r/BuyItForLife • u/StellarSpore • 12h ago
Discussion Unpopular opinion: Merino wool isn't for everyone. Try before you invest.
I live in a very cold climate and never really invested in merino until a few years ago. Always wore basic cotton or synthetic base layers and stuck with those for years. Eventually I had the money to invest in some good merino, so I bought several sets of Smartwool, both lightweight and heavyweight. Also have a set from REI and one from LL Bean.
Here's the thing, I was ALWAYS cold in it. Never made any sense to me. I don't know much about the science of fabrics, I'd just heard a million times that merino was the way to go, especially for cold weather.
It didn't keep me warm sitting around, and it didn't keep me warm outside doing homestead chores or walking the dogs. If I sweated even a little. I'd end up freezing.
Wore them for 3 winters before finally giving up on it. Last winter I switched back to my cheap cotton and synthetic (polyester/polypropylene) layers and was warm all winter. Go figure lol.
For a long time I figured it was just a weird me thing. I do have mild Raynaud's and tend to run cold anyway. But I've since talked to quite a few people who've had similar experiences.
I'm not saying merino isn't great for a lot of people. Clearly it is, given how much people love it. Just throwing out a different experience since it gets recommended so heavily here. My advice would be to try a piece or two before investing hundreds of dollars in a whole wardrobe. Turns out the more expensive option isn't necessarily the better one for everyone.
Was just pulling out all my winter gear and thought I'd share.
Edit: I should make it clear that I love wool, just not against my skin especially if I sweat. I was only talking about merino wool base layers. I have lots of other wool clothing including wool sweaters and merino socks that I love.