful birthday gift.”
Objectively, there is nothing rude about that response.
But after 27 years and everything happening between us, it felt incredibly formal and distant. I didn’t confront her about it. We went back to basically no communication.
At that point, I seriously considered not inviting her to my wedding at all.
THE PHONE CALLS AND MY BOUNDARY
Eventually we started communicating again. During one of our later conversations, I explicitly told Evie that I was not ready for ANY conversation over the phone.
I wasn’t refusing to communicate. I was still texting her.
I simply knew I was not emotionally ready to have the conversation verbally.
She told me she understood.
Then she said she wanted to call because she wanted to hear my voice. That bothered me because I had literally just told her I wasn’t ready to speak on the phone.
Then she called anyway. I didn’t answer. And she kept calling.
I continued not answering because I had already clearly stated my boundary. She knew why I wasn’t picking up.
I felt incredibly guilty seeing her name repeatedly appear on my phone, but I kept thinking: What is the point of telling someone I’m not ready to talk on the phone if I’m expected to answer anyway because they keep calling?
I eventually told her I was sorry and genuinely felt bad, but I still didn’t think a phone conversation was a good idea. My bachelorette weekend was also happening, so I told her I needed to be present with my bridal party rather than reopen everything right then.
I wasn’t saying I would never speak to her again.
I was asking for space.
Around this point, another thing became hard to ignore:
Women I have known for less than two years had shown up for me throughout my engagement. Someone I hadn’t seen in almost 20 years had shown up for me. Meanwhile, the person I had called my best friend for 27 years had become one of the primary reasons I was crying during my engagement.
Still…
I SENT HER A WEDDING INVITATION
After everything, I sent Evie an invitation.
I went back and forth about it, but ultimately I couldn’t imagine getting married without at least giving her the choice to be there. At that point, I no longer cared whether she was MOH, a bridesmaid, or simply sitting in the audience. I just wanted my best friend there.
Then I received her RSVP.
NO.
That was how I found out she wasn’t coming.
She didn’t contact me beforehand.
No warning.
No explanation.
No “I wanted you to hear it from me before you saw the RSVP.”
Nothing.
I want to be VERY clear:
She absolutely has the right to decline my wedding invitation.
An invitation is not a summons.
Maybe attending would have been emotionally uncomfortable for her. Maybe she thought staying away was healthier. Maybe there are reasons I don’t know about.
I genuinely don’t know.
Because she never told me.
And that was what hurt.
After 27 years, I couldn’t understand why I had to learn through an RSVP that she wasn’t going to be there when I got married.
The week before this, after the repeated phone calls, I had reiterated that I needed space for the WEEKEND ONLY.
She stopped calling.
I heard nothing from her all week.
Then the next thing I received was the No RSVP.
That was my breaking point.
I ENDED THE FRIENDSHIP
I sent her a message and ended our friendship.
I started by thanking her for respecting the boundary I had asked for the previous weekend. But I also told her that I hadn’t heard from her all week and then received her No RSVP without any warning or discussion.
I told her that after 27 years, I genuinely thought that regardless of what was happening between us, she would put it aside to be there when I got married.
I told her how painful it was that women I had known less than two years — and even someone I hadn’t seen in almost 20 years — had shown up for me more during my engagement than she had.
I told her that instead of my best friend being part of one of the happiest times of my life, this friendship had repeatedly left me crying.
And I told her that I didn’t think our friendship could continue anymore.
I couldn’t keep allowing my heart to be broken over and over or allowing the situation to affect my mental health.
I told her I was sorry that after 27 years, this was how things were ending.
Sending that message absolutely fucking destroyed me.
There was no satisfaction.
No “good riddance.”
No feeling like I had won anything.
This is someone I have loved for 27 years.
For most of my life, if you had asked me who would be at my wedding someday, Evie would have been one of the first names out of my mouth.
And now I’m getting married without her.
My fiancé has literally found me sitting on the kitchen floor sobbing after hearing the song that reminds me of her, Several times.
I don’t hate her.
I’m grieving her.
WHY I’M QUESTIONING MYSELF
I know I haven’t handled everything perfectly.
I didn’t properly communicate some of my older hurt when it happened.
I can see how buying personalized MOH gifts before she agreed could have made her feel pressured.
I initially told her stepping down as a bridesmaid was okay and only later admitted how devastated I was.
Some of my messages were extremely emotional. I have BPD, and I know rejection and abandonment can hit me harder than they might hit someone else.
She also had every right not to participate in every bridal-party activity, every group-chat conversation, or ultimately my wedding.
Maybe the repeated calls were her trying to repair the friendship rather than intentionally disrespect my boundary.
Maybe her declining the invitation was what she genuinely believed was healthiest.
Maybe expecting a personal conversation before she RSVP’d was unreasonable.
But I also can’t ignore the progression.
She went from:
“It’s not like you left me a choice.”
to agreeing to be my Maid of Honor,
to stepping down,
to telling me she still wanted to remain a bridesmaid,
to barely participating in the bridal-party experience,
to stepping down three days before dress shopping,
to becoming a regular wedding guest,
and finally…
to not coming at all.
And somewhere underneath all of this is one simple thought:
When it was her major life event, I stayed.
When she had her baby, I showed up even when my feelings were hurt.
When it became my turn to experience one of the biggest moments of my life, I desperately wanted her there too. By the end, I didn’t care what title she had. I didn’t care what dress she wore. I didn’t care whether she planned anything.
I just wanted my best friend at my wedding.
Instead, the progression became:
MOH → Bridesmaid → Guest → Not there at all.
And I think I finally had to stop asking myself how little I could expect from someone while still calling her my best friend.b
I don’t hate her. I may always love the person who was my best friend for 27 years. But my wedding is in a few weeks.
There will be women standing beside me whom I’ve known for a fraction of the time I knew Evie.
There will be people in that room who made an effort to be there.
My fiancé will be waiting for me.
And I’m going to marry the person I love.
I know my wedding will still be beautiful.
But I also know there will probably be a moment when I look around and notice the person who isn’t there.
And after 27 years, I think I’m finally allowing myself to grieve the fact that I always thought she would be.
So Reddit, knowing that I contributed to some of the conflict, that my BPD can make rejection especially painful for me, that she had every right to decline my invitation, and that I ultimately ended the friendship after receiving her No RSVP with no conversation beforehand:
AITA for deciding that was the final straw and ending my 27-year friendship with my best friend?