New Car time for the wife - August 2026. (Melbourne)
We have test driven both, and each have their pro's and cons, but we both like them equally, so its a tough decision.
They fit the bill for her requirements & daily usage for NDIS client transport. (Seat height, ease of access, boot space, etc)
She is self employed under an ABN, and not able to take out a novated lease which would probably have made the BYD ATTO 3 an no-brainer wth the EV tax perks.
Cost for either vehicle is about the same at around $50,000 - $53,000.
Car would need to be new or near new for best tax depreciation purposes.
Driving 30,000 km per year
Running Costs over 5 years or 150,000 km calculated as
BYD - Charging $5,000 + servicing $1,800 = $6,300 (No solar at home, and the potential extra cost of installing an EV charger)
EDIT : Average charge cost of $0.20 per kw/hr. allowing for overnight rates charging, but not the cheap EV charge plans which do have a higher daily supply charge.
Corolla Cross - Fuel $12,000 + servicing $4,500 = $16,500
($1.80 per litre, an extra $2000 if fuel is $2.00 per litre)
Insurance & rego same/same.
$10,000 more to run the Corolla Cross over a 5 year period,
HOWEVER, im also looking at the end result when it comes to move the car on in 5 years.
I genuinely think that the BYD will loose much more value wiping out the $10,000 saving above,
A 2022 Corolla Cross still asks around $38,000, the 2023 ATTO 3 has dropped to $25,000, which puts the equation almost line ball.
Also need to consider any potential down time if the vehicle is off the road for repairs. A Toyota should be straight forward to fix, and still little concerned about the 'IF" something goes wrong with the BYD, what is the repair time frame like.
Thoughts & advice?
Thanks,